Skip to main content
Back to Matrices & Determinants
JEE Main 2023
Matrices & Determinants
Matrices and Determinants
Medium

Question

Let p and p + 2 be prime numbers and let Δ=p!(p+1)!(p+2)!(p+1)!(p+2)!(p+3)!(p+2)!(p+3)!(p+4)!\Delta=\left|\begin{array}{ccc} \mathrm{p} ! & (\mathrm{p}+1) ! & (\mathrm{p}+2) ! \\ (\mathrm{p}+1) ! & (\mathrm{p}+2) ! & (\mathrm{p}+3) ! \\ (\mathrm{p}+2) ! & (\mathrm{p}+3) ! & (\mathrm{p}+4) ! \end{array}\right| Then the sum of the maximum values of α\alpha and β\beta, such that pα\mathrm{p}^{\alpha} and (p+2)β(\mathrm{p}+2)^{\beta} divide Δ\Delta, is __________.

Answer: 1

Solution

1. Key Concepts and Formulas

  • Determinant Properties:
    • Factoring Common Terms: A common factor from any row or column can be factored out of the determinant. If a factor kk is common to all elements of a row/column, then det(A)=kdet(A)\det(A) = k \cdot \det(A').
    • Row/Column Operations: The value of a determinant remains unchanged if we apply the operation RiRi+kRjR_i \to R_i + k R_j (or CiCi+kCjC_i \to C_i + k C_j). This is particularly useful for creating zeros.
    • Vandermonde Determinant: A determinant of the form 111xyzx2y2z2=(yx)(zx)(zy)\left|\begin{array}{ccc} 1 & 1 & 1 \\ x & y & z \\ x^2 & y^2 & z^2 \end{array}\right| = (y-x)(z-x)(z-y). Related forms can often be simplified to this.
  • Factorials: The definition n!=n×(n1)××1n! = n \times (n-1) \times \dots \times 1. Also, (n+k)!=(n+k)(n+k1)(n+1)n!(n+k)! = (n+k)(n+k-1)\dots(n+1)n!.
  • Legendre's Formula: The exponent of a prime qq in the prime factorization of n!n! is given by Eq(n!)=k=1nqkE_q(n!) = \sum_{k=1}^{\infty} \left\lfloor \frac{n}{q^k} \right\rfloor. This formula helps determine the maximum power of a prime that divides a factorial.
  • Prime Numbers: A prime number is a natural number greater than 1 that has no positive divisors other than 1 and itself. The condition "p and p+2 are prime numbers" implies pp must be an odd prime (since if p=2p=2, p+2=4p+2=4 is not prime), so p3p \ge 3. This means pp and p+2p+2 are distinct odd primes.

2. Step-by-Step Solution

Step 1: Simplify the Determinant by Factoring

The given determinant is: Δ=p!(p+1)!(p+2)!(p+1)!(p+2)!(p+3)!(p+2)!(p+3)!(p+4)!\Delta=\left|\begin{array}{ccc} \mathrm{p} ! & (\mathrm{p}+1) ! & (\mathrm{p}+2) ! \\ (\mathrm{p}+1) ! & (\mathrm{p}+2) ! & (\mathrm{p}+3) ! \\ (\mathrm{p}+2) ! & (\mathrm{p}+3) ! & (\mathrm{p}+4) ! \end{array}\right| We observe common factors in each column. We factor out p!p! from C1C_1, (p+1)!(p+1)! from C2C_2, and (p+2)!(p+2)! from C3C_3.

  • From Column 1 (C1C_1): p!(1p+1(p+1)(p+2))p! \begin{pmatrix} 1 \\ p+1 \\ (p+1)(p+2) \end{pmatrix}
  • From Column 2 (C2C_2): (p+1)!(1p+2(p+2)(p+3))(p+1)! \begin{pmatrix} 1 \\ p+2 \\ (p+2)(p+3) \end{pmatrix}
  • From Column 3 (C3C_3): (p+2)!(1p+3(p+3)(p+4))(p+2)! \begin{pmatrix} 1 \\ p+3 \\ (p+3)(p+4) \end{pmatrix}

Applying the determinant property of factoring common terms from columns, we get: Δ=p!(p+1)!(p+2)!111p+1p+2p+3(p+1)(p+2)(p+2)(p+3)(p+3)(p+4)\Delta = p! \cdot (p+1)! \cdot (p+2)! \left|\begin{array}{ccc} 1 & 1 & 1 \\ p+1 & p+2 & p+3 \\ (p+1)(p+2) & (p+2)(p+3) & (p+3)(p+4) \end{array}\right| Let K=p!(p+1)!(p+2)!K = p! (p+1)! (p+2)! and let DD be the remaining determinant.

Step 2: Evaluate the Simplified Determinant DD

The determinant DD is: D=111p+1p+2p+3(p+1)(p+2)(p+2)(p+3)(p+3)(p+4)D = \left|\begin{array}{ccc} 1 & 1 & 1 \\ p+1 & p+2 & p+3 \\ (p+1)(p+2) & (p+2)(p+3) & (p+3)(p+4) \end{array}\right| To simplify DD, we recognize it as a form related to a Vandermonde determinant. Let x=p+1,y=p+2,z=p+3x=p+1, y=p+2, z=p+3. Then DD becomes: D=111xyzx(x+1)y(y+1)z(z+1)D = \left|\begin{array}{ccc} 1 & 1 & 1 \\ x & y & z \\ x(x+1) & y(y+1) & z(z+1) \end{array}\right| We can simplify this by performing a row operation R3R3R2R_3 \to R_3 - R_2: D=111xyzx2+xxy2+yyz2+zz=111xyzx2y2z2D = \left|\begin{array}{ccc} 1 & 1 & 1 \\ x & y & z \\ x^2+x-x & y^2+y-y & z^2+z-z \end{array}\right| = \left|\begin{array}{ccc} 1 & 1 & 1 \\ x & y & z \\ x^2 & y^2 & z^2 \end{array}\right| This is a standard Vandermonde determinant, which evaluates to (yx)(zx)(zy)(y-x)(z-x)(z-y). Substitute back x=p+1,y=p+2,z=p+3x=p+1, y=p+2, z=p+3:

  • yx=(p+2)(p+1)=1y-x = (p+2)-(p+1) = 1
  • zx=(p+3)(p+1)=2z-x = (p+3)-(p+1) = 2
  • zy=(p+3)(p+2)=1z-y = (p+3)-(p+2) = 1 So, D=(1)(2)(1)=2D = (1)(2)(1) = 2.

Thus, the determinant Δ\Delta simplifies to: Δ=2p!(p+1)!(p+2)!\Delta = 2 \cdot p! \cdot (p+1)! \cdot (p+2)!

Step 3: Determine the Exponent of pp (α\alpha)

We are given that pp and p+2p+2 are prime numbers.

  • If p=2p=2, then p+2=4p+2=4, which is not prime. Therefore, pp must be an odd prime.
  • This implies p3p \ge 3.
  • Since p3p \ge 3, pp and p+2p+2 are distinct odd prime numbers.

We need to find the maximum value of α\alpha such that pαp^{\alpha} divides Δ\Delta. This is equivalent to finding the exponent of prime pp in the prime factorization of Δ\Delta, denoted as Ep(Δ)E_p(\Delta). Δ=2p!(p+1)!(p+2)!\Delta = 2 \cdot p! \cdot (p+1)! \cdot (p+2)! Since pp is an odd prime, p2p \ne 2, so pp does not divide 2. Thus, Ep(2)=0E_p(2) = 0. The total exponent of pp in Δ\Delta is the sum of exponents from its factors: α=Ep(Δ)=Ep(2)+Ep(p!)+Ep((p+1)!)+Ep((p+2)!)\alpha = E_p(\Delta) = E_p(2) + E_p(p!) + E_p((p+1)!) + E_p((p+2)!) Using Legendre's formula Eq(n!)=k=1n/qkE_q(n!) = \sum_{k=1}^{\infty} \lfloor n/q^k \rfloor:

  • Ep(p!)=p/p+p/p2+=1+0+=1E_p(p!) = \lfloor p/p \rfloor + \lfloor p/p^2 \rfloor + \dots = 1 + 0 + \dots = 1. (Since p3p \ge 3, p2>pp^2 > p, so higher powers of pp don't contribute).
  • Ep((p+1)!)=(p+1)/p+(p+1)/p2+=1+0+=1E_p((p+1)!) = \lfloor (p+1)/p \rfloor + \lfloor (p+1)/p^2 \rfloor + \dots = 1 + 0 + \dots = 1. (Since p3p \ge 3, p+1<2pp+1 < 2p, so (p+1)/p=1\lfloor (p+1)/p \rfloor = 1. Also p2>p+1p^2 > p+1, so higher powers of pp don't contribute).
  • Ep((p+2)!)=(p+2)/p+(p+2)/p2+=1+0+=1E_p((p+2)!) = \lfloor (p+2)/p \rfloor + \lfloor (p+2)/p^2 \rfloor + \dots = 1 + 0 + \dots = 1. (Since p3p \ge 3, p+2<2pp+2 < 2p, so (p+2)/p=1\lfloor (p+2)/p \rfloor = 1. Also p2>p+2p^2 > p+2, so higher powers of pp don't contribute).

Summing these exponents: α=0+1+1+1=3\alpha = 0 + 1 + 1 + 1 = 3

Step 4: Determine the Exponent of (p+2)(p+2) (β\beta)

Similarly, we need to find the maximum value of β\beta such that (p+2)β(p+2)^{\beta} divides Δ\Delta. This is Ep+2(Δ)E_{p+2}(\Delta). Since p+2p+2 is an odd prime, p+22p+2 \ne 2, so p+2p+2 does not divide 2. Thus, Ep+2(2)=0E_{p+2}(2) = 0. β=Ep+2(Δ)=Ep+2(2)+Ep+2(p!)+Ep+2((p+1)!)+Ep+2((p+2)!)\beta = E_{p+2}(\Delta) = E_{p+2}(2) + E_{p+2}(p!) + E_{p+2}((p+1)!) + E_{p+2}((p+2)!) Using Legendre's formula:

  • Ep+2(p!)=0E_{p+2}(p!) = 0. (Since p+2>pp+2 > p, p+2p+2 cannot be a factor of p!p!).
  • Ep+2((p+1)!)=0E_{p+2}((p+1)!) = 0. (Since p+2>p+1p+2 > p+1, p+2p+2 cannot be a factor of (p+1)!(p+1)!).
  • Ep+2((p+2)!)=(p+2)/(p+2)+(p+2)/(p+2)2+=1+0+=1E_{p+2}((p+2)!) = \lfloor (p+2)/(p+2) \rfloor + \lfloor (p+2)/(p+2)^2 \rfloor + \dots = 1 + 0 + \dots = 1. (Since p+25p+2 \ge 5, (p+2)2>p+2(p+2)^2 > p+2, so higher powers don't contribute).

Summing these exponents: β=0+0+0+1=1\beta = 0 + 0 + 0 + 1 = 1

Step 5: Calculate the Sum α+β\alpha + \beta

We found α=3\alpha = 3 and β=1\beta = 1. The sum of the maximum values of α\alpha and β\beta is: α+β=3+1=4\alpha + \beta = 3 + 1 = 4

3. Common Mistakes & Tips

  • Forgetting to factor out all common terms: Ensure all possible common factors are extracted from rows/columns to simplify the determinant as much as possible.
  • Errors in Vandermonde determinant calculation: Be careful with the order of terms in (yx)(zx)(zy)(y-x)(z-x)(z-y).
  • Incorrect application of Legendre's Formula: Remember that Eq(n!)=n/qkE_q(n!) = \sum \lfloor n/q^k \rfloor. For q>nq > n, Eq(n!)=0E_q(n!) = 0. For qnq \le n, ensure all relevant powers of qq are considered, though for small nn relative to qq, often only n/q\lfloor n/q \rfloor is non-zero.
  • Misinterpreting "p and p+2 are prime numbers": This condition is crucial for determining the behavior of pp and p+2p+2 as prime factors (e.g., p2p \ne 2, pp and p+2p+2 are distinct primes).

4. Summary

The problem required us to first simplify a determinant involving factorials and then find the maximum powers of primes pp and p+2p+2 that divide the simplified determinant. We factored out common factorial terms from the determinant, reducing it to a product of factorials and a simpler 3×33 \times 3 determinant. This simpler determinant was identified as a form of a Vandermonde determinant, which evaluated to 2. Thus, Δ=2p!(p+1)!(p+2)!\Delta = 2 \cdot p! (p+1)! (p+2)!. Using Legendre's formula and the property that pp and p+2p+2 are distinct odd primes, we calculated the exponent of pp in Δ\Delta as α=3\alpha=3 and the exponent of p+2p+2 in Δ\Delta as β=1\beta=1. The sum of these maximum values is α+β=3+1=4\alpha + \beta = 3 + 1 = 4.

5. Final Answer

The final answer is 4\boxed{4}.

Practice More Matrices & Determinants Questions

View All Questions