Skip to main content
Back to Statistics & Probability
JEE Main 2022
Statistics & Probability
Statistics
Hard

Question

Consider the statistics of two sets of observations as follows : Size Mean Variance Observation I 10 2 2 Observation II n 3 1 If the variance of the combined set of these two observations is 179{{17} \over 9}, then the value of n is equal to ___________.

Answer: 1

Solution

Here's a clear, educational, and well-structured solution to the problem:

  1. Key Concepts and Formulas

    To solve this problem, we need to understand the definitions and formulas for mean and variance, especially when combining two sets of observations.

    • Mean (xˉ\bar{x}): The average of NN observations x1,x2,,xNx_1, x_2, \dots, x_N is given by xˉ=i=1NxiN\bar{x} = \frac{\sum_{i=1}^{N} x_i}{N}. From this, we can find the sum of observations: xi=Nxˉ\sum x_i = N \bar{x}.
    • Variance (σ2\sigma^2): A measure of data dispersion, calculated as σ2=i=1Nxi2N(xˉ)2\sigma^2 = \frac{\sum_{i=1}^{N} x_i^2}{N} - (\bar{x})^2. From this, we can find the sum of squares of observations: xi2=N(σ2+(xˉ)2)\sum x_i^2 = N(\sigma^2 + (\bar{x})^2).
    • Combined Statistics: When two sets of observations are combined (Set I: N1,xˉ1,σ12N_1, \bar{x}_1, \sigma_1^2; Set II: N2,xˉ2,σ22N_2, \bar{x}_2, \sigma_2^2), the combined statistics are:
      • Total Number of Observations: Ncomb=N1+N2N_{comb} = N_1 + N_2
      • Combined Mean: xˉcomb=N1xˉ1+N2xˉ2N1+N2\bar{x}_{comb} = \frac{N_1 \bar{x}_1 + N_2 \bar{x}_2}{N_1 + N_2}
      • Combined Variance: σcomb2=Xcomb2Ncomb(xˉcomb)2\sigma^2_{comb} = \frac{\sum X^2_{comb}}{N_{comb}} - (\bar{x}_{comb})^2, where Xcomb2=N1(σ12+xˉ12)+N2(σ22+xˉ22)\sum X^2_{comb} = N_1(\sigma_1^2 + \bar{x}_1^2) + N_2(\sigma_2^2 + \bar{x}_2^2).
  2. Step-by-Step Solution

    We are given the statistics for two sets of observations and the variance of their combined set. Our goal is to find the size (nn) of the second set.

    Step 1: Calculate the sum of observations and sum of squares for Set I.

    • What we are doing: We are extracting the fundamental sums (xi\sum x_i and xi2\sum x_i^2) for the first set. These are essential building blocks for calculating the combined statistics.
    • Given for Set I:
      • Size (N1N_1) = 10
      • Mean (xˉ1\bar{x}_1) = 2
      • Variance (σ12\sigma_1^2) = 2
    • Calculation:
      1. Sum of observations (x1\sum x_1): x1=N1xˉ1=10×2=20\sum x_1 = N_1 \bar{x}_1 = 10 \times 2 = 20
      2. Sum of squares of observations (x12\sum x_1^2): x12=N1(σ12+xˉ12)=10(2+(2)2)=10(2+4)=10×6=60\sum x_1^2 = N_1(\sigma_1^2 + \bar{x}_1^2) = 10(2 + (2)^2) = 10(2 + 4) = 10 \times 6 = 60
    • Reasoning: The sum of observations allows us to find the total sum for the combined set. The sum of squares is directly used in the formula for combined variance.

    Step 2: Calculate the sum of observations and sum of squares for Set II (in terms of nn).

    • What we are doing: Similarly, we are finding the fundamental sums for the second set, which depend on the unknown size nn.
    • Given for Set II:
      • Size (N2N_2) = nn
      • Mean (xˉ2\bar{x}_2) = 3
      • Variance (σ22\sigma_2^2) = 1
    • Calculation:
      1. Sum of observations (x2\sum x_2): x2=N2xˉ2=n×3=3n\sum x_2 = N_2 \bar{x}_2 = n \times 3 = 3n
      2. Sum of squares of observations (x22\sum x_2^2): x22=N2(σ22+xˉ22)=n(1+(3)2)=n(1+9)=n×10=10n\sum x_2^2 = N_2(\sigma_2^2 + \bar{x}_2^2) = n(1 + (3)^2) = n(1 + 9) = n \times 10 = 10n
    • Reasoning: These expressions in terms of nn will be combined with the values from Set I to form equations for the combined set, which we can then solve for nn.

    Step 3: Calculate the combined statistics.

    • What we are doing: We are now combining the information from both sets to find the total number of observations, the total sum of observations, the total sum of squares, and the combined mean.
    • Calculation:
      1. Total number of observations (NcombN_{comb}): Ncomb=N1+N2=10+nN_{comb} = N_1 + N_2 = 10 + n
      2. Total sum of observations (Xcomb\sum X_{comb}): Xcomb=x1+x2=20+3n\sum X_{comb} = \sum x_1 + \sum x_2 = 20 + 3n
      3. Total sum of squares of observations (Xcomb2\sum X^2_{comb}): Xcomb2=x12+x22=60+10n\sum X^2_{comb} = \sum x_1^2 + \sum x_2^2 = 60 + 10n
      4. Combined Mean (xˉcomb\bar{x}_{comb}): xˉcomb=XcombNcomb=20+3n10+n\bar{x}_{comb} = \frac{\sum X_{comb}}{N_{comb}} = \frac{20 + 3n}{10 + n}
    • Reasoning: These combined values are directly substituted into the combined variance formula to form an equation in terms of nn. The combined mean is a necessary intermediate step for the combined variance calculation.

    Step 4: Apply the combined variance formula and solve for nn.

    • What we are doing: We use the given combined variance and the expressions derived in Step 3 to form an algebraic equation and solve for nn.
    • Given combined variance: σcomb2=179\sigma^2_{comb} = \frac{17}{9}
    • Formula: σcomb2=Xcomb2Ncomb(xˉcomb)2\sigma^2_{comb} = \frac{\sum X^2_{comb}}{N_{comb}} - (\bar{x}_{comb})^2
    • Substitution and Calculation: 179=60+10n10+n(20+3n10+n)2\frac{17}{9} = \frac{60 + 10n}{10 + n} - \left(\frac{20 + 3n}{10 + n}\right)^2 To simplify, find a common denominator (10+n)2(10+n)^2: 179=(60+10n)(10+n)(10+n)2(20+3n)2(10+n)2\frac{17}{9} = \frac{(60 + 10n)(10 + n)}{(10 + n)^2} - \frac{(20 + 3n)^2}{(10 + n)^2} 179=(60+10n)(10+n)(20+3n)2(10+n)2\frac{17}{9} = \frac{(60 + 10n)(10 + n) - (20 + 3n)^2}{(10 + n)^2} Expand the numerator:
      • (60+10n)(10+n)=600+60n+100n+10n2=10n2+160n+600(60 + 10n)(10 + n) = 600 + 60n + 100n + 10n^2 = 10n^2 + 160n + 600
      • (20+3n)2=400+120n+9n2(20 + 3n)^2 = 400 + 120n + 9n^2 Substitute back into the equation: 179=(10n2+160n+600)(9n2+120n+400)(10+n)2\frac{17}{9} = \frac{(10n^2 + 160n + 600) - (9n^2 + 120n + 400)}{(10 + n)^2} Carefully distribute the negative sign: 179=10n2+160n+6009n2120n400(10+n)2\frac{17}{9} = \frac{10n^2 + 160n + 600 - 9n^2 - 120n - 400}{(10 + n)^2} Combine like terms in the numerator: 179=n2+40n+200(10+n)2\frac{17}{9} = \frac{n^2 + 40n + 200}{(10 + n)^2} Cross-multiply: 17(10+n)2=9(n2+40n+200)17(10 + n)^2 = 9(n^2 + 40n + 200) Expand (10+n)2=100+20n+n2(10+n)^2 = 100 + 20n + n^2: 17(100+20n+n2)=9n2+360n+180017(100 + 20n + n^2) = 9n^2 + 360n + 1800 Distribute constants: 1700+340n+17n2=9n2+360n+18001700 + 340n + 17n^2 = 9n^2 + 360n + 1800 Rearrange into a quadratic equation an2+bn+c=0an^2 + bn + c = 0: 17n29n2+340n360n+17001800=017n^2 - 9n^2 + 340n - 360n + 1700 - 1800 = 0 8n220n100=08n^2 - 20n - 100 = 0 Divide by 4 to simplify: 2n25n25=02n^2 - 5n - 25 = 0 Factor the quadratic equation: We look for two numbers that multiply to 2×(25)=502 \times (-25) = -50 and add to 5-5. These are 10-10 and 55. 2n210n+5n25=02n^2 - 10n + 5n - 25 = 0 2n(n5)+5(n5)=02n(n - 5) + 5(n - 5) = 0 (2n+5)(n5)=0(2n + 5)(n - 5) = 0 This gives two possible solutions for nn: 2n+5=0    n=522n + 5 = 0 \implies n = -\frac{5}{2} n5=0    n=5n - 5 = 0 \implies n = 5
    • Reasoning: Since nn represents the number of observations, it must be a positive integer. Therefore, n=5n=5 is the only valid solution.
  3. Common Mistakes & Tips

    • Algebraic Errors: Be extremely careful when expanding squared terms like (20+3n)2(20+3n)^2 and distributing negative signs, e.g., (9n2+120n+400)-(9n^2 + 120n + 400) becomes 9n2120n400-9n^2 - 120n - 400. This is a frequent source of errors.
    • Formula Application: Ensure you use the correct variance formula and its derived form for x2\sum x^2. A common mistake is using x2=Nσ2\sum x^2 = N \sigma^2 instead of x2=N(σ2+xˉ2)\sum x^2 = N(\sigma^2 + \bar{x}^2).
    • Physical Constraints: Always check if your final answer makes sense in the context of the problem. nn must be a positive integer, as it represents the count of observations.
  4. Summary

    This problem involved calculating the mean and variance for two individual sets of observations, then combining them to find the overall variance. By systematically using the definitions of mean and variance to find the sums and sums of squares for each set, we were able to set up an equation for the combined variance. Solving the resulting quadratic equation yielded n=5n=5 as the physically meaningful number of observations.

The final answer is 5\boxed{5}.

Practice More Statistics & Probability Questions

View All Questions