Let f : (−1, 1) → R be a function defined by f(x) = max {−∣x∣,−1−x2}. If K be the set of all points at which f is not differentiable, then K has exactly -
Options
Solution
Key Concepts and Formulas
Definition of Absolute Value:∣x∣=x if x≥0 and ∣x∣=−x if x<0.
Differentiability of Maximum Function: The function h(x)=max(g(x),s(x)) is not differentiable at points where g(x)=s(x) and the derivatives of g(x) and s(x) are different at those points.
Derivative of ∣x∣:dxd∣x∣=∣x∣x for x=0. This is equivalent to 1 for x>0 and -1 for x<0.
Derivative of a2−x2:dxda2−x2=2a2−x2−2x=a2−x2−x for a2−x2>0.
Step-by-Step Solution
Step 1: Analyze the function and the domain.
The function is given by f(x)=max{−∣x∣,−1−x2} for x∈(−1,1). We need to find the points in this interval where f(x) is not differentiable.
Step 2: Simplify the terms inside the maximum function.
We have two functions to compare: g(x)=−∣x∣ and s(x)=−1−x2.
Since the domain is (−1,1), we know that 1−x2>0.
Step 3: Determine where the two functions are equal.
The function f(x) will be non-differentiable at points where −∣x∣=−1−x2, which simplifies to ∣x∣=1−x2.
Squaring both sides, we get x2=1−x2.
This leads to 2x2=1, so x2=21.
Therefore, x=21 and x=−21.
Both of these points lie within the domain (−1,1).
Step 4: Analyze the differentiability of each term.
The function g(x)=−∣x∣ is not differentiable at x=0. However, x=0 is not a point where g(x)=s(x).
The function s(x)=−1−x2 is differentiable for x∈(−1,1). Its derivative is s′(x)=−1−x2−x=1−x2x.
Step 5: Evaluate the derivatives of g(x) and s(x) at the points of equality.
We found that the two functions are equal at x=21 and x=−21.
Let's find the derivatives of g(x)=−∣x∣ and s(x)=−1−x2 at these points.
For x>0, ∣x∣=x, so g(x)=−x. The derivative is g′(x)=−1.
For x<0, ∣x∣=−x, so g(x)=−(−x)=x. The derivative is g′(x)=1.
The derivative of s(x) is s′(x)=1−x2x.
Case 1: x=21
At this point, x>0, so g′(x)=−1.
The derivative of s(x) is s′(21)=1−(21)221=1−2121=2121=2121=1.
Since g′(21)=−1 and s′(21)=1, and −1=1, the function f(x) is not differentiable at x=21.
Case 2: x=−21
At this point, x<0, so g′(x)=1.
The derivative of s(x) is s′(−21)=1−(−21)2−21=1−21−21=21−21=21−21=−1.
Since g′(−21)=1 and s′(−21)=−1, and 1=−1, the function f(x) is not differentiable at x=−21.
Step 6: Consider the point x=0.
At x=0, ∣x∣=0 and 1−x2=1−0=1.
So, −∣x∣=0 and −1−x2=−1.
Thus, f(0)=max{0,−1}=0.
The function g(x)=−∣x∣ is not differentiable at x=0. However, the definition of f(x) as the maximum of two functions means we only need to consider points where the two functions are equal and their derivatives differ. At x=0, the two functions are not equal.
Let's check the differentiability of f(x) around x=0.
For x close to 0 and x>0, f(x)=max{−x,−1−x2}. Since x is small and positive, −x is small and negative. −1−x2 is close to −1. So f(x)=−x.
For x close to 0 and x<0, f(x)=max{x,−1−x2}. Since x is small and negative, x is small and negative. −1−x2 is close to −1. So f(x)=x.
Thus, for x in a neighborhood of 0 (excluding 0 itself), f(x)=−∣x∣.
The derivative of −∣x∣ is −1 for x>0 and 1 for x<0. The left-hand derivative at x=0 is 1 and the right-hand derivative is −1. Therefore, f(x) is not differentiable at x=0.
Step 7: Consolidate the points of non-differentiability.
The points where f(x) is not differentiable are x=21, x=−21, and x=0.
All these points are within the domain (−1,1).
Therefore, the set K of all points at which f is not differentiable has exactly three elements.
Common Mistakes & Tips
Incorrectly handling the absolute value: Remember that ∣x∣ has a point of non-differentiability at x=0. This needs to be considered even if it's not a point where the two functions inside the max are equal.
Forgetting to check the derivatives at the points of equality: It's not enough for the two functions to be equal; their derivatives must also be different at those points for non-differentiability.
Domain restrictions: Always ensure the points of non-differentiability lie within the given domain of the function.
Summary
The function f(x)=max{−∣x∣,−1−x2} is analyzed for differentiability in the interval (−1,1). The points of potential non-differentiability occur where the two arguments of the maximum function are equal, i.e., −∣x∣=−1−x2, which simplifies to ∣x∣=1−x2. Squaring both sides leads to x2=1−x2, giving x2=1/2, so x=±21. At these points, we compared the derivatives of −∣x∣ and −1−x2 and found they were different, confirming non-differentiability. Additionally, the term −∣x∣ itself is not differentiable at x=0. We examined the behavior of f(x) around x=0 and found that f(x)=−∣x∣ in a neighborhood of 0, making f(x) non-differentiable at x=0. Thus, there are three points of non-differentiability: 0, 21, and −21.