Skip to main content
Back to Permutations & Combinations
JEE Main 2020
Permutations & Combinations
Permutations and Combinations
Easy

Question

The number of ordered pairs (r, k) for which 6. 35 C r = (k 2 - 3). 36 C r + 1 , where k is an integer, is :

Options

Solution

Key Concepts and Formulas

  • Binomial Coefficient Definition: nCr=n!r!(nr)!{^nC_r} = \frac{n!}{r!(n-r)!}
  • Adjacent Binomial Coefficient Relation: nCr+1=nr+1n1Cr{^nC_{r+1}} = \frac{n}{r+1} {^{n-1}C_r}
  • Integer Constraints: Understanding when binomial coefficients are defined and the implications of k being an integer.

Step-by-Step Solution

Step 1: Understand the given equation and define the domain for rr.

The given equation is: 635Cr=(k23)36Cr+16 \cdot {^{35}C_r} = (k^2 - 3) \cdot {^{36}C_{r+1}} For the binomial coefficients to be defined, we need 0r350 \le r \le 35 for 35Cr{^{35}C_r} and 0r+1360 \le r+1 \le 36 for 36Cr+1{^{36}C_{r+1}}, which gives 1r35-1 \le r \le 35. Combining these, we have 0r350 \le r \le 35. We are also given that kk is an integer.

Explanation: Defining the range of possible values for rr is crucial to ensure we only consider valid solutions.

Step 2: Apply the combination identity for simplification.

We use the identity nCr+1=nr+1n1Cr{^nC_{r+1}} = \frac{n}{r+1} \cdot {^{n-1}C_r} with n=36n=36: 36Cr+1=36r+135Cr{^{36}C_{r+1}} = \frac{36}{r+1} \cdot {^{35}C_r} Substituting this into the original equation: 635Cr=(k23)(36r+135Cr)6 \cdot {^{35}C_r} = (k^2 - 3) \cdot \left( \frac{36}{r+1} \cdot {^{35}C_r} \right)

Explanation: This substitution allows us to cancel out the 35Cr{^{35}C_r} term, simplifying the equation.

Step 3: Rearrange the equation to isolate k23k^2-3.

Since 35Cr0{^{35}C_r} \neq 0 for 0r350 \le r \le 35, we can divide both sides by 35Cr{^{35}C_r}: 6=(k23)36r+16 = (k^2 - 3) \cdot \frac{36}{r+1} Multiply both sides by (r+1)(r+1): 6(r+1)=(k23)366(r+1) = (k^2 - 3) \cdot 36 Divide both sides by 36: 6(r+1)36=k23\frac{6(r+1)}{36} = k^2 - 3 r+16=k23\frac{r+1}{6} = k^2 - 3

Explanation: Isolating k23k^2 - 3 allows us to establish a direct relationship between rr and kk, which we can then use to find integer solutions for kk.

Step 4: Analyze conditions for integer kk.

Since kk is an integer, k2k^2 is a non-negative perfect square. Thus, k23k^2 - 3 must be an integer. Therefore, r+16\frac{r+1}{6} must be an integer. This implies (r+1)(r+1) must be a multiple of 6.

Also, since k20k^2 \ge 0, k233k^2 - 3 \ge -3. From the expression r+16\frac{r+1}{6}, and knowing r0r \ge 0, we have r+11r+1 \ge 1. So, r+1616\frac{r+1}{6} \ge \frac{1}{6}. Combining these, k23k^2-3 must be greater than or equal to -3. But since r+16\frac{r+1}{6} must be an integer, k23k^2 - 3 must be an integer.

Furthermore, k2=r+16+3k^2 = \frac{r+1}{6} + 3. Since k2k^2 must be a perfect square, r+16+3\frac{r+1}{6} + 3 must be a perfect square.

Explanation: These conditions are essential for ensuring that kk is an integer.

Step 5: Find possible values of rr.

From Step 1, we know 0r350 \le r \le 35. This means 1r+1361 \le r+1 \le 36. Since r+1r+1 must be a multiple of 6 (from Step 4), the possible values for r+1r+1 are: 6,12,18,24,30,366, 12, 18, 24, 30, 36.

Let's find the corresponding values for rr:

  • If r+1=6    r=5r+1 = 6 \implies r=5
  • If r+1=12    r=11r+1 = 12 \implies r=11
  • If r+1=18    r=17r+1 = 18 \implies r=17
  • If r+1=24    r=23r+1 = 24 \implies r=23
  • If r+1=30    r=29r+1 = 30 \implies r=29
  • If r+1=36    r=35r+1 = 36 \implies r=35

All these values of rr are within the valid domain 0r350 \le r \le 35.

Explanation: We systematically find all possible values of rr that satisfy the divisibility condition.

Step 6: Determine corresponding kk values and count ordered pairs.

For each valid rr, we calculate k23k^2-3 and then k2k^2. We only accept cases where k2k^2 is a perfect square.

  1. For r=5r=5: k23=5+16=66=1k^2-3 = \frac{5+1}{6} = \frac{6}{6} = 1 k2=1+3=4k^2 = 1+3 = 4 k=±2k = \pm 2. So, (5,2)(5, 2) and (5,2)(5, -2) are solutions.

  2. For r=11r=11: k23=11+16=126=2k^2-3 = \frac{11+1}{6} = \frac{12}{6} = 2 k2=2+3=5k^2 = 2+3 = 5 k=±5k = \pm \sqrt{5}. Not an integer, so no solution.

  3. For r=17r=17: k23=17+16=186=3k^2-3 = \frac{17+1}{6} = \frac{18}{6} = 3 k2=3+3=6k^2 = 3+3 = 6 k=±6k = \pm \sqrt{6}. Not an integer, so no solution.

  4. For r=23r=23: k23=23+16=246=4k^2-3 = \frac{23+1}{6} = \frac{24}{6} = 4 k2=4+3=7k^2 = 4+3 = 7 k=±7k = \pm \sqrt{7}. Not an integer, so no solution.

  5. For r=29r=29: k23=29+16=306=5k^2-3 = \frac{29+1}{6} = \frac{30}{6} = 5 k2=5+3=8k^2 = 5+3 = 8 k=±8k = \pm \sqrt{8}. Not an integer, so no solution.

  6. For r=35r=35: k23=35+16=366=6k^2-3 = \frac{35+1}{6} = \frac{36}{6} = 6 k2=6+3=9k^2 = 6+3 = 9 k=±3k = \pm 3. So, (35,3)(35, 3) and (35,3)(35, -3) are solutions.

Therefore, the ordered pairs (r,k)(r, k) are (5,2),(5,2),(35,3),(35,3)(5, 2), (5, -2), (35, 3), (35, -3). There are 4 such ordered pairs.

Explanation: We explicitly check each possible value of rr to determine if it yields integer values for kk.

Common Mistakes & Tips

  • Remember to check for both positive and negative values of kk when taking the square root.
  • Always ensure that the values of rr you obtain are within the valid range determined by the binomial coefficients.
  • Don't forget the fundamental definition of binomial coefficients and when they are valid.

Summary

We simplified the given equation using the adjacent binomial coefficient relation. We then found the possible values of rr by enforcing the condition that kk must be an integer. Finally, we verified which of these values of rr actually resulted in integer values of kk, counting the number of ordered pairs. The number of ordered pairs is 4.

Final Answer

The final answer is \boxed{4}, which corresponds to option (D).

Practice More Permutations & Combinations Questions

View All Questions