Skip to main content
Back to Conic Sections
JEE Main 2023
Conic Sections
Parabola
Medium

Question

Let P : y 2 = 4ax, a > 0 be a parabola with focus S. Let the tangents to the parabola P make an angle of π4{\pi \over 4} with the line y = 3x + 5 touch the parabola P at A and B. Then the value of a for which A, B and S are collinear is :

Options

Solution

This problem is a comprehensive test of your understanding of parabolas, tangents, angles between lines, and collinearity. We will systematically approach it by first identifying the key elements, then finding the slopes of the tangents, determining the points of contact, and finally applying the collinearity condition.


1. Fundamental Concepts and Formulas

Let's begin by recalling the essential tools we'll be using:

  • Parabola PP: Given by the equation y2=4axy^2 = 4ax, where a>0a > 0.
    • Focus (S): For a parabola y2=4axy^2 = 4ax, the focus is located at S(a,0)S(a, 0).
    • Equation of a Tangent in Slope Form: A line with slope mm that is tangent to the parabola y2=4axy^2 = 4ax has the equation y=mx+amy = mx + \frac{a}{m}. This formula is valid for m0m \neq 0.
    • Point of Tangency: The point where the line y=mx+amy = mx + \frac{a}{m} touches the parabola y2=4axy^2 = 4ax is T(am2,2am)T\left(\frac{a}{m^2}, \frac{2a}{m}\right).
  • Angle Between Two Lines: If two lines have slopes m1m_1 and m2m_2, the acute angle θ\theta between them is given by the formula: tanθ=m1m21+m1m2\tan \theta = \left| \frac{m_1 - m_2}{1 + m_1 m_2} \right|
  • Collinearity of Three Points: Three points (x1,y1)(x_1, y_1), (x2,y2)(x_2, y_2), and (x3,y3)(x_3, y_3) are collinear if the slope of the line segment connecting the first two points is equal to the slope of the line segment connecting the second two points. That is: y2y1x2x1=y3y2x3x2\frac{y_2 - y_1}{x_2 - x_1} = \frac{y_3 - y_2}{x_3 - x_2} (Alternatively, their determinant form for area of triangle being zero can be used: x1(y2y3)+x2(y3y1)+x3(y1y2)=0x_1(y_2 - y_3) + x_2(y_3 - y_1) + x_3(y_1 - y_2) = 0).

2. Step 1: Determine the Focus S of the Parabola

The given parabola is y2=4axy^2 = 4ax.

  • Explanation: For a standard parabola y2=4axy^2 = 4ax with its vertex at the origin and axis along the x-axis, the focus is defined as the point (a,0)(a, 0). This is a direct application of the standard form.
  • Calculation: Thus, the focus SS is at (a,0)(a, 0).

3. Step 2: Find the Slopes of the Tangents

We are given that the tangents make an angle of π4\frac{\pi}{4} with the line y=3x+5y = 3x + 5.

  • Explanation: We need to find the slopes of the lines (tangents) that satisfy this angular condition. We'll use the formula for the angle between two lines.
  • Identify given slope: The line y=3x+5y = 3x + 5 is in the slope-intercept form y=mx+cy = mx + c. Its slope is m1=3m_1 = 3.
  • Let tangent slope be m2m_2: Let mm be the slope of the tangents we are looking for.
  • Apply the angle formula: The angle θ=π4\theta = \frac{\pi}{4}, so tanθ=tanπ4=1\tan \theta = \tan \frac{\pi}{4} = 1. tanπ4=m31+m3\tan \frac{\pi}{4} = \left| \frac{m - 3}{1 + m \cdot 3} \right| 1=m31+3m1 = \left| \frac{m - 3}{1 + 3m} \right|
  • Solve for mm: This absolute value equation gives two possibilities: Case 1: m31+3m=1\frac{m - 3}{1 + 3m} = 1 m3=1+3mm - 3 = 1 + 3m 4=2m-4 = 2m mA=2m_A = -2 Case 2: m31+3m=1\frac{m - 3}{1 + 3m} = -1 m3=(1+3m)m - 3 = -(1 + 3m) m3=13mm - 3 = -1 - 3m 4m=24m = 2 mB=12m_B = \frac{1}{2}
  • Result: We have two possible slopes for the tangents: mA=2m_A = -2 and mB=12m_B = \frac{1}{2}.

4. Step 3: Determine the Points of Tangency A and B

Now we use the slopes found in Step 2 to determine the coordinates of the points A and B where the tangents touch the parabola.

  • Explanation: We will use the formula for the point of tangency (am2,2am)\left(\frac{a}{m^2}, \frac{2a}{m}\right) for each slope.
  • For slope mA=2m_A = -2: The point of tangency A is: A=(a(2)2,2a2)=(a4,a)A = \left( \frac{a}{(-2)^2}, \frac{2a}{-2} \right) = \left( \frac{a}{4}, -a \right)
  • For slope mB=12m_B = \frac{1}{2}: The point of tangency B is: B=(a(1/2)2,2a1/2)=(a1/4,4a)=(4a,4a)B = \left( \frac{a}{(1/2)^2}, \frac{2a}{1/2} \right) = \left( \frac{a}{1/4}, 4a \right) = \left( 4a, 4a \right)
  • Result: The points of tangency are A(a4,a)A\left(\frac{a}{4}, -a\right) and B(4a,4a)B(4a, 4a).

5. Step 4: Apply the Collinearity Condition for A, B, and S

We are given that points A, B, and the focus S are collinear.

  • Explanation: We will use the condition that the slope of AS must be equal to the slope of BS. This is a robust way to check collinearity.

  • Points:

    • S=(a,0)S = (a, 0)
    • A=(a4,a)A = \left(\frac{a}{4}, -a\right)
    • B=(4a,4a)B = (4a, 4a)
  • Calculate slope of SA (mSAm_{SA}): mSA=a0a4a=a3a4=43m_{SA} = \frac{-a - 0}{\frac{a}{4} - a} = \frac{-a}{-\frac{3a}{4}} = \frac{4}{3}

    • Tip: Be careful with fractions and signs during simplification. We can assume a0a \neq 0 since a>0a>0 is given.
  • Calculate slope of SB (mSBm_{SB}): mSB=4a04aa=4a3a=43m_{SB} = \frac{4a - 0}{4a - a} = \frac{4a}{3a} = \frac{4}{3}

    • Observation: Notice that mSA=mSB=43m_{SA} = m_{SB} = \frac{4}{3}. This means that A, B, and S are indeed collinear, regardless of the value of aa (as long as a>0a > 0).
  • Re-evaluating the question: The question asks for "the value of aa for which A, B and S are collinear". Since the slopes are equal for any a>0a>0, this implies that A, B, and S are always collinear for any a>0a > 0.

  • Wait, is there a catch? Let's double-check. The problem asks for "the value of aa". If it's "any a>0a > 0", then option (D) would be correct. However, the provided correct answer is (A) 8 only. This suggests there might be an implicit condition or a subtle point missed.

    Let's check the alternative collinearity condition (Area of triangle = 0) to be absolutely sure. xS(yAyB)+xA(yByS)+xB(ySyA)=0x_S(y_A - y_B) + x_A(y_B - y_S) + x_B(y_S - y_A) = 0 a(a4a)+a4(4a0)+4a(0(a))=0a(-a - 4a) + \frac{a}{4}(4a - 0) + 4a(0 - (-a)) = 0 a(5a)+a4(4a)+4a(a)=0a(-5a) + \frac{a}{4}(4a) + 4a(a) = 0 5a2+a2+4a2=0-5a^2 + a^2 + 4a^2 = 0 (5+1+4)a2=0(-5 + 1 + 4)a^2 = 0 0a2=00 \cdot a^2 = 0 This equation 0=00 = 0 is always true for any aa. This confirms that A, B, and S are collinear for any a>0a > 0.

    This result directly points to option (D) "any a > 0". If the provided correct answer (A) is "8 only", there might be a misunderstanding of the question or a typo in the provided options/answer.

    Let's consider a crucial property of parabolas: The line segment AB, connecting the points of tangency of two perpendicular tangents, passes through the focus. The slopes of the tangents we found are mA=2m_A = -2 and mB=12m_B = \frac{1}{2}. Their product is mAmB=(2)(12)=1m_A \cdot m_B = (-2) \cdot (\frac{1}{2}) = -1.

    • Key Property: Tangents to a parabola y2=4axy^2 = 4ax are perpendicular if and only if they intersect on the directrix x=ax = -a.
    • Key Property: The chord of contact connecting the points of tangency of two perpendicular tangents passes through the focus. This is a well-known property. Since mAmB=1m_A \cdot m_B = -1, the tangents are perpendicular. Therefore, the chord AB (connecting the points of tangency) must pass through the focus S. This means A, B, and S are always collinear for any a>0a > 0.

    Given the analysis, the answer must be (D) "any a > 0". If the provided answer (A) is correct, then the question statement or options might be flawed. Assuming the question is correctly stated and the standard properties of parabolas apply, the derived answer is (D).

    Let's assume there is no trick and the question implies a unique 'a' must exist, which contradicts our findings. If this were a multiple-choice exam, and option (D) was available, it would be the correct choice based on this proof. If (D) were not an option, it would indicate an issue with the question itself. Since (D) is an option, it should be the answer.

    Self-correction/Double check: Is there any condition for aa that could make the slopes undefined? No, a>0a>0 is given. Are A, B, or S ever coincident? A=(a/4,a)A = (a/4, -a), B=(4a,4a)B=(4a, 4a), S=(a,0)S=(a,0). If A=SA=S, then a/4=aa/4=a and a=0-a=0, implying a=0a=0, which contradicts a>0a>0. If B=SB=S, then 4a=a4a=a and 4a=04a=0, implying a=0a=0, contradicts a>0a>0. So the points are distinct.

    The conclusion remains: A, B, and S are collinear for any a>0a > 0. Therefore, the value of aa can be any positive number.

    Final Answer based on derivation: The points A, B, and S are collinear for any value of a>0a > 0.

    If we must choose one of the options (A), (B), (C), and (D) and (A) is the intended correct answer, then there's a serious discrepancy with the problem statement or the expected solution path. However, as an expert teacher, I must provide the correct derivation based on mathematical principles.

    Let's re-read the original problem and provided solution snippet: "Current Solution: This problem combines concepts of parabolas, tangents, angles between lines, and collinearity. We will systematically break it down into finding the slopes of the tangents, determining the points of contact, identifying the focus, and finally applying the condition for collinearity. --- 1. Fundamental Concepts and Formulas Before we begin, let's review the essential tools we'll be using: * Parabola: The standard equation of a parabola with its vertex at the origin and axis along the x-axis is y2=4axy^2 = 4ax, where a>0a > 0. * Focus (S): For y2=4axy^2 = 4ax, the focus is at S(a,0)S(a, 0). * Tangent in"

    The provided "current solution" snippet is incomplete. It doesn't show the calculation for aa. My derivation leads to (D). If the answer is indeed (A), then the problem statement must have some additional constraint or a

Practice More Conic Sections Questions

View All Questions