Skip to main content
Back to 3D Geometry
JEE Main 2023
3D Geometry
3D Geometry
Easy

Question

If the two lines l1:x23=y+12,z=2{l_1}:{{x - 2} \over 3} = {{y + 1} \over {-2}},\,z = 2 and l2:x11=2y+3α=z+52{l_2}:{{x - 1} \over 1} = {{2y + 3} \over \alpha } = {{z + 5} \over 2} are perpendicular, then an angle between the lines l 2 and l3:1x3=2y14=z4{l_3}:{{1 - x} \over 3} = {{2y - 1} \over { - 4}} = {z \over 4} is :

Options

Solution

1. Key Concepts and Formulas

To solve this problem, we'll utilize the following fundamental concepts regarding lines in three-dimensional space:

  • Standard (Symmetric) Form of a Line: A line passing through a point (x1,y1,z1)(x_1, y_1, z_1) and having direction ratios (a,b,c)(a, b, c) is represented as: xx1a=yy1b=zz1c{{x - x_1} \over a} = {{y - y_1} \over b} = {{z - z_1} \over c} The vector d=(a,b,c)\vec{d} = (a, b, c) is known as the direction vector of the line. It indicates the direction in which the line extends. It is crucial that the coefficients of x,y,zx, y, z in the numerator are 11.

  • Condition for Perpendicular Lines: Two lines are perpendicular if and only if their direction vectors are orthogonal. If the direction vectors are d1=(a1,b1,c1)\vec{d_1} = (a_1, b_1, c_1) and d2=(a2,b2,c2)\vec{d_2} = (a_2, b_2, c_2), then their dot product must be zero: d1d2=a1a2+b1b2+c1c2=0\vec{d_1} \cdot \vec{d_2} = a_1 a_2 + b_1 b_2 + c_1 c_2 = 0

  • Angle Between Two Lines: The acute angle θ\theta between two lines with direction vectors d1=(a1,b1,c1)\vec{d_1} = (a_1, b_1, c_1) and d2=(a2,b2,c2)\vec{d_2} = (a_2, b_2, c_2) is given by the formula: cosθ=d1d2d1d2=a1a2+b1b2+c1c2a12+b12+c12a22+b22+c22\cos \theta = {{|\vec{d_1} \cdot \vec{d_2}|} \over {||\vec{d_1}|| \cdot ||\vec{d_2}||}} = {{|a_1 a_2 + b_1 b_2 + c_1 c_2|} \over {\sqrt{a_1^2 + b_1^2 + c_1^2} \sqrt{a_2^2 + b_2^2 + c_2^2}}} We use the absolute value in the numerator to ensure we find the acute angle between the lines (i.e., θ[0,π/2]\theta \in [0, \pi/2]).

2. Step-by-Step Solution

Step 1: Standardize Line Equations and Identify Direction Vectors

The first crucial step is to rewrite all line equations in their standard symmetric form to correctly identify their direction vectors. This is essential because the direction ratios directly correspond to the denominators in the standard form after ensuring the numerators are (xx1)(x-x_1), (yy1)(y-y_1), and (zz1)(z-z_1).

  • For line l1l_1: l1:x23=y+12,z=2{l_1}:{{x - 2} \over 3} = {{y + 1} \over {-2}},\,z = 2

    • Reasoning: The condition z=2z=2 implies that the zz-coordinate is constant along the line. This means the line lies in the plane z=2z=2, and any change in zz along the line is zero. In the standard form, this translates to a zz-direction ratio of 00, which can be written as {{z - 2} \over 0}}.
    • Rewriting l1l_1 in standard form: x23=y(1)2=z20{{x - 2} \over 3} = {{y - (-1)} \over {-2}} = {{z - 2} \over 0}
    • The direction vector for l1l_1 is d1=(3,2,0)\vec{d_1} = (3, -2, 0).
  • For line l2l_2: l2:x11=2y+3α=z+52{l_2}:{{x - 1} \over 1} = {{2y + 3} \over \alpha } = {{z + 5} \over 2}

    • Reasoning: The term {{2y + 3} \over \alpha }} is not in the standard form {{y - y_1} \over b}} because the coefficient of yy in the numerator is 22, not 11. We must factor out the coefficient of yy from the numerator and adjust the denominator accordingly.
    • Rewrite the yy-term: 2y+3α=2(y+32)α=y+32α2{{2y + 3} \over \alpha } = {{2(y + {3 \over 2})} \over \alpha } = {{y + {3 \over 2}} \over {{\alpha \over 2}}}
    • Rewriting l2l_2 in standard form: x11=y(32)α2=z(5)2{{x - 1} \over 1} = {{y - (-{3 \over 2})} \over {{\alpha \over 2}}} = {{z - (-5)} \over 2}
    • The direction vector for l2l_2 is d2=(1,α2,2)\vec{d_2} = (1, {\alpha \over 2}, 2).
  • For line l3l_3: l3:1x3=2y14=z4{l_3}:{{1 - x} \over 3} = {{2y - 1} \over { - 4}} = {z \over 4}

    • Reasoning: Similar to l2l_2, the terms {{1 - x} \over 3}} and 2y14{{2y - 1} \over { - 4}} are not in standard form. For the xx-term, we need xx1x - x_1, so we factor out 1-1. For the yy-term, we factor out 22.
    • Rewrite the xx-term: 1x3=(x1)3=x13{{1 - x} \over 3} = {{-(x - 1)} \over 3} = {{x - 1} \over {-3}}
    • Rewrite the yy-term: 2y14=2(y12)4=y1242=y122{{2y - 1} \over { - 4}} = {{2(y - {1 \over 2})} \over { - 4}} = {{y - {1 \over 2}} \over { - {4 \over 2}}} = {{y - {1 \over 2}} \over {-2}}
    • The zz-term z/4z/4 is already in standard form, (z0)/4(z-0)/4.
    • Rewriting l3l_3 in standard form: x13=y122=z04{{x - 1} \over {-3}} = {{y - {1 \over 2}} \over {-2}} = {{z - 0} \over 4}
    • The direction vector for l3l_3 is d3=(3,2,4)\vec{d_3} = (-3, -2, 4).

Step 2: Use the Perpendicularity Condition of l1l_1 and l2l_2 to Find α\alpha

We are given that lines l1l_1 and l2l_2 are perpendicular. We will use the condition d1d2=0\vec{d_1} \cdot \vec{d_2} = 0 to find the value of α\alpha.

  • Direction vector of l1l_1: d1=(3,2,0)\vec{d_1} = (3, -2, 0)

  • Direction vector of l2l_2: d2=(1,α2,2)\vec{d_2} = (1, {\alpha \over 2}, 2)

  • Apply the perpendicularity condition: d1d2=(3)(1)+(2)(α2)+(0)(2)=0\vec{d_1} \cdot \vec{d_2} = (3)(1) + (-2)\left({\alpha \over 2}\right) + (0)(2) = 0 3α+0=03 - \alpha + 0 = 0 3α=03 - \alpha = 0 α=3\alpha = 3

  • Now we have the complete direction vector for l2l_2: d2=(1,32,2)\vec{d_2} = (1, {3 \over 2}, 2).

Step 3: Calculate the Angle Between Lines l2l_2 and l3l_3

Now that we have the value of α\alpha, we can find the angle between l2l_2 and l3l_3 using their direction vectors d2\vec{d_2} and d3\vec{d_3}.

  • Direction vector of l2l_2: d2=(1,32,2)\vec{d_2} = (1, {3 \over 2}, 2)

  • Direction vector of l3l_3: d3=(3,2,4)\vec{d_3} = (-3, -2, 4)

  • Calculate the dot product d2d3\vec{d_2} \cdot \vec{d_3}: d2d3=(1)(3)+(32)(2)+(2)(4)\vec{d_2} \cdot \vec{d_3} = (1)(-3) + \left({3 \over 2}\right)(-2) + (2)(4) =33+8= -3 - 3 + 8 =2= 2

  • Calculate the magnitude of d2\vec{d_2} (d2||\vec{d_2}||): d2=12+(32)2+22||\vec{d_2}|| = \sqrt{1^2 + \left({3 \over 2}\right)^2 + 2^2} =1+94+4= \sqrt{1 + {9 \over 4} + 4} =44+94+164= \sqrt{{4 \over 4} + {9 \over 4} + {16 \over 4}} =294=292= \sqrt{{29 \over 4}} = {{\sqrt{29}} \over 2}

  • Calculate the magnitude of d3\vec{d_3} (d3||\vec{d_3}||): d3=(3)2+(2)2+42||\vec{d_3}|| = \sqrt{(-3)^2 + (-2)^2 + 4^2} =9+4+16= \sqrt{9 + 4 + 16} =29= \sqrt{29}

  • Apply the angle formula cosθ=d2d3d2d3\cos \theta = {{|\vec{d_2} \cdot \vec{d_3}|} \over {||\vec{d_2}|| \cdot ||\vec{d_3}||}}: cosθ=2(292)(29)\cos \theta = {{|2|} \over {\left({{\sqrt{29}} \over 2}\right) (\sqrt{29})}} cosθ=2292\cos \theta = {{2} \over {{29} \over 2}} cosθ=2×229\cos \theta = {{2 \times 2} \over 29} cosθ=429\cos \theta = {{4} \over {29}}

  • Therefore, the angle θ\theta between lines l2l_2 and l3l_3 is: θ=cos1(429)\theta = {\cos ^{ - 1}}\left( {{4 \over {29}}} \right)

Step 4: Compare with Options and Final Answer

We found the angle between lines l2l_2 and l3l_3 to be θ=cos1(429)\theta = {\cos ^{ - 1}}\left( {{4 \over {29}}} \right). Let's check the given options:

(A) cos1(294){\cos ^{ - 1}}\left( {{{29} \over 4}} \right) (B) sec1(294){\sec ^{ - 1}}\left( {{{29} \over 4}} \right) (C) cos1(229){\cos ^{ - 1}}\left( {{2 \over {29}}} \right) (D) cos1(229){\cos ^{ - 1}}\left( {{2 \over {\sqrt {29} }}} \right)

Our calculated value is cosθ=4/29\cos \theta = 4/29. Recall that secθ=1/cosθ\sec \theta = 1/\cos \theta. So, secθ=1/(4/29)=29/4\sec \theta = 1 / (4/29) = 29/4. Therefore, θ=sec1(294)\theta = {\sec ^{ - 1}}\left( {{{29} \over 4}} \right).

This precisely matches option (B). Note that option (A) is mathematically impossible for a real angle since the cosine of any real angle must be between -1 and 1, and 29/4>129/4 > 1.

3. Common Mistakes & Tips

  • Always Standardize: The most frequent error is failing to convert line equations to their standard symmetric form (xx1/a=yy1/b=zz1/cx-x_1 / a = y-y_1 / b = z-z_1 / c) before identifying direction ratios. Always ensure the coefficients of x,y,zx, y, z in the numerator are +1+1. If they are not (e.g., 1x1-x or 2y+32y+3), factor out the coefficient and adjust the denominator.
  • Constant Coordinate: If a coordinate is constant (e.g., z=kz=k), its corresponding direction ratio is 00. This implies the line is perpendicular to that axis (e.g., z=kz=k means the line is perpendicular to the zz-axis and parallel to the xyxy-plane).
  • Acute Angle: The formula for cosθ\cos \theta includes an absolute value in the numerator, ensuring that the calculated angle is the acute angle (0θπ/20 \le \theta \le \pi/2).

4. Summary

This problem required a systematic approach to 3D geometry. First, we correctly converted all given line equations into their standard symmetric form to extract their direction vectors. Then, we utilized the perpendicularity condition for lines l1l_1 and l2l_2 to determine the unknown parameter α\alpha. Finally, with all direction vectors known, we applied the formula for the angle between two lines to find the desired angle between l2l_2 and l3l_3. The calculated cosine of the angle was 4/294/29, which corresponds to an angle of sec1(29/4)\sec^{-1}(29/4).

The final answer is (B)\boxed{\text{(B)}}.

Practice More 3D Geometry Questions

View All Questions