Question
if and only if :
Options
Solution
Key Concepts and Formulas
- Combinations (Binomial Coefficients): The number of ways to choose items from a set of items is denoted by or , and its formula is .
- Conditions for Combinations: For to be defined, and must be non-negative integers, and .
- Combinatorial Identity: and .
Step-by-Step Solution
Step 1: Analyze the Conditions for Combinations The given equation is . For the binomial coefficients to be defined, we must satisfy the following conditions:
- For : , , and .
- For : , , and .
Combining these, we get:
- is a positive integer ().
- is a non-negative integer ().
- The condition is the strongest of the inequalities involving and , as it implies .
Step 2: Simplify the Equation using a Combinatorial Identity We can rewrite the given equation as: We use the identity . Inverting this, we get: Therefore, we have:
Step 3: Determine the Range of the Ratio From Step 1, we have the conditions: , , and . Let's find the bounds for the ratio :
- Lower Bound: Since , . Since , both numerator and denominator are positive. Thus, .
- Upper Bound: From the condition , we can divide by (since ) to get . The equality holds when .
So, the range of the ratio is .
Step 4: Solve the Inequality for Substituting the ratio back into the equation from Step 2: This compound inequality can be split into two inequalities:
Inequality 1: Taking the square root of both sides, we get . This implies or .
Inequality 2: Taking the square root of both sides, we get . This implies .
Step 5: Find the Intersection of the Solutions We need to find the values of that satisfy both or , AND .
For the positive values of : We need and . This gives the interval .
For the negative values of : We need and . This gives the interval .
Combining both intervals, the solution for is .
Step 6: Compare with the Given Options The question asks for the condition that the equation holds if and only if. The options provided are generally for the positive range of . Our derived range for positive is . Let's examine the options: (A) (B) (C) (D)
Our derived range exactly matches option (B).
Common Mistakes & Tips
- Forgetting Conditions: Always start by listing the conditions for and to ensure the combinations are well-defined. This is crucial for establishing the bounds of the ratio.
- Absolute Value Inequalities: Remember that implies (i.e., or ), and implies (i.e., ).
- Intersection of Intervals: When solving compound inequalities, carefully find the intersection of the solution sets. Visualizing on a number line can be helpful.
Summary The problem was solved by first establishing the necessary conditions for the binomial coefficients to be defined, which led to constraints on and . A key combinatorial identity was then used to simplify the given equation into an expression involving and the ratio . By analyzing the valid range of this ratio based on the initial conditions, we derived inequalities for . Solving these inequalities for yielded the range . Comparing this with the given options, the condition emerges as the correct choice for the positive range of .
The final answer is .