Skip to main content
Back to Conic Sections
JEE Main 2023
Conic Sections
Ellipse
Easy

Question

If the minimum area of the triangle formed by a tangent to the ellipse x2b2+y24a2=1{{{x^2}} \over {{b^2}}} + {{{y^2}} \over {4{a^2}}} = 1 and the co-ordinate axis is kab, then k is equal to _______________.

Answer: 2

Solution

This problem is a classic application of analytical geometry, specifically involving ellipses and tangents, combined with trigonometric optimization. Our goal is to find the minimum possible area of a triangle formed by a tangent line to a given ellipse and the coordinate axes.


Key Concepts and Formulas (Prerequisites)

To tackle this problem, we need to be proficient with the following fundamental concepts:

  1. Standard Equation of an Ellipse: An ellipse centered at the origin has the standard form x2A2+y2B2=1{{{x^2}} \over {{A^2}}} + {{{y^2}} \over {{B^2}}} = 1. Here, AA and BB represent the lengths of the semi-major and semi-minor axes along the x and y directions, respectively.
  2. Parametric Coordinates on an Ellipse: Any point on the ellipse x2A2+y2B2=1{{{x^2}} \over {{A^2}}} + {{{y^2}} \over {{B^2}}} = 1 can be conveniently represented in parametric form as (Acosθ,Bsinθ)(A\cos\theta, B\sin\theta). This representation simplifies many geometric calculations.
  3. Equation of a Tangent to an Ellipse (Parametric Form): The equation of the tangent line to the ellipse x2A2+y2B2=1{{{x^2}} \over {{A^2}}} + {{{y^2}} \over {{B^2}}} = 1 at the point (Acosθ,Bsinθ)(A\cos\theta, B\sin\theta) is given by xcosθA+ysinθB=1{{x\cos \theta } \over A} + {{y\sin \theta } \over B} = 1. This form is particularly useful for finding intercepts.
  4. Area of a Triangle formed by a Line and Coordinate Axes: If a straight line intersects the x-axis at (X0,0)(X_0, 0) and the y-axis at (0,Y0)(0, Y_0), the area of the triangle formed by this line and the coordinate axes (with the origin as one vertex) is 12X0Y0{1 \over 2} |X_0 Y_0|. For typical minimum area problems, we consider the tangent in the first quadrant, where X0>0X_0 > 0 and Y0>0Y_0 > 0, simplifying the area to 12X0Y0{1 \over 2} X_0 Y_0.
  5. Trigonometric Double-Angle Identity: The identity sin(2θ)=2sinθcosθ\sin(2\theta) = 2\sin\theta\cos\theta is crucial for simplifying expressions involving products of sine and cosine functions.
  6. Range of the Sine Function: The value of sinx\sin x is always bounded between -1 and 1, i.e., 1sinx1-1 \le \sin x \le 1. Consequently, its maximum positive value is 1. This property is fundamental for optimization (finding minimum or maximum values).

Detailed Step-by-Step Solution

Let's break down the problem into logical steps, explaining the reasoning behind each action.

Step 1: Understanding the Ellipse and its Tangent Equation

Our first task is to correctly identify the parameters of the given ellipse and then formulate the general equation of a tangent to it.

  • Given Ellipse Equation: The problem provides the ellipse equation as x2b2+y24a2=1{{{x^2}} \over {{b^2}}} + {{{y^2}} \over {4{a^2}}} = 1

  • Why this step? To apply the standard formulas for tangents and other properties, we must first correctly identify the semi-axis lengths, often denoted as AA and BB, from the given equation. These values will be substituted into the general formulas.

  • Action: We compare the given equation with the standard form of an ellipse centered at the origin, x2A2+y2B2=1{{{x^2}} \over {{A^2}}} + {{{y^2}} \over {{B^2}}} = 1. From this comparison, we deduce: A2=b2    A=b{A^2} = {b^2} \implies A = b (The semi-axis length along the x-axis) B2=4a2    B=2a{B^2} = {4{a^2}} \implies B = 2a (The semi-axis length along the y-axis)

    Now, we write the equation of the tangent to this specific ellipse.

  • Why parametric form? The parametric form of the tangent equation xcosθA+ysinθB=1{{x\cos \theta } \over A} + {{y\sin \theta } \over B} = 1 is particularly advantageous here because it directly provides expressions for the x and y intercepts in terms of cosθ\cos\theta and sinθ\sin\theta. These expressions are easy to manipulate for area calculation and subsequent minimization. Using the slope-intercept form (y=mx±A2m2+B2y=mx \pm \sqrt{A^2m^2+B^2}) would be more cumbersome for finding intercepts and then minimizing.

  • Action: Substitute A=bA=b and B=2aB=2a into the general tangent formula: xcosθb+ysinθ2a=1{{x\cos \theta } \over b} + {{y\sin \theta } \over {2a}} = 1 This is the equation of the tangent line to the given ellipse at the point (bcosθ,2asinθ)(b\cos\theta, 2a\sin\theta).

Step 2: Finding the Intercepts with the Coordinate Axes

The triangle whose area we need to minimize is formed by this tangent line and the x and y axes. To calculate its area, we must first find where this tangent line intersects the coordinate axes.

  • Why this step? The x-intercept and y-intercept will serve as the base and height (or legs) of the right-angled triangle formed with the origin. These lengths are essential for calculating the triangle's area.

  • Action for x-intercept: To find the point where the tangent line crosses the x-axis, we set y=0y=0 in the tangent equation: xcosθb+0sinθ2a=1{{x\cos \theta } \over b} + {{0\sin \theta } \over {2a}} = 1 xcosθb=1{{x\cos \theta } \over b} = 1 x=bcosθx = {b \over {\cos \theta}} So, the x-intercept is X0=bcosθX_0 = {b \over {\cos \theta}}.

  • Action for y-intercept: Similarly, to find the point where the tangent line crosses the y-axis, we set x=0x=0 in the tangent equation: 0cosθb+ysinθ2a=1{{0\cos \theta } \over b} + {{y\sin \theta } \over {2a}} = 1 ysinθ2a=1{{y\sin \theta } \over {2a}} = 1 y=2asinθy = {{2a} \over {\sin \theta}} So, the y-intercept is Y0=2asinθY_0 = {{2a} \over {\sin \theta}}.

  • Important Note: For the minimum area, the tangent line will typically be in the first quadrant, meaning the point of tangency (bcosθ,2asinθ)(b\cos\theta, 2a\sin\theta) is also in the first quadrant. This implies cosθ>0\cos\theta > 0 and sinθ>0\sin\theta > 0, which means θ(0,π/2)\theta \in (0, \pi/2). Consequently, both X0X_0 and Y0Y_0 will be positive, allowing us to drop the absolute value signs in the area formula.

Step 3: Calculating the Area of the Triangle

Now that we have the x and y intercepts, we can calculate the area of the right-angled triangle formed by the tangent line and the coordinate axes.

  • Why this step? We need an explicit expression for the area in terms of θ\theta that we can then minimize.

  • Action: Using the formula for the area of a triangle formed by a line and the coordinate axes: Area(ΔOAB)=12X0Y0Area (\Delta OAB) = {1 \over 2} |X_0 Y_0| Since X0X_0 and Y0Y_0 are positive (as explained above for minimum area), we have: Area=12X0Y0Area = {1 \over 2} X_0 Y_0 Substitute the intercept expressions we found: Area=12×(bcosθ)×(2asinθ)Area = {1 \over 2} \times \left( {{b \over {\cos \theta }}} \right) \times \left( {{{2a} \over {\sin \theta }}} \right) Area=2ab2cosθsinθArea = {{2ab} \over {2\cos \theta \sin \theta}}

Step 4: Simplifying the Area Expression using Trigonometric Identities

The current area expression contains a product of cosθ\cos\theta and sinθ\sin\theta in the denominator. This can be significantly simplified using a standard trigonometric identity.

  • Why this step? Simplifying the expression is crucial because it allows us to reduce it to a single trigonometric function. This transformation makes it much easier to find the minimum value by leveraging the known range of that function.

  • Action: We recall the double-angle identity: sin(2θ)=2sinθcosθ\sin(2\theta) = 2\sin\theta\cos\theta. Substitute this identity into our area expression: Area=2absin(2θ)Area = {{2ab} \over {\sin(2\theta)}}

Step 5: Minimizing the Area

With the area now expressed in a simplified form, we can use the properties of the sine function to find its minimum value.

  • Why this step? To find the minimum value of the area, we need to understand how the expression Area=2absin(2θ)Area = {{2ab} \over {\sin(2\theta)}} behaves as θ\theta changes.

  • Action: We want to minimize Area=2absin(2θ)Area = {{2ab} \over {\sin(2\theta)}}. Since 2ab2ab is a positive constant, to minimize the entire fraction, we must maximize its denominator, sin(2θ)\sin(2\theta). We know that the maximum value of the sine function, sin(x)\sin(x), is 1. Therefore, the maximum value of sin(2θ)\sin(2\theta) is 1. This maximum occurs when 2θ=π22\theta = {\pi \over 2} (or any 2nπ+π/22n\pi + \pi/2), which implies θ=π4\theta = {\pi \over 4}. This value of θ\theta is indeed in the first quadrant (0,π/2)(0, \pi/2), validating our earlier assumption that the intercepts are positive.

    Substitute the maximum value of sin(2θ)=1\sin(2\theta) = 1 into the area expression to find the minimum area: Areamin=2ab1Area_{min} = {{2ab} \over {1}} Areamin=2abArea_{min} = 2ab

Step 6: Determining the Value of k

The problem states that the minimum area of the triangle is kabkab. We have just calculated this minimum area.

  • Why this step? This is the final step to answer the specific question asked by comparing our derived minimum area with the given symbolic representation.

  • Action: We are given that: MinimumArea=kabMinimum Area = kab From our calculations, we found that: MinimumArea=2abMinimum Area = 2ab By comparing these two expressions, we can equate them: kab=2abkab = 2ab Assuming aa and bb are non-zero (as they represent lengths of semi-axes and thus must be positive), we can divide both sides of the equation by abab: k=2k = 2


Important Tips and Common Pitfalls

  • Correctly Identify A and B: A very common mistake is to automatically assume A=aA=a and B=bB=b. Always carefully compare the given ellipse equation (here, x2b2+y24a2=1{{{x^2}} \over {{b^2}}} + {{{y^2}} \over {4{a^2}}} = 1) with the standard form x2A2+y2B2=1{{{x^2}} \over {{A^2}}} + {{{y^2}} \over {{B^2}}} = 1. In this problem, A=bA=b and B=2aB=2a. Misidentification will lead to incorrect intercepts and ultimately a wrong answer.
  • Understanding Absolute Values for Area: While the general area formula is 12X0Y0{1 \over 2} |X_0 Y_0|, for minimum area problems involving ellipses, the tangent point is invariably considered in the first quadrant (θ(0,π/2)\theta \in (0, \pi/2)). This ensures that cosθ\cos\theta and sinθ\sin\theta are positive, making X0X_0 and Y0Y_0 positive, which allows you to safely drop the absolute value

Practice More Conic Sections Questions

View All Questions