Skip to main content
Back to Binomial Theorem
JEE Main 2024
Binomial Theorem
Binomial Theorem
Hard

Question

n1Cr=(k28)nCr+1{ }^{n-1} C_r=\left(k^2-8\right){ }^n C_{r+1} if and only if :

Options

Solution

Key Concepts and Formulas

  • Combinations (Binomial Coefficients): The number of ways to choose rr items from a set of nn items is denoted by nCr{}^n C_r or (nr)\binom{n}{r}, and its formula is n!r!(nr)!\frac{n!}{r!(n-r)!}.
  • Conditions for Combinations: For NCK{}^N C_K to be defined, NN and KK must be non-negative integers, and NKN \ge K.
  • Combinatorial Identity: nCrn1Cr1=nr\frac{{}^n C_r}{{}^{n-1} C_{r-1}} = \frac{n}{r} and nCr+1n1Cr=nr+1\frac{{}^n C_{r+1}}{{}^{n-1} C_r} = \frac{n}{r+1}.

Step-by-Step Solution

Step 1: Analyze the Conditions for Combinations The given equation is n1Cr=(k28)nCr+1{ }^{n-1} C_r=\left(k^2-8\right){ }^n C_{r+1}. For the binomial coefficients to be defined, we must satisfy the following conditions:

  • For n1Cr{ }^{n-1} C_r: n10    n1n-1 \ge 0 \implies n \ge 1, r0r \ge 0, and n1rn-1 \ge r.
  • For nCr+1{ }^n C_{r+1}: n0n \ge 0, r+10    r1r+1 \ge 0 \implies r \ge -1, and nr+1n \ge r+1.

Combining these, we get:

  • nn is a positive integer (n1n \ge 1).
  • rr is a non-negative integer (r0r \ge 0).
  • The condition nr+1n \ge r+1 is the strongest of the inequalities involving nn and rr, as it implies n1rn-1 \ge r.

Step 2: Simplify the Equation using a Combinatorial Identity We can rewrite the given equation as: n1CrnCr+1=k28\frac{{ }^{n-1} C_r}{{ }^n C_{r+1}} = k^2-8 We use the identity nCr+1n1Cr=nr+1\frac{{ }^n C_{r+1}}{{ }^{n-1} C_r} = \frac{n}{r+1}. Inverting this, we get: n1CrnCr+1=r+1n\frac{{ }^{n-1} C_r}{{ }^n C_{r+1}} = \frac{r+1}{n} Therefore, we have: k28=r+1nk^2-8 = \frac{r+1}{n}

Step 3: Determine the Range of the Ratio r+1n\frac{r+1}{n} From Step 1, we have the conditions: n1n \ge 1, r0r \ge 0, and nr+1n \ge r+1. Let's find the bounds for the ratio r+1n\frac{r+1}{n}:

  • Lower Bound: Since r0r \ge 0, r+11r+1 \ge 1. Since n1n \ge 1, both numerator and denominator are positive. Thus, r+1n>0\frac{r+1}{n} > 0.
  • Upper Bound: From the condition nr+1n \ge r+1, we can divide by nn (since n>0n > 0) to get r+1nnn=1\frac{r+1}{n} \le \frac{n}{n} = 1. The equality holds when n=r+1n = r+1.

So, the range of the ratio is 0<r+1n10 < \frac{r+1}{n} \le 1.

Step 4: Solve the Inequality for kk Substituting the ratio back into the equation from Step 2: 0<k2810 < k^2-8 \le 1 This compound inequality can be split into two inequalities:

Inequality 1: k28>0k^2-8 > 0 k2>8k^2 > 8 Taking the square root of both sides, we get k>8=22|k| > \sqrt{8} = 2\sqrt{2}. This implies k<22k < -2\sqrt{2} or k>22k > 2\sqrt{2}.

Inequality 2: k281k^2-8 \le 1 k29k^2 \le 9 Taking the square root of both sides, we get k3|k| \le 3. This implies 3k3-3 \le k \le 3.

Step 5: Find the Intersection of the Solutions We need to find the values of kk that satisfy both k<22k < -2\sqrt{2} or k>22k > 2\sqrt{2}, AND 3k3-3 \le k \le 3.

For the positive values of kk: We need k>22k > 2\sqrt{2} and k3k \le 3. This gives the interval (22,3](2\sqrt{2}, 3].

For the negative values of kk: We need k<22k < -2\sqrt{2} and k3k \ge -3. This gives the interval [3,22)[-3, -2\sqrt{2}).

Combining both intervals, the solution for kk is k[3,22)(22,3]k \in [-3, -2\sqrt{2}) \cup (2\sqrt{2}, 3].

Step 6: Compare with the Given Options The question asks for the condition that the equation holds if and only if. The options provided are generally for the positive range of kk. Our derived range for positive kk is 22<k32\sqrt{2} < k \le 3. Let's examine the options: (A) 22<k<232 \sqrt{2}<\mathrm{k}<2 \sqrt{3} (B) 22<k32 \sqrt{2}<\mathrm{k} \leq 3 (C) 23<k<332 \sqrt{3}<\mathrm{k}<3 \sqrt{3} (D) 23<k322 \sqrt{3}<\mathrm{k} \leq 3 \sqrt{2}

Our derived range (22,3](2\sqrt{2}, 3] exactly matches option (B).

Common Mistakes & Tips

  • Forgetting Conditions: Always start by listing the conditions for nn and rr to ensure the combinations are well-defined. This is crucial for establishing the bounds of the ratio.
  • Absolute Value Inequalities: Remember that k2>ak^2 > a implies k>a|k| > \sqrt{a} (i.e., k<ak < -\sqrt{a} or k>ak > \sqrt{a}), and k2ak^2 \le a implies ka|k| \le \sqrt{a} (i.e., aka-\sqrt{a} \le k \le \sqrt{a}).
  • Intersection of Intervals: When solving compound inequalities, carefully find the intersection of the solution sets. Visualizing on a number line can be helpful.

Summary The problem was solved by first establishing the necessary conditions for the binomial coefficients to be defined, which led to constraints on nn and rr. A key combinatorial identity was then used to simplify the given equation into an expression involving k28k^2-8 and the ratio r+1n\frac{r+1}{n}. By analyzing the valid range of this ratio based on the initial conditions, we derived inequalities for k28k^2-8. Solving these inequalities for kk yielded the range k[3,22)(22,3]k \in [-3, -2\sqrt{2}) \cup (2\sqrt{2}, 3]. Comparing this with the given options, the condition 22<k32\sqrt{2} < k \le 3 emerges as the correct choice for the positive range of kk.

The final answer is A\boxed{A}.

Practice More Binomial Theorem Questions

View All Questions