Skip to main content
Back to 3D Geometry
JEE Main 2021
3D Geometry
3D Geometry
Easy

Question

Consider the three planes P 1 : 3x + 15y + 21z = 9, P 2 : x - 3y - z = 5, and P 3 : 2x + 10y + 14z = 5 Then, which one of the following is true?

Options

Solution

1. Key Concepts and Formulas

  • Normal Vector of a Plane: For a plane given by the general equation Ax+By+Cz=DAx + By + Cz = D, its normal vector, denoted as n\vec{n}, is (A,B,C)(A, B, C). This vector is perpendicular to the plane.
  • Condition for Parallel Planes: Two planes are parallel if and only if their normal vectors are parallel. This means that if n1=(A1,B1,C1)\vec{n_1} = (A_1, B_1, C_1) and n2=(A2,B2,C2)\vec{n_2} = (A_2, B_2, C_2) are the normal vectors of two planes, then they are parallel if their components are proportional: A1A2=B1B2=C1C2=k\frac{A_1}{A_2} = \frac{B_1}{B_2} = \frac{C_1}{C_2} = k for some non-zero constant kk. If the normal vectors are parallel, the planes are either distinct parallel planes or coincident (the same) planes.
  • Distinguishing Parallel and Coincident Planes: If the normal vectors are parallel (i.e., A1A2=B1B2=C1C2=k\frac{A_1}{A_2} = \frac{B_1}{B_2} = \frac{C_1}{C_2} = k), then:
    • The planes are distinct parallel planes if D1D2k\frac{D_1}{D_2} \neq k.
    • The planes are coincident planes if D1D2=k\frac{D_1}{D_2} = k.

2. Step-by-Step Solution

Step 1: Identify the Equations of the Planes and their Normal Vectors

We are given the equations of three planes. Our first step is to extract their normal vectors and, for ease of comparison, simplify them by dividing by any common factors.

  • Plane P1P_1: 3x+15y+21z=93x + 15y + 21z = 9

    • The normal vector is n1=(3,15,21)\vec{n_1} = (3, 15, 21).
    • To simplify, we can divide each component by 3: n1=(1,5,7)\vec{n_1}' = (1, 5, 7).
    • The original equation can be simplified by dividing by 3: x+5y+7z=3x + 5y + 7z = 3. Here, D1=3D_1' = 3.
  • Plane P2P_2: x3yz=5x - 3y - z = 5

    • The normal vector is n2=(1,3,1)\vec{n_2} = (1, -3, -1).
    • This vector cannot be simplified further. Here, D2=5D_2 = 5.
  • Plane P3P_3: 2x+10y+14z=52x + 10y + 14z = 5

    • The normal vector is n3=(2,10,14)\vec{n_3} = (2, 10, 14).
    • To simplify, we can divide each component by 2: n3=(1,5,7)\vec{n_3}' = (1, 5, 7).
    • The original equation can be simplified by dividing by 2: x+5y+7z=52x + 5y + 7z = \frac{5}{2}. Here, D3=52D_3' = \frac{5}{2}.

Step 2: Compare Normal Vectors for Parallelism

We will now compare the simplified normal vectors for each pair of planes to determine if they are parallel.

  • Comparing P1P_1 and P2P_2:

    • We compare n1=(1,5,7)\vec{n_1}' = (1, 5, 7) and n2=(1,3,1)\vec{n_2} = (1, -3, -1).
    • Let's check the ratios of corresponding components: A1A2=11=1\frac{A_1'}{A_2} = \frac{1}{1} = 1 B1B2=53=53\frac{B_1'}{B_2} = \frac{5}{-3} = -\frac{5}{3} C1C2=71=7\frac{C_1'}{C_2} = \frac{7}{-1} = -7
    • Since these ratios (11, 53-\frac{5}{3}, and 7-7) are not equal, the normal vectors n1\vec{n_1} and n2\vec{n_2} are not parallel.
    • Therefore, planes P1P_1 and P2P_2 are not parallel.
  • Comparing P1P_1 and P3P_3:

    • We compare n1=(1,5,7)\vec{n_1}' = (1, 5, 7) and n3=(1,5,7)\vec{n_3}' = (1, 5, 7).
    • We observe that n1=n3\vec{n_1}' = \vec{n_3}'. This means their normal vectors are identical, which implies they are parallel (with a proportionality constant k=1k=1).
    • Since their normal vectors are parallel, planes P1P_1 and P3P_3 are parallel.
    • Next, we check if they are distinct parallel planes or coincident planes by comparing their constant terms (DD values) from their simplified equations:
      • For P1P_1: x+5y+7z=3    D1=3x + 5y + 7z = 3 \implies D_1' = 3.
      • For P3P_3: x+5y+7z=52    D3=52x + 5y + 7z = \frac{5}{2} \implies D_3' = \frac{5}{2}.
    • Since D1=3D_1' = 3 and D3=52D_3' = \frac{5}{2}, and 3523 \neq \frac{5}{2}, the planes P1P_1 and P3P_3 are parallel but distinct.
  • Comparing P2P_2 and P3P_3:

    • We compare n2=(1,3,1)\vec{n_2} = (1, -3, -1) and n3=(1,5,7)\vec{n_3}' = (1, 5, 7).
    • Let's check the ratios of corresponding components: A2A3=11=1\frac{A_2}{A_3'} = \frac{1}{1} = 1 B2B3=35=35\frac{B_2}{B_3'} = \frac{-3}{5} = -\frac{3}{5} C2C3=17=17\frac{C_2}{C_3'} = \frac{-1}{7} = -\frac{1}{7}
    • Since these ratios (11, 35-\frac{3}{5}, and 17-\frac{1}{7}) are not equal, the normal vectors n2\vec{n_2} and n3\vec{n_3} are not parallel.
    • Therefore, planes P2P_2 and P3P_3 are not parallel.

Step 3: Evaluate the Options

Based on our detailed analysis:

  • (A) P1P_1 and P2P_2 are parallel. (False)
  • (B) P1P_1, P2P_2 and P3P_3 all are parallel. (False, as not all pairs are parallel)
  • (C) P1P_1 and P3P_3 are parallel. (True)
  • (D) P2P_2 and P3P_3 are parallel. (False)

Our mathematical derivation clearly shows that planes P1P_1 and P3P_3 are parallel. This corresponds to option (C).

3. Common Mistakes & Tips

  • Always Simplify Normal Vectors: Before comparing, simplify the components of each normal vector by dividing by their greatest common divisor. This makes it easier to spot proportionality.
  • Check All Components: For two vectors to be parallel, the ratios of all three corresponding components (A/AA/A', B/BB/B', C/CC/C') must be equal. If even one ratio differs, the vectors are not parallel.
  • Distinguish Parallel from Coincident: If the normal vectors are parallel, remember to check the proportionality of the constant terms (D/DD/D') using the scaled equations. This step determines if the planes are distinct or coincident.

4. Summary

To determine if planes are parallel, the key is to examine their normal vectors. If the normal vectors are parallel (i.e., their components are proportional), then the planes are parallel. We systematically extracted the normal vectors for the three given planes, simplified them, and compared them pairwise. Our analysis revealed that the normal vectors for P1P_1 and P3P_3 are proportional (in fact, identical after simplification), indicating that these two planes are parallel. A subsequent check of their constant terms confirmed that they are distinct parallel planes. No other pair of planes had parallel normal vectors. Therefore, the only true statement among the options is that P1P_1 and P3P_3 are parallel.

The final answer is C\boxed{C}.

Practice More 3D Geometry Questions

View All Questions