Question
Which of the following is the negation of the statement "for all M > 0, there exists xS such that x M" ?
Options
Solution
Key Concepts and Formulas
- Negation of "for all x, P(x)" is "there exists x, such that not P(x)". Symbolically, .
- Negation of "there exists x, such that P(x)" is "for all x, not P(x)". Symbolically, .
- The negation of is .
Step-by-Step Solution
Step 1: Identify the original statement and its components.
The given statement is: "For all , there exists such that ." We can express this symbolically as: .
Step 2: Negate the outer quantifier.
The original statement starts with "for all ". The negation of "for all" is "there exists". So, the negation will start with "there exists ". Symbolically: .
Step 3: Negate the inner quantifier.
Now we need to negate "there exists such that ". The negation of "there exists" is "for all". So, the negation of "there exists such that " is "for all , ". Symbolically: .
Step 4: Negate the inequality.
The negation of is . Therefore, the complete negation is "there exists , such that for all , ". Symbolically: .
Step 5: Convert the symbolic form back to English. The statement translates to "there exists , such that for all ".
Common Mistakes & Tips
- Remember to negate every part of the statement, including quantifiers and inequalities.
- The order of quantifiers is important. Changing the order can drastically change the meaning of the statement.
- Be careful with inequalities. The negation of "greater than or equal to" is "strictly less than".
Summary
We are asked to find the negation of the statement "for all M > 0, there exists xS such that x M". We negate the quantifiers one by one, changing "for all" to "there exists" and vice versa, and also negate the inequality. This results in the statement "there exists M > 0, such that x < M for all xS".
Final Answer
The final answer is \boxed{there exists M > 0, such that x < M for all xS}, which corresponds to option (A).