Skip to main content
Back to Conic Sections
JEE Main 2021
Conic Sections
Ellipse
Medium

Question

Let a tangent be drawn to the ellipse x227+y2=1{{{x^2}} \over {27}} + {y^2} = 1 at (33cosθ,sinθ)(3\sqrt 3 \cos \theta ,\sin \theta ) where 0(0,π2)0 \in \left( {0,{\pi \over 2}} \right). Then the value of θ\theta such that the sum of intercepts on axes made by this tangent is minimum is equal to :

Options

Solution

This problem is a classic example that beautifully integrates concepts from coordinate geometry (specifically, ellipses and their tangents) with differential calculus (for optimization). Our ultimate goal is to determine a specific angle θ\theta in the first quadrant that results in the minimum possible sum of the x and y-intercepts made by a tangent line to the given ellipse.


1. Understanding the Ellipse and the Parametric Point

The given equation of the ellipse is x227+y21=1{{{x^2}} \over {27}} + {{{y^2}} \over 1} = 1.

  • Why this step? To effectively work with an ellipse, it's crucial to identify its standard parameters (aa and bb) by comparing it with the general standard form of an ellipse centered at the origin: x2a2+y2b2=1{{{x^2}} \over {{a^2}}} + {{{y^2}} \over {{b^2}}} = 1.

By comparing the given equation with the standard form, we can identify:

  • a2=27    a=27=33a^2 = 27 \implies a = \sqrt{27} = 3\sqrt{3}
  • b2=1    b=1b^2 = 1 \implies b = 1

The point of tangency is given in parametric form as (33cosθ,sinθ)(3\sqrt 3 \cos \theta ,\sin \theta ).

  • Why this check? We confirm that this point indeed lies on the ellipse and matches its parametric representation. The general parametric coordinates for an ellipse are (acosθ,bsinθ)(a \cos \theta, b \sin \theta). Substituting our values for aa and bb: (33cosθ,1sinθ)(3\sqrt 3 \cos \theta, 1 \sin \theta), which perfectly matches the given point.

The condition θ(0,π2)\theta \in \left( {0,{\pi \over 2}} \right) is critical. It implies that the point of tangency is in the first quadrant, which means sinθ\sin\theta, cosθ\cos\theta, tanθ\tan\theta, and their reciprocals (cscθ\csc\theta, secθ\sec\theta, cotθ\cot\theta) will all be positive. This will be important when we perform divisions involving these trigonometric functions later, ensuring they are non-zero and positive.

2. Equation of the Tangent Line to an Ellipse

The most efficient way to find the equation of a tangent to an ellipse when the point of tangency is given in parametric form is to use the dedicated parametric tangent formula.

  • Key Concept/Formula: The general equation of a tangent to an ellipse x2a2+y2b2=1{{{x^2}} \over {{a^2}}} + {{{y^2}} \over {{b^2}}} = 1 at a parametric point (acosθ,bsinθ)(a \cos \theta, b \sin \theta) is given by: xcosθa+ysinθb=1{{x \cos \theta} \over a} + {{y \sin \theta} \over b} = 1

  • Why this formula? This formula is derived by substituting the parametric coordinates (x1=acosθ,y1=bsinθ)(x_1 = a \cos\theta, y_1 = b \sin\theta) into the general tangent equation xx1a2+yy1b2=1{{x{x_1}} \over {{a^2}}} + {{y{y_1}} \over {{b^2}}} = 1 and simplifying. It streamlines the process significantly compared to using derivatives to find the slope.

Now, we substitute the specific values of a=33a = 3\sqrt{3} and b=1b = 1 into this formula: xcosθ33+ysinθ1=1{{x \cos \theta} \over {3\sqrt 3 }} + {{y \sin \theta} \over 1} = 1 This is the equation of the tangent line to our given ellipse at the specified parametric point.

3. Calculating Intercepts on the Coordinate Axes

To find the sum of intercepts, we first need to determine the x-intercept and y-intercept of the tangent line.

  • Why this step? The problem asks us to minimize the sum of intercepts. Therefore, finding these intercepts is a direct requirement.

  • x-intercept: This is the point where the line crosses the x-axis.

    • How to find it? At the x-intercept, the y-coordinate is 00. So, we set y=0y=0 in the tangent equation: xcosθ33+(0)sinθ=1{{x \cos \theta} \over {3\sqrt 3 }} + (0)\sin \theta = 1 xcosθ33=1{{x \cos \theta} \over {3\sqrt 3 }} = 1
    • Why can we divide? Since θ(0,π2)\theta \in \left( {0,{\pi \over 2}} \right), cosθ\cos \theta is positive and thus non-zero. This allows us to safely divide by cosθ\cos \theta: x=33cosθ=33secθx = {{3\sqrt 3 } \over {\cos \theta }} = 3\sqrt 3 \sec \theta So, the x-intercept is 33secθ3\sqrt 3 \sec \theta.
  • y-intercept: This is the point where the line crosses the y-axis.

    • How to find it? At the y-intercept, the x-coordinate is 00. So, we set x=0x=0 in the tangent equation: {(0) \cos \theta} \over {3\sqrt 3 }} + y\sin \theta = 1 ysinθ=1y\sin \theta = 1
    • Why can we divide? Since θ(0,π2)\theta \in \left( {0,{\pi \over 2}} \right), sinθ\sin \theta is positive and thus non-zero. This allows us to safely divide by sinθ\sin \theta: y=1sinθ=cscθy = {1 \over {\sin \theta }} = \csc \theta So, the y-intercept is cscθ\csc \theta.

4. Forming the Function to be Minimized

Let S(θ)S(\theta) represent the sum of the intercepts on the axes.

  • Why this step? We need to define the quantity that we are asked to minimize as a function of our variable, θ\theta. S(θ)=(x-intercept)+(y-intercept)S(\theta) = (\text{x-intercept}) + (\text{y-intercept}) S(θ)=33secθ+cscθS(\theta) = 3\sqrt 3 \sec \theta + \csc \theta Our task is now to find the value of θ(0,π2)\theta \in \left( {0,{\pi \over 2}} \right) for which this function S(θ)S(\theta) attains its minimum value.

5. Optimization using Differential Calculus

To find the minimum value of S(θ)S(\theta), we employ the standard procedure from differential calculus:

  • Key Concept: For a function f(x)f(x), local minima or maxima occur at critical points where the first derivative f(x)=0f'(x) = 0 or is undefined. The second derivative test (f(x)>0f''(x) > 0 for minimum, f(x)<0f''(x) < 0 for maximum) helps distinguish between them.

Step 5.1: Calculate the First Derivative, S(θ)S'(\theta)

  • Why this step? The first derivative tells us about the rate of change of S(θ)S(\theta). Setting it to zero will help us locate points where the tangent to the curve of S(θ)S(\theta) is horizontal, which are potential minima or maxima.

Recall the derivatives of the trigonometric functions:

  • ddθ(secθ)=secθtanθ{d \over {d\theta}}(\sec \theta) = \sec \theta \tan \theta
  • ddθ(cscθ)=cscθcotθ{d \over {d\theta}}(\csc \theta) = -\csc \theta \cot \theta

Now, differentiate S(θ)S(\theta) with respect to θ\theta: S(θ)=ddθ(33secθ+cscθ)S'(\theta) = {d \over {d\theta}}(3\sqrt 3 \sec \theta + \csc \theta) S(θ)=33(secθtanθ)(cscθcotθ)S'(\theta) = 3\sqrt 3 (\sec \theta \tan \theta) - (\csc \theta \cot \theta)

Step 5.2: Set the First Derivative to Zero to Find Critical Points

  • Why this step? Setting the first derivative to zero helps us find the critical points where the slope of S(θ)S(\theta) is zero. These are the candidates for local minima or maxima. 33secθtanθcscθcotθ=03\sqrt 3 \sec \theta \tan \theta - \csc \theta \cot \theta = 0 Rearrange the equation: 33secθtanθ=cscθcotθ3\sqrt 3 \sec \theta \tan \theta = \csc \theta \cot \theta

Step 5.3: Solve the Trigonometric Equation for θ\theta

  • Why this strategy? To simplify and solve complex trigonometric equations, it's often easiest to express all trigonometric functions in terms of their fundamental components, sinθ\sin \theta and cosθ\cos \theta.

Convert all terms to sinθ\sin \theta and cosθ\cos \theta: 33(1cosθ)(sinθcosθ)=(1sinθ)(cosθsinθ)3\sqrt 3 \left( {1 \over {\cos \theta }} \right) \left( {{\sin \theta } \over {\cos \theta }} \right) = \left( {1 \over {\sin \theta }} \right) \left( {{\cos \theta } \over {\sin \theta }} \right) Simplify the expressions on both sides: 33sinθcos2θ=cosθsin2θ3\sqrt 3 {{\sin \theta } \over {{{\cos }^2}\theta }} = {{\cos \theta } \over {{{\sin }^2}\theta }} Now, cross-multiply to eliminate denominators: 33sin3θ=cos3θ3\sqrt 3 {\sin^3}\theta = {\cos^3}\theta

  • Why can we divide by cos3θ\cos^3\theta? Since θ(0,π2)\theta \in \left( {0,{\pi \over 2}} \right), cosθ\cos \theta is positive and thus non-zero. Therefore, cos3θ0\cos^3\theta \neq 0, and we can safely divide both sides by cos3θ{\cos^3}\theta: 33sin3θcos3θ=13\sqrt 3 {{\sin^3}\theta \over {{\cos^3}\theta }} = 1 33tan3θ=13\sqrt 3 {\tan^3}\theta = 1 Solve for tan3θ{\tan^3}\theta: tan3θ=133{\tan^3}\theta = {1 \over {3\sqrt 3 }} To find tanθ\tan\theta, take the cube root of both sides. It's helpful to recognize that 33=9×3=273\sqrt 3 = \sqrt{9 \times 3} = \sqrt{27}, or (3)3/2(3)^{3/2}. tanθ=(1(3)3/2)1/3=1(3)(3/2)×(1/3)=1(3)1/2=13\tan \theta = {\left( {{1 \over {{(3)^{3/2}}}}} \right)^{1/3}} = {1 \over {{(3)^{(3/2) \times (1/3)}}}} = {1 \over {{(3)^{1/2}}}} = {1 \over {\sqrt 3 }}

Now, we need to find the angle θ\theta such that tanθ=13\tan \theta = {1 \over {\sqrt 3 }}. For θ(0,π2)\theta \in \left( {0,{\pi \over 2}} \right), there is a unique value of θ\theta that satisfies this condition: θ=π6\theta = {{\pi \over 6}}

Step 5.4: Verify Minimum using the Second Derivative Test (Optional but Recommended)

  • Why this step? While setting S(θ)=0S'(\theta)=0 gives critical points, it doesn't distinguish between local minima, local maxima, or inflection points. The second derivative test provides this confirmation. If S(θ)>0S''(\theta) > 0 at the critical point, it's a local minimum.

Let's find the second derivative, S(θ)S''(\theta): S(θ)=33secθtanθcscθcotθS'(\theta) = 3\sqrt 3 \sec \theta \tan \theta - \csc \theta \cot \theta Using the product rule and chain rule for differentiation: ddθ(secθtanθ)=(secθtanθ)tanθ+secθ(sec2θ)=secθtan2θ+sec3θ{d \over {d\theta}}(\sec \theta \tan \theta) = (\sec \theta \tan \theta)\tan \theta + \sec \theta (\sec^2 \theta) = \sec \theta \tan^2 \theta + \sec^3 \theta ddθ(cscθcotθ)=[(cscθcotθ)cotθ+cscθ(csc2θ)]=cscθcot2θ+csc3θ{d \over {d\theta}}(-\csc \theta \cot \theta) = -[(-\csc \theta \cot \theta)\cot \theta + \csc \theta (-\csc^2 \theta)] = \csc \theta \cot^2 \theta + \csc^3 \theta So, S(θ)=33(secθtan2θ+sec3θ)+(cscθcot2θ+csc3θ)S''(\theta) = 3\sqrt 3 (\sec \theta \tan^2 \theta + \sec^3 \theta) + (\csc \theta \cot^2 \theta + \csc^3 \theta) For θ(0,π2)\theta \in \left( {0,{\pi \over 2}} \right), all trigonometric functions (secθ,tanθ,cscθ,cotθ\sec\theta, \tan\theta, \csc\theta, \cot\theta) are positive. Consequently, all terms in S(θ)S''(\theta) are positive. Therefore, S(θ)>0S''(\theta) > 0 for all θ(0,π2)\theta \in \left( {0,{\pi \over 2}} \right). This confirms that the critical point θ=π/6\theta = \pi/6 indeed corresponds to a local minimum for S(θ)S(\theta).

6. Conclusion

The value of θ\theta that minimizes the sum of intercepts on the axes made by the tangent is π6{{\pi \over 6}}.

The final answer is π6\boxed{{{\pi \over 6}}}.


Summary of Key Concepts and Tips for Success:

  • Parametric Tangent Equation: For problems involving tangents to ellipses at parametric points, remember the formula $${{x \cos \theta}

Practice More Conic Sections Questions

View All Questions