Skip to main content
Back to 3D Geometry
JEE Main 2023
3D Geometry
3D Geometry
Medium

Question

Let the lines l1:x+53=y+41=zα2l_{1}: \frac{x+5}{3}=\frac{y+4}{1}=\frac{z-\alpha}{-2} and l2:3x+2y+z2=0=x3y+2z13l_{2}: 3 x+2 y+z-2=0=x-3 y+2 z-13 be coplanar. If the point P(a,b,c)\mathrm{P}(a, b, c) on l1l_{1} is nearest to the point Q(4,3,2)\mathrm{Q}(-4,-3,2), then a+b+c|a|+|b|+|c| is equal to

Options

Solution

Key Concepts and Formulas

  1. Coplanarity of Lines: Two lines l1l_1 and l2l_2 are coplanar if and only if there exists a plane containing both lines. If l2l_2 is given as the intersection of two planes P1=0P_1=0 and P2=0P_2=0, then any plane containing l2l_2 can be represented as P1+μP2=0P_1 + \mu P_2 = 0. For l1l_1 to be coplanar with l2l_2, l1l_1 must lie in this plane. A line with direction vector d\vec{d} and passing through point AA lies in a plane with normal vector n\vec{n} and equation Ax+By+Cz+D=0Ax'+By'+Cz'+D=0 if:
    • dn=0\vec{d} \cdot \vec{n} = 0 (the line is parallel to the plane).
    • The point AA lies on the plane (i.e., its coordinates satisfy the plane equation).
  2. Nearest Point from a Point to a Line: The point P on a line LL that is nearest to a given external point Q is the foot of the perpendicular from Q to LL. This means the line segment PQ is perpendicular to the line LL. If d\vec{d} is the direction vector of LL, then PQd=0\vec{PQ} \cdot \vec{d} = 0.

Step-by-Step Solution

Part 1: Determining the value of α\alpha for coplanarity

Step 1: Identify the properties of lines l1l_1 and l2l_2. The line l1l_1 is given in symmetric form: l1:x+53=y+41=zα2l_{1}: \frac{x+5}{3}=\frac{y+4}{1}=\frac{z-\alpha}{-2} From this, we identify a point on l1l_1 as A1(5,4,α)A_1(-5, -4, \alpha) and its direction vector as d1=(3,1,2)\vec{d_1} = (3, 1, -2).

The line l2l_2 is given as the intersection of two planes: P1:3x+2y+z2=0P_1: 3x+2y+z-2=0 P2:x3y+2z13=0P_2: x-3y+2z-13=0

Step 2: Formulate the equation of a plane containing l2l_2. Any plane containing the line l2l_2 can be represented by a linear combination of the equations of P1P_1 and P2P_2: (3x+2y+z2)+μ(x3y+2z13)=0(3x+2y+z-2) + \mu(x-3y+2z-13) = 0 Rearranging this into the standard form Ax+By+Cz+D=0Ax+By+Cz+D=0: (3+μ)x+(23μ)y+(1+2μ)z(2+13μ)=0(3+\mu)x + (2-3\mu)y + (1+2\mu)z - (2+13\mu) = 0 The normal vector to this plane is n=(3+μ,23μ,1+2μ)\vec{n} = (3+\mu, 2-3\mu, 1+2\mu).

Step 3: Apply the first condition for l1l_1 to lie in the plane. For l1l_1 to lie in this plane, its direction vector d1\vec{d_1} must be perpendicular to the plane's normal vector n\vec{n}. Their dot product must be zero: d1n=0\vec{d_1} \cdot \vec{n} = 0 3(3+μ)+1(23μ)+(2)(1+2μ)=03(3+\mu) + 1(2-3\mu) + (-2)(1+2\mu) = 0 9+3μ+23μ24μ=09 + 3\mu + 2 - 3\mu - 2 - 4\mu = 0 94μ=0    4μ=9    μ=949 - 4\mu = 0 \implies 4\mu = 9 \implies \mu = \frac{9}{4} This value of μ\mu defines the specific plane that contains l2l_2 and is parallel to l1l_1.

Step 4: Apply the second condition for l1l_1 to lie in the plane and determine α\alpha. For l1l_1 to be coplanar with l2l_2, the line l1l_1 must actually lie in this plane. This means the point A1(5,4,α)A_1(-5, -4, \alpha) on l1l_1 must satisfy the plane equation. Substitute μ=94\mu = \frac{9}{4} into the plane equation and then substitute the coordinates of A1A_1: (3x+2y+z2)+94(x3y+2z13)=0(3x+2y+z-2) + \frac{9}{4}(x-3y+2z-13) = 0 Substitute A1(5,4,α)A_1(-5, -4, \alpha): (3(5)+2(4)+α2)+94((5)3(4)+2α13)=0(3(-5)+2(-4)+\alpha-2) + \frac{9}{4}((-5)-3(-4)+2\alpha-13) = 0 (158+α2)+94(5+12+2α13)=0(-15-8+\alpha-2) + \frac{9}{4}(-5+12+2\alpha-13) = 0 (α25)+94(2α6)=0(\alpha-25) + \frac{9}{4}(2\alpha-6) = 0 To eliminate the fraction, multiply the entire equation by 4: 4(α25)+9(2α6)=04(\alpha-25) + 9(2\alpha-6) = 0 4α100+18α54=04\alpha - 100 + 18\alpha - 54 = 0 22α154=022\alpha - 154 = 0 22α=154    α=15422    α=722\alpha = 154 \implies \alpha = \frac{154}{22} \implies \alpha = 7

Part 2: Finding the point P on l1l_1 nearest to Q

Step 5: Represent any point P on l1l_1 and the vector PQ. Now that we have α=7\alpha=7, the equation of line l1l_1 is: l1:x+53=y+41=z72l_{1}: \frac{x+5}{3}=\frac{y+4}{1}=\frac{z-7}{-2} Let this ratio be equal to λ\lambda. Then any point P(a,b,c)P(a,b,c) on l1l_1 can be expressed in terms of λ\lambda: P(a,b,c)=(3λ5,λ4,2λ+7)P(a,b,c) = (3\lambda-5, \lambda-4, -2\lambda+7) The given point Q is (4,3,2)(-4, -3, 2). The vector PQ\vec{PQ} is obtained by subtracting the coordinates of P from Q: PQ=QP=(4(3λ5),3(λ4),2(2λ+7))\vec{PQ} = Q - P = (-4 - (3\lambda-5), -3 - (\lambda-4), 2 - (-2\lambda+7)) PQ=(43λ+5,3λ+4,2+2λ7)\vec{PQ} = (-4 - 3\lambda + 5, -3 - \lambda + 4, 2 + 2\lambda - 7) PQ=(13λ,1λ,2λ5)\vec{PQ} = (1 - 3\lambda, 1 - \lambda, 2\lambda - 5) Alternatively, we can use QP=PQ=(3λ5(4),λ4(3),2λ+72)=(3λ1,λ1,2λ+5)\vec{QP} = P - Q = (3\lambda-5 - (-4), \lambda-4 - (-3), -2\lambda+7 - 2) = (3\lambda-1, \lambda-1, -2\lambda+5). The dot product with d1\vec{d_1} will yield the same λ\lambda. Let's use QP\vec{QP}.

Step 6: Apply the condition for the nearest point. The line segment PQ (or QP) must be perpendicular to the line l1l_1. This means their dot product must be zero: QPd1=0\vec{QP} \cdot \vec{d_1} = 0 (3λ1)(3)+(λ1)(1)+(2λ+5)(2)=0(3\lambda-1)(3) + (\lambda-1)(1) + (-2\lambda+5)(-2) = 0 9λ3+λ1+4λ10=09\lambda - 3 + \lambda - 1 + 4\lambda - 10 = 0 14λ14=014\lambda - 14 = 0 14λ=14    λ=114\lambda = 14 \implies \lambda = 1

Step 7: Determine the coordinates of P and calculate a+b+c|a|+|b|+|c|. Substitute λ=1\lambda=1 back into the coordinates of P: P(a,b,c)=(3(1)5,(1)4,2(1)+7)P(a,b,c) = (3(1)-5, (1)-4, -2(1)+7) P(a,b,c)=(35,14,2+7)P(a,b,c) = (3-5, 1-4, -2+7) P(a,b,c)=(2,3,5)P(a,b,c) = (-2, -3, 5) So, a=2a=-2, b=3b=-3, and c=5c=5. Finally, calculate a+b+c|a|+|b|+|c|: a+b+c=2+3+5=2+3+5=10|a|+|b|+|c| = |-2| + |-3| + |5| = 2 + 3 + 5 = 10

Common Mistakes & Tips

  • Incomplete Coplanarity Conditions: Remember that for a line to lie in a plane, both conditions must be satisfied: the line's direction vector must be perpendicular to the plane's normal vector, AND a point on the line must lie in the plane.
  • Sign Errors: Be careful with signs when defining points on the line (e.g., x+5x+5 implies x0=5x_0=-5) and when calculating dot products.
  • Vector Subtraction: Ensure consistency when calculating the vector between two points (e.g., QPQ-P or PQP-Q). While the dot product with the direction vector will still be zero, it's good practice to be consistent.

Summary

First, we determined the value of α\alpha by using the conditions for coplanarity of two lines. We formed a family of planes containing l2l_2 and found the specific plane that also contained l1l_1. This yielded α=7\alpha=7. Next, we used this value of α\alpha to find the equation of l1l_1. We then found the point P on l1l_1 nearest to Q by ensuring the vector PQ was perpendicular to the direction vector of l1l_1. This gave us the coordinates of P as (2,3,5)(-2,-3,5). Finally, we calculated the sum of the absolute values of its coordinates, which is 10.

The final answer is 10\boxed{10} which corresponds to option (C).

Practice More 3D Geometry Questions

View All Questions