Skip to main content
Back to Matrices & Determinants
JEE Main 2019
Matrices & Determinants
Matrices and Determinants
Medium

Question

The number of distinct real roots of the equation, \left| {\matrix{ {\cos x} & {\sin x} & {\sin x} \cr {\sin x} & {\cos x} & {\sin x} \cr {\sin x} & {\sin x} & {\cos x} \cr } } \right| = 0 in the interval [π4,π4]\left[ { - {\pi \over 4},{\pi \over 4}} \right] is :

Options

Solution

Key Concepts and Formulas:

This problem primarily involves the properties of determinants and solving trigonometric equations.

  1. Determinant Properties:
    • The value of a determinant remains unchanged if we apply row operations of the form RiRi+kRjR_i \to R_i + kR_j (or column operations CiCi+kCjC_i \to C_i + kC_j).
    • If a row or column has a common factor, it can be taken out of the determinant.
    • If a row or column consists entirely of zeros, the determinant is zero.
    • If two rows or columns are identical, the determinant is zero.
    • The determinant of an upper or lower triangular matrix is the product of its diagonal elements.
  2. Trigonometric Equations: Solving equations involving sinx\sin x, cosx\cos x, or tanx\tan x and finding solutions within a specified interval.

Step-by-Step Solution:

We are given the equation: \left| {\matrix{ {\cos x} & {\sin x} & {\sin x} \cr {\sin x} & {\cos x} & {\sin x} \cr {\sin x} & {\sin x} & {\cos x} \cr } } \right| = 0

Our goal is to find the values of xx in the interval [π4,π4]\left[ { - {\pi \over 4},{\pi \over 4}} \right] that satisfy this equation.

Step 1: Simplify the determinant using row operations. To simplify the determinant, we look for ways to create common factors or zeros. A common strategy for determinants where all elements are similar (like here, cosx\cos x on diagonal and sinx\sin x elsewhere) is to sum all rows/columns.

Apply the operation R1R1+R2+R3R_1 \to R_1 + R_2 + R_3: (This operation adds the elements of R2R_2 and R3R_3 to R1R_1, helping us find a common factor.) \left| {\matrix{ {\cos x + 2\sin x} & {\cos x + 2\sin x} & {\cos x + 2\sin x} \cr {\sin x} & {\cos x} & {\sin x} \cr {\sin x} & {\sin x} & {\cos x} \cr } } \right| = 0

Now, we can factor out (cosx+2sinx)(\cos x + 2\sin x) from the first row (R1R_1): (\cos x + 2\sin x) \left| {\matrix{ 1 & 1 & 1 \cr {\sin x} & {\cos x} & {\sin x} \cr {\sin x} & {\sin x} & {\cos x} \cr } } \right| = 0

Step 2: Further simplify the determinant using column operations. To make the determinant easier to expand, we can create more zeros in the first row.

Apply the operations C2C2C1C_2 \to C_2 - C_1 and C3C3C1C_3 \to C_3 - C_1: (These operations subtract the first column from the second and third columns, creating zeros in the first row without changing the determinant's value.) (\cos x + 2\sin x) \left| {\matrix{ 1 & {1 - 1} & {1 - 1} \cr {\sin x} & {\cos x - \sin x} & {\sin x - \sin x} \cr {\sin x} & {\sin x - \sin x} & {\cos x - \sin x} \cr } } \right| = 0 (\cos x + 2\sin x) \left| {\matrix{ 1 & 0 & 0 \cr {\sin x} & {\cos x - \sin x} & 0 \cr {\sin x} & 0 & {\cos x - \sin x} \cr } } \right| = 0

Step 3: Expand the simplified determinant. The determinant is now in an upper triangular form (or can be seen as expanding along the first row). The determinant of a triangular matrix is the product of its diagonal elements. Expanding along the first row: (cosx+2sinx)[1((cosxsinx)(cosxsinx)00)0+0]=0(\cos x + 2\sin x) \cdot \left[ 1 \cdot ((\cos x - \sin x)(\cos x - \sin x) - 0 \cdot 0) - 0 + 0 \right] = 0 (cosx+2sinx)(cosxsinx)2=0(\cos x + 2\sin x) (\cos x - \sin x)^2 = 0

Step 4: Solve the resulting trigonometric equations. For the product of terms to be zero, at least one of the terms must be zero. This gives us two possible cases:

Case 1: cosxsinx=0\cos x - \sin x = 0 cosx=sinx\cos x = \sin x Dividing by cosx\cos x (assuming cosx0\cos x \neq 0; if cosx=0\cos x = 0, then sinx=±1\sin x = \pm 1, so sinx=cosx\sin x = \cos x would not hold. So cosx0\cos x \neq 0 is a valid assumption here): tanx=1\tan x = 1

Case 2: cosx+2sinx=0\cos x + 2\sin x = 0 cosx=2sinx\cos x = -2\sin x Dividing by cosx\cos x (again, cosx0\cos x \neq 0 for similar reasons): 1=2tanx1 = -2 \tan x tanx=12\tan x = - {1 \over 2}

Step 5: Find the roots in the given interval [π4,π4]\left[ { - {\pi \over 4},{\pi \over 4}} \right].

For Case 1: tanx=1\tan x = 1 The general solution for tanx=1\tan x = 1 is x=nπ+π4x = n\pi + {\pi \over 4}, where nn is an integer. Let's check values of nn:

  • If n=0n=0, x=π4x = {\pi \over 4}. This value is in the interval [π4,π4]\left[ { - {\pi \over 4},{\pi \over 4}} \right].
  • If n=1n=1, x=π+π4=5π4x = \pi + {\pi \over 4} = {5\pi \over 4}. This is outside the interval.
  • If n=1n=-1, x=π+π4=3π4x = -\pi + {\pi \over 4} = -{3\pi \over 4}. This is outside the interval. So, from Case 1, we have one distinct root: x=π4x = {\pi \over 4}.

For Case 2: tanx=12\tan x = - {1 \over 2} Let α=arctan(12)\alpha = \arctan\left({1 \over 2}\right). Since 1/21/2 is positive, α\alpha is in the first quadrant, i.e., 0<α<π20 < \alpha < {\pi \over 2}. Since tanx\tan x is negative, xx must be in the second or fourth quadrant. The general solution for tanx=12\tan x = - {1 \over 2} is x=nπ+arctan(12)x = n\pi + \arctan\left(-{1 \over 2}\right), or x=nπαx = n\pi - \alpha. Let's check values of nn:

  • If n=0n=0, x=arctan(12)x = \arctan\left(-{1 \over 2}\right). This value lies in the interval (π2,0)\left( -{\pi \over 2}, 0 \right) because the principal value range of arctan\arctan is (π2,π2)\left( -{\pi \over 2}, {\pi \over 2} \right). To be precise, since 0<12<10 < {1 \over 2} < 1, we know 0<arctan(12)<π40 < \arctan\left({1 \over 2}\right) < {\pi \over 4}. Therefore, x=arctan(12)x = -\arctan\left({1 \over 2}\right) is in the interval (π4,0)\left( -{\pi \over 4}, 0 \right), which is within [π4,π4]\left[ -{\pi \over 4}, {\pi \over 4} \right].
  • If n=1n=1, x=πarctan(12)x = \pi - \arctan\left({1 \over 2}\right). This is clearly outside the interval.
  • If n=1n=-1, x=πarctan(12)x = -\pi - \arctan\left({1 \over 2}\right). This is also outside the interval. So, from Case 2, we have one distinct root: x=arctan(12)x = -\arctan\left({1 \over 2}\right).

Step 6: Count the distinct real roots. The distinct real roots in the given interval are:

  1. x=π4x = {\pi \over 4}
  2. x=arctan(12)x = -\arctan\left({1 \over 2}\right)

Both values are distinct and lie within the specified interval [π4,π4]\left[ { - {\pi \over 4},{\pi \over 4}} \right]. Therefore, there are 2 distinct real roots.

The provided solution states the answer is (A) 4. Let's re-check the question and solution carefully. Ah, the provided correct answer is (A) 4, but my derived answer is 2. Let's check the original solution again. Original solution: Expanding using first column, (cosx - sinx)(cos - sinx) (sinx + cos x) + sinx (cosx - sinx) (sinx - cosx) = 0 => (cosx - sinx) 2 (sinx + cosx) + sinx (cosx - sinx) 2 = 0 => (cosx - sinx) 2 (sinx + cosx + sinx) = 0 => (2sinx + cosx )(cosx - sinx) 2 = 0

This factorization is identical to what I derived: (cosx+2sinx)(cosxsinx)2=0(\cos x + 2\sin x) (\cos x - \sin x)^2 = 0. The roots are tanx=1\tan x = 1 and tanx=1/2\tan x = -1/2. My

Practice More Matrices & Determinants Questions

View All Questions