Question
Consider the function defined by and the function defined by
Options
Solution
Key Concepts and Formulas
- Continuity at a point : A function is continuous at if .
- Differentiability at a point : A function is differentiable at if the left-hand derivative and the right-hand derivative at are equal. That is, .
- Monotonicity of a function: A function is decreasing if in the given interval.
- Minimum of a function: For a decreasing function on an interval , the minimum value is .
Step-by-Step Solution
Step 1: Analyze the function and its derivative. The function is given by for . We find the derivative of : . To determine the monotonicity of , we examine the sign of in the interval . . Since , we have , which implies . Thus, for all . This means is strictly decreasing on the interval .
Step 2: Determine the expression for for . The function is defined as for . Since is a decreasing function on , for any in , the minimum value of for occurs at . Therefore, for , .
Step 3: Define the function piecewise. Combining the definition from the problem statement and our finding in Step 2, we have:
Step 4: Check for continuity of at . To check for continuity at , we need to evaluate the left-hand limit, the right-hand limit, and the function value at . Left-hand limit: . Right-hand limit: . Function value at : . Since , the function is continuous at .
Step 5: Check for differentiability of at . To check for differentiability at , we need to find the left-hand derivative and the right-hand derivative at . Left-hand derivative: The derivative of the first piece is . So, the left-hand derivative at is: . Right-hand derivative: The derivative of the second piece is . So, the right-hand derivative at is: . Since the left-hand derivative () is not equal to the right-hand derivative (), the function is not differentiable at .
Step 6: Analyze the continuity and differentiability for and . For , . This is a rational function, and its denominator is non-zero in this interval. Thus, is continuous and differentiable for all . For , . This is a linear function, which is continuous and differentiable for all .
Step 7: Conclude about the properties of at . From Step 4, is continuous at . From Step 5, is not differentiable at .
Therefore, is continuous but not differentiable at .
Common Mistakes & Tips
- Incorrectly evaluating the minimum: Remember that for a decreasing function, the minimum on an interval occurs at the right endpoint .
- Forgetting to check both left and right derivatives: Differentiability at a point requires the equality of both the left-hand and right-hand derivatives.
- Assuming differentiability implies continuity: While differentiability implies continuity, the converse is not always true. A function can be continuous at a point but not differentiable there (e.g., sharp corners or cusps).
Summary
We first analyzed the function and found it to be strictly decreasing on . This allowed us to determine that for , . The function was then defined piecewise. We checked the continuity of at by comparing the left-hand limit, right-hand limit, and the function value, all of which were equal to . Next, we checked the differentiability at by calculating the left-hand derivative () and the right-hand derivative (). Since these were not equal, is not differentiable at . Thus, is continuous but not differentiable at .
The final answer is \boxed{A}.