The acute angle between the planes P 1 and P 2 , when P 1 and P 2 are the planes passing through the intersection of the planes 5x+8y+13z−29=0 and 8x−7y+z−20=0 and the points (2, 1, 3) and (0, 1, 2), respectively, is :
Options
Solution
1. Key Concepts and Formulas
To determine the acute angle between the two planes, P1 and P2, we will use the following fundamental concepts from 3D Geometry:
Family of Planes: If two planes are given by the equations PA:A1x+B1y+C1z+D1=0 and PB:A2x+B2y+C2z+D2=0, then any plane passing through their line of intersection can be represented by the general equation PA+λPB=0, where λ is a scalar parameter. This expands to:
(A1x+B1y+C1z+D1)+λ(A2x+B2y+C2z+D2)=0
A specific value of λ defines a unique plane in this family, usually determined by an additional condition, such as the plane passing through a given point.
Angle Between Two Planes: The acute angle θ between two planes is found by calculating the angle between their respective normal vectors. If the normal vectors to the planes are n1=⟨A1,B1,C1⟩ and n2=⟨A2,B2,C2⟩, the cosine of the acute angle θ is given by the formula:
cosθ=∣n1∣∣n2∣∣n1⋅n2∣
The absolute value in the numerator, ∣n1⋅n2∣, ensures that cosθ≥0, which corresponds to the acute angle (i.e., θ∈[0,π/2]).
2. Step-by-Step Solution
Step 1: Formulate the General Equation for the Family of Planes
We are given two planes whose intersection defines the family:
Plane PA:5x+8y+13z−29=0
Plane PB:8x−7y+z−20=0
Any plane passing through the line of intersection of PA and PB can be expressed as PA+λPB=0. We write this equation and then group terms by x,y,z to easily identify the normal vector components:
(5x+8y+13z−29)+λ(8x−7y+z−20)=0
Rearranging the terms, we get the general equation for any plane in this family:
(5+8λ)x+(8−7λ)y+(13+λ)z−(29+20λ)=0(∗)
The normal vector to any plane in this family will be n=⟨5+8λ,8−7λ,13+λ⟩.
**Step 2: Determine Plane P1 and its Normal Vector n1}
Plane P1 is a member of the family (∗) and passes through the point (2,1,3).
To find the specific value of λ (let's call it λ1) for P1, we substitute the coordinates (x=2,y=1,z=3) into equation (∗):
(5+8λ1)(2)+(8−7λ1)(1)+(13+λ1)(3)−(29+20λ1)=0
Now, we simplify and solve for λ1:
(10+16λ1)+(8−7λ1)+(39+3λ1)−(29+20λ1)=0
Combine the λ1 terms and the constant terms:
(16λ1−7λ1+3λ1−20λ1)+(10+8+39−29)=0(−8λ1)+(28)=08λ1=28λ1=828=27
Now, we find the normal vector n1 for P1 by substituting λ1=27 into the coefficients of x,y,z from equation (∗):
Coefficient of x: A1=5+8(27)=5+28=33
Coefficient of y: B1=8−7(27)=8−249=216−49=−233
Coefficient of z: C1=13+(27)=226+7=233
So, n1=⟨33,−233,233⟩. For simplicity in calculations, we can use a scalar multiple of this vector. Multiplying by 332 gives us a simpler normal vector:
n1′=⟨33×332,−233×332,233×332⟩=⟨2,−1,1⟩
**Step 3: Determine Plane P2 and its Normal Vector n2}
Plane P2 also belongs to the family (∗) and passes through the point (0,1,2).
We substitute (x=0,y=1,z=2) into equation (∗) to find λ2:
(5+8λ2)(0)+(8−7λ2)(1)+(13+λ2)(2)−(29+20λ2)=0
Simplify and solve for λ2:
0+(8−7λ2)+(26+2λ2)−(29+20λ2)=0
Combine the λ2 terms and the constant terms:
(−7λ2+2λ2−20λ2)+(8+26−29)=0(−25λ2)+(5)=025λ2=5λ2=255=51
Now, we find the normal vector n2 for P2 by substituting λ2=51 into the coefficients of x,y,z from equation (∗):
Coefficient of x: A2=5+8(51)=5+58=525+8=533
Coefficient of y: B2=8−7(51)=8−57=540−7=533
Coefficient of z: C2=13+(51)=565+1=566
So, n2=⟨533,533,566⟩. Again, we simplify by multiplying by 335:
n2′=⟨533×335,533×335,566×335⟩=⟨1,1,2⟩
**Step 4: Calculate the Acute Angle Between P1 and P2}
We now have the simplified normal vectors for P1 and P2:
n1′=⟨2,−1,1⟩n2′=⟨1,1,2⟩
We use the formula for the cosine of the acute angle θ:
cosθ=∣n1′∣∣n2′∣∣n1′⋅n2′∣
First, calculate the dot product:
n1′⋅n2′=(2)(1)+(−1)(1)+(1)(2)=2−1+2=3
Next, calculate the magnitudes of the normal vectors:
∣n1′∣=22+(−1)2+12=4+1+1=6∣n2′∣=12+12+22=1+1+4=6
Substitute these values into the angle formula:
cosθ=6×6∣3∣=63=21
Since cosθ=21, the acute angle θ is:
θ=arccos(21)=3π
3. Common Mistakes & Tips
Sign Errors: Be very careful with signs when substituting coordinates into the general plane equation and when expanding and combining terms. A single sign error can lead to an incorrect λ value and, subsequently, incorrect normal vectors.
Forgetting Absolute Value: When calculating the acute angle between planes (or lines), remember to take the absolute value of the dot product in the numerator of the cosine formula. This ensures that cosθ is positive, yielding an acute angle (0≤θ≤π/2).
Simplifying Normal Vectors: Always simplify normal vectors by dividing out common factors. This makes calculations for dot products and magnitudes much easier and reduces the chance of arithmetic errors, without affecting the direction of the vector or the angle. For example, ⟨33,−233,233⟩ is directionally equivalent to ⟨2,−1,1⟩.
4. Summary
This problem required us to first determine the equations of two specific planes, P1 and P2, each belonging to a family of planes passing through the intersection of two given planes. This was achieved by using the family of planes formula PA+λPB=0 and then using the additional point condition for each plane to solve for its unique λ value. Once the λ values were found, we extracted the normal vectors for P1 and P2, simplifying them to make calculations easier. Finally, the acute angle between these two planes was calculated using the dot product formula involving their normal vectors. The result was 3π.
The final answer is 3π, which corresponds to option (A).