Question
Bag 1 contains 4 white balls and 5 black balls, and Bag 2 contains n white balls and 3 black balls. One ball is drawn randomly from Bag 1 and transferred to Bag 2. A ball is then drawn randomly from Bag 2. If the probability, that the ball drawn is white, is , then n is equal to:
Options
Solution
Key Concepts and Formulas
- Law of Total Probability: This fundamental principle allows us to calculate the overall probability of an event by considering all mutually exclusive and exhaustive conditions under which the event can occur. If are such conditions, and is an event, then .
- Conditional Probability: is the probability of event occurring given that event has already occurred.
- Basic Probability Calculation: The probability of an event is the ratio of the number of favorable outcomes to the total number of possible outcomes.
Step-by-Step Solution
Step 1: Define Events and Initial Setup First, we clearly state the initial contents of each bag and define the key events involved in the experiment.
-
Bag 1:
- Number of white balls () = 4
- Number of black balls () = 5
- Total balls in Bag 1 =
-
Bag 2:
- Number of white balls () =
- Number of black balls () = 3
- Total balls in Bag 2 =
Now, let's define the events for the two stages of the experiment:
- Event : A white ball is drawn from Bag 1 and transferred to Bag 2.
- Why define this? This is one of the two possible outcomes of the first stage of the experiment, and it will change the composition of Bag 2.
- Event : A black ball is drawn from Bag 1 and transferred to Bag 2.
- Why define this? This is the other possible outcome of the first stage. Events and are mutually exclusive (you can't transfer both a white and a black ball at the same time) and exhaustive (you must transfer either a white or a black ball).
- Event : The ball drawn randomly from Bag 2 (in the second stage) is white.
- Why define this? This is the ultimate event whose probability we are interested in. We are given and need to use this to find the value of .
Step 2: Calculate Probabilities of the Transfer Events ( and ) These are the probabilities of the initial conditions (transferring a white or black ball). They are calculated from the contents of Bag 1.
-
Probability of transferring a white ball (): There are 4 white balls out of a total of 9 balls in Bag 1.
-
Probability of transferring a black ball (): There are 5 black balls out of a total of 9 balls in Bag 1.
- Self-check: Notice that . This confirms that these two events cover all possibilities for the first stage.
Step 3: Calculate Conditional Probabilities of Drawing a White Ball from Bag 2 ( and ) These probabilities depend on how the composition of Bag 2 changes after a ball is transferred.
-
Case 1: A white ball was transferred (Event occurred).
- Why this case? If a white ball was transferred, the number of white balls in Bag 2 increases by one.
- Composition of Bag 2 after transfer:
- Number of white balls = (original plus the transferred white ball)
- Number of black balls = 3 (unchanged)
- Total balls in Bag 2 =
- Conditional probability of drawing a white ball from this modified Bag 2 ():
-
Case 2: A black ball was transferred (Event occurred).
- Why this case? If a black ball was transferred, the number of black balls in Bag 2 increases by one.
- Composition of Bag 2 after transfer:
- Number of white balls = (unchanged)
- Number of black balls = (original 3 plus the transferred black ball)
- Total balls in Bag 2 =
- Conditional probability of drawing a white ball from this modified Bag 2 ():
- Common Mistake Alert: It's crucial to correctly update the total number of balls in Bag 2. In both cases, one ball is added, so the total becomes . Forgetting to update the total or incorrectly updating the number of white/black balls is a frequent error.
Step 4: Apply the Law of Total Probability and Solve for n Now, we combine the probabilities calculated in the previous steps using the Law of Total Probability formula: We are given that . Let's substitute all the values: To simplify, combine the terms on the right-hand side. Notice they share a common denominator : Now, expand the numerator: We can simplify by dividing both sides by : Now, cross-multiply to solve for : Gather terms on one side and constant terms on the other: Divide by 16 to find :
Step 5: Verify the Answer Let's quickly check if yields the given probability. If : . This matches the given probability, confirming our derived value of .
Common Mistakes & Tips
- Forgetting to update total balls: When a ball is transferred, the total number of balls in the receiving bag changes. Always update the total number of balls in the bag for subsequent probability calculations.
- Incorrectly updating ball counts: Ensure you add the transferred ball to the correct color count in the receiving bag. If a white ball is transferred, only the white ball count increases.
- Algebraic errors: Be careful with algebraic manipulation when solving for . Double-check expansion, combining like terms, and cross-multiplication.
- Understanding "Mutually Exclusive and Exhaustive": The initial conditions (transferring a white or black ball) must cover all possibilities and cannot happen simultaneously for the Law of Total Probability to be applied correctly.
Summary
This problem is a classic application of the Law of Total Probability. We systematically defined the initial conditions (transferring a white or black ball from Bag 1 to Bag 2) and their respective probabilities. Then, for each condition, we determined the conditional probability of drawing a white ball from Bag 2 after the transfer. By combining these using the Law of Total Probability, we set up an equation that allowed us to solve for . The derived value of was verified against the given probability.
The final answer is , which corresponds to option (B).