Skip to main content
Back to 3D Geometry
JEE Main 2021
3D Geometry
3D Geometry
Hard

Question

Let the line L pass through (1,1,1)(1,1,1) and intersect the lines x12=y+13=z14\frac{x-1}{2}=\frac{y+1}{3}=\frac{z-1}{4} and x31=y42=z1\frac{x-3}{1}=\frac{y-4}{2}=\frac{z}{1}. Then, which of the following points lies on the line LL ?

Options

Solution

1. Key Concepts and Formulas

  • Parametric Form of a Line: A point on a line passing through (x0,y0,z0)(x_0, y_0, z_0) with direction ratios (a,b,c)(a, b, c) can be represented as (x0+aλ,y0+bλ,z0+cλ)(x_0 + a\lambda, y_0 + b\lambda, z_0 + c\lambda) for some parameter λ\lambda.
  • Collinearity of Three Points: Three points P(x1,y1,z1)P(x_1,y_1,z_1), A(x2,y2,z2)A(x_2,y_2,z_2), and B(x3,y3,z3)B(x_3,y_3,z_3) are collinear if the direction ratios of the line segment PAPA are proportional to the direction ratios of the line segment PBPB. Mathematically, this means x2x1x3x1=y2y1y3y1=z2z1z3z1\frac{x_2-x_1}{x_3-x_1} = \frac{y_2-y_1}{y_3-y_1} = \frac{z_2-z_1}{z_3-z_1}, provided the denominators are non-zero. If any denominator is zero, the corresponding numerator must also be zero.
  • Equation of a Line Passing Through Two Points: The equation of a line passing through two points (x1,y1,z1)(x_1,y_1,z_1) and (x2,y2,z2)(x_2,y_2,z_2) is given by xx1x2x1=yy1y2y1=zz1z2z1\frac{x-x_1}{x_2-x_1} = \frac{y-y_1}{y_2-y_1} = \frac{z-z_1}{z_2-z_1}.

2. Step-by-Step Solution

Step 1: Represent General Points on the Given Lines

We are given two lines: L1:x12=y+13=z14L_1: \frac{x-1}{2}=\frac{y+1}{3}=\frac{z-1}{4} L2:x31=y42=z1L_2: \frac{x-3}{1}=\frac{y-4}{2}=\frac{z}{1} And a point P(1,1,1)P(1,1,1).

Let AA be a general point on line L1L_1. We can write its coordinates in parametric form by setting the ratios equal to a parameter, say λ\lambda: x12=y+13=z14=λ\frac{x-1}{2}=\frac{y+1}{3}=\frac{z-1}{4} = \lambda So, A=(1+2λ,1+3λ,1+4λ)A = (1+2\lambda, -1+3\lambda, 1+4\lambda).

Similarly, let BB be a general point on line L2L_2. We set the ratios equal to another parameter, say μ\mu: x31=y42=z1=μ\frac{x-3}{1}=\frac{y-4}{2}=\frac{z}{1} = \mu So, B=(3+μ,4+2μ,μ)B = (3+\mu, 4+2\mu, \mu).

Reasoning: The line LL passes through P(1,1,1)P(1,1,1) and intersects L1L_1 and L2L_2. This means that there exist specific points AA on L1L_1 and BB on L2L_2 such that PP, AA, and BB are collinear. Our goal is to find these specific points AA and BB.

Step 2: Apply the Collinearity Condition for P, A, and B

For P(1,1,1)P(1,1,1), A(1+2λ,1+3λ,1+4λ)A(1+2\lambda, -1+3\lambda, 1+4\lambda), and B(3+μ,4+2μ,μ)B(3+\mu, 4+2\mu, \mu) to be collinear, the direction ratios of PAPA must be proportional to the direction ratios of PBPB.

Direction ratios of PAPA: (xAxP,yAyP,zAzP)=((1+2λ)1,(1+3λ)1,(1+4λ)1)(x_A-x_P, y_A-y_P, z_A-z_P) = ( (1+2\lambda)-1, (-1+3\lambda)-1, (1+4\lambda)-1 ) =(2λ,3λ2,4λ)= (2\lambda, 3\lambda-2, 4\lambda)

Direction ratios of PBPB: (xBxP,yByP,zBzP)=((3+μ)1,(4+2μ)1,μ1)(x_B-x_P, y_B-y_P, z_B-z_P) = ( (3+\mu)-1, (4+2\mu)-1, \mu-1 ) =(2+μ,3+2μ,μ1)= (2+\mu, 3+2\mu, \mu-1)

For collinearity, these direction ratios must be proportional: 2λ2+μ=3λ23+2μ=4λμ1\frac{2\lambda}{2+\mu} = \frac{3\lambda-2}{3+2\mu} = \frac{4\lambda}{\mu-1}

Reasoning: This step sets up a system of equations to solve for the unknown parameters λ\lambda and μ\mu. We need to find values of λ\lambda and μ\mu that satisfy these proportionality conditions, as these values will define the specific points AA and BB that lie on line LL.

Step 3: Solve the System of Equations for λ\lambda and μ\mu

We can form two equations from the proportionality:

Equation 1 (from the first two ratios): 2λ(3+2μ)=(3λ2)(2+μ)2\lambda(3+2\mu) = (3\lambda-2)(2+\mu) 6λ+4λμ=6λ+3λμ42μ6\lambda + 4\lambda\mu = 6\lambda + 3\lambda\mu - 4 - 2\mu 4λμ=3λμ42μ4\lambda\mu = 3\lambda\mu - 4 - 2\mu λμ=42μ()\lambda\mu = -4 - 2\mu \quad (*)

Equation 2 (from the last two ratios): (3λ2)(μ1)=4λ(3+2μ)(3\lambda-2)(\mu-1) = 4\lambda(3+2\mu) 3λμ3λ2μ+2=12λ+8λμ3\lambda\mu - 3\lambda - 2\mu + 2 = 12\lambda + 8\lambda\mu 5λμ15λ2μ+2=0()-5\lambda\mu - 15\lambda - 2\mu + 2 = 0 \quad (**)

Now, substitute λμ=42μ\lambda\mu = -4-2\mu from ()(*) into ()(**): 5(42μ)15λ2μ+2=0-5(-4-2\mu) - 15\lambda - 2\mu + 2 = 0 20+10μ15λ2μ+2=020 + 10\mu - 15\lambda - 2\mu + 2 = 0 8μ15λ+22=0()8\mu - 15\lambda + 22 = 0 \quad (***)

From ()(*), we can express λ\lambda in terms of μ\mu (assuming μ0\mu \neq 0; if μ=0\mu=0, then 0=40=-4, which is false, so μ0\mu \neq 0): λ=42μμ\lambda = \frac{-4-2\mu}{\mu}

Substitute this expression for λ\lambda into ()(***): 8μ15(42μμ)+22=08\mu - 15\left(\frac{-4-2\mu}{\mu}\right) + 22 = 0 Multiply the entire equation by μ\mu to eliminate the denominator: 8μ215(42μ)+22μ=08\mu^2 - 15(-4-2\mu) + 22\mu = 0 8μ2+60+30μ+22μ=08\mu^2 + 60 + 30\mu + 22\mu = 0 8μ2+52μ+60=08\mu^2 + 52\mu + 60 = 0 Divide by 4: 2μ2+13μ+15=02\mu^2 + 13\mu + 15 = 0

Solve this quadratic equation for μ\mu using the quadratic formula μ=b±b24ac2a\mu = \frac{-b \pm \sqrt{b^2-4ac}}{2a}: μ=13±1324(2)(15)2(2)\mu = \frac{-13 \pm \sqrt{13^2 - 4(2)(15)}}{2(2)} μ=13±1691204\mu = \frac{-13 \pm \sqrt{169 - 120}}{4} μ=13±494\mu = \frac{-13 \pm \sqrt{49}}{4} μ=13±74\mu = \frac{-13 \pm 7}{4}

Two possible values for μ\mu: μ1=13+74=64=32\mu_1 = \frac{-13+7}{4} = \frac{-6}{4} = -\frac{3}{2} μ2=1374=204=5\mu_2 = \frac{-13-7}{4} = \frac{-20}{4} = -5

Now, find the corresponding λ\lambda values using λ=42μμ\lambda = \frac{-4-2\mu}{\mu}: For μ=32\mu = -\frac{3}{2}: λ=42(32)32=4+332=132=23\lambda = \frac{-4-2(-\frac{3}{2})}{-\frac{3}{2}} = \frac{-4+3}{-\frac{3}{2}} = \frac{-1}{-\frac{3}{2}} = \frac{2}{3}

For μ=5\mu = -5: λ=42(5)5=4+105=65=65\lambda = \frac{-4-2(-5)}{-5} = \frac{-4+10}{-5} = \frac{6}{-5} = -\frac{6}{5}

We must verify which pair (λ,μ)(\lambda, \mu) satisfies the original proportionality condition. Consider the condition 2λ2+μ=4λμ1\frac{2\lambda}{2+\mu} = \frac{4\lambda}{\mu-1}. If λ0\lambda \neq 0, then 12+μ=2μ1\frac{1}{2+\mu} = \frac{2}{\mu-1}, which implies μ1=2(2+μ)μ1=4+2μμ=5μ=5\mu-1 = 2(2+\mu) \Rightarrow \mu-1 = 4+2\mu \Rightarrow -\mu = 5 \Rightarrow \mu = -5. If λ=0\lambda = 0, then A=(1,1,1)A=(1,-1,1). The direction ratios of PAPA would be (0,2,0)(0, -2, 0). For P,A,BP,A,B to be collinear, the direction ratios of PBPB must be proportional to (0,2,0)(0,-2,0), which means xBxP=0x_B-x_P=0 and zBzP=0z_B-z_P=0. So 2+μ=0μ=22+\mu=0 \Rightarrow \mu=-2 and μ1=0μ=1\mu-1=0 \Rightarrow \mu=1. This is a contradiction, so λ0\lambda \neq 0. Thus, the correct value for μ\mu is 5-5, which implies λ=65\lambda = -\frac{6}{5}.

Let's check this pair with all three ratios: 2λ2+μ=2(65)2+(5)=1253=1215=45\frac{2\lambda}{2+\mu} = \frac{2(-\frac{6}{5})}{2+(-5)} = \frac{-\frac{12}{5}}{-3} = \frac{12}{15} = \frac{4}{5} 3λ23+2μ=3(65)23+2(5)=1852310=2857=2835=45\frac{3\lambda-2}{3+2\mu} = \frac{3(-\frac{6}{5})-2}{3+2(-5)} = \frac{-\frac{18}{5}-2}{3-10} = \frac{-\frac{28}{5}}{-7} = \frac{28}{35} = \frac{4}{5} 4λμ1=4(65)51=2456=2430=45\frac{4\lambda}{\mu-1} = \frac{4(-\frac{6}{5})}{-5-1} = \frac{-\frac{24}{5}}{-6} = \frac{24}{30} = \frac{4}{5} All ratios are equal, so the values λ=65\lambda = -\frac{6}{5} and μ=5\mu = -5 are correct.

Reasoning: Solving the system of equations for λ\lambda and μ\mu is the most critical algebraic step. The values obtained for λ\lambda and μ\mu uniquely define the points AA and BB through which line LL passes. It's crucial to verify the solution with all parts of the collinearity condition.

Step 4: Find the Equation of Line L

We can use the values of λ\lambda or μ\mu to find the coordinates of point AA or BB. Let's use λ=65\lambda = -\frac{6}{5} to find point AA: A=(1+2λ,1+3λ,1+4λ)A = (1+2\lambda, -1+3\lambda, 1+4\lambda) A=(1+2(65),1+3(65),1+4(65))A = (1+2(-\frac{6}{5}), -1+3(-\frac{6}{5}), 1+4(-\frac{6}{5})) A=(1125,1185,1245)A = (1-\frac{12}{5}, -1-\frac{18}{5}, 1-\frac{24}{5}) A=(5125,5185,5245)A = (\frac{5-12}{5}, \frac{-5-18}{5}, \frac{5-24}{5}) A=(75,235,195)A = (-\frac{7}{5}, -\frac{23}{5}, -\frac{19}{5})

Now, we have two points on line LL: P(1,1,1)P(1,1,1) and A(75,235,195)A(-\frac{7}{5}, -\frac{23}{5}, -\frac{19}{5}). The direction ratios of line LL are (xAxP,yAyP,zAzP)(x_A-x_P, y_A-y_P, z_A-z_P): DRL=(751,2351,1951)DR_L = (-\frac{7}{5}-1, -\frac{23}{5}-1, -\frac{19}{5}-1) DRL=(125,285,245)DR_L = (-\frac{12}{5}, -\frac{28}{5}, -\frac{24}{5}) We can simplify these direction ratios by multiplying by 54-\frac{5}{4}: Simplified DRL=(3,7,6)DR_L = (3, 7, 6).

The equation of line LL passing through P(1,1,1)P(1,1,1) with direction ratios (3,7,6)(3,7,6) is: x13=y17=z16=k\frac{x-1}{3} = \frac{y-1}{7} = \frac{z-1}{6} = k A general point on line LL can be written as (1+3k,1+7k,1+6k)(1+3k, 1+7k, 1+6k).

Reasoning: Once the specific points AA and BB (or just one of them) are found, the problem reduces to finding the equation of a line passing through two known points (PP and AA in this case). Simplifying the direction ratios makes it easier to work with the equation and check the options.

Step 5: Check Which Option Lies on Line L

We need to check which of the given options satisfies the equation of line LL: x13=y17=z16\frac{x-1}{3} = \frac{y-1}{7} = \frac{z-1}{6}.

(A) (7,15,13)(7,15,13) 713=63=2\frac{7-1}{3} = \frac{6}{3} = 2 1517=147=2\frac{15-1}{7} = \frac{14}{7} = 2 1316=126=2\frac{13-1}{6} = \frac{12}{6} = 2 Since all ratios are equal to 2, the point (7,15,13)(7,15,13) lies on line LL.

(B) (4,22,7)(4,22,7) 413=1\frac{4-1}{3} = 1 2217=3\frac{22-1}{7} = 3 The ratios are not equal, so this point does not lie on LL.

(C) (10,29,50)(10,-29,-50) 1013=3\frac{10-1}{3} = 3 2917=307\frac{-29-1}{7} = \frac{-30}{7} The ratios are not equal, so this point does not lie on LL.

(D) (5,4,3)(5,4,3) 513=43\frac{5-1}{3} = \frac{4}{3} 417=37\frac{4-1}{7} = \frac{3}{7} The ratios are not equal, so this point does not lie on LL.

Reasoning: The final step involves substituting the coordinates of each option into the equation of line LL. If all three components yield the same value for the parameter kk, then the point lies on the line.

3. Common Mistakes & Tips

  • Algebraic Precision: The process of solving for λ\lambda and μ\mu involves multiple algebraic manipulations. Errors in signs, multiplication, or simplification can lead to incorrect values. Double-check your calculations.
  • Verification of Parameters: Always substitute the calculated values of λ\lambda and μ\mu back into the original proportionality equations (all three parts) to ensure consistency. This helps catch errors before proceeding to find the line equation.
  • Understanding Collinearity: Remember that collinearity means the direction vectors (or direction ratios) formed by any two pairs of points are parallel, hence proportional.
  • Simplifying Direction Ratios: While not strictly necessary, simplifying direction ratios by dividing by a common factor can make subsequent calculations (like checking options) much easier and reduce the chance of arithmetic errors.

4. Summary

This problem required finding a point on a line LL that passes through a given point PP and intersects two other lines, L1L_1 and L2L_2. The fundamental approach was to leverage the collinearity of PP with a point AA on L1L_1 and a point BB on L2L_2. We first expressed general points AA and BB in their parametric forms. Then, by equating the ratios of the direction numbers of PAPA and PBPB, we formed a system of equations in two variables, λ\lambda and μ\mu. Solving this system yielded unique values for λ\lambda and μ\mu, which in turn allowed us to determine the coordinates of point AA. With point PP and point AA known, we found the direction ratios and the Cartesian equation of line LL. Finally, we tested each given option by substituting its coordinates into the equation of line LL to identify the point that lies on it.

5. Final Answer

The final answer is (7,15,13)\boxed{(7,15,13)}, which corresponds to option (A).

Practice More 3D Geometry Questions

View All Questions