Skip to main content
Back to Statistics & Probability
JEE Main 2021
Statistics & Probability
Probability
Hard

Question

Let M be the maximum value of the product of two positive integers when their sum is 66. Let the sample space S={xZ:x(66x)59M}S = \left\{ {x \in \mathbb{Z}:x(66 - x) \ge {5 \over 9}M} \right\} and the event A={xS:xisamultipleof3}\mathrm{A = \{ x \in S:x\,is\,a\,multiple\,of\,3\}}. Then P(A) is equal to :

Options

Solution

1. Key Concepts and Formulas

  • Arithmetic Mean-Geometric Mean (AM-GM) Inequality: For any two non-negative real numbers aa and bb, a+b2ab\frac{a+b}{2} \ge \sqrt{ab}. Equality holds if and only if a=ba=b. This is used to find the maximum product for a fixed sum.
  • Solving Quadratic Inequalities: A quadratic inequality of the form (xa)(xb)0(x-a)(x-b) \le 0 (where a<ba<b) is satisfied for values of xx such that axba \le x \le b. This is crucial for defining the sample space.
  • Counting Elements in a Set:
    • The number of integers in an inclusive range [a,b][a, b] is ba+1b - a + 1.
    • The number of terms in an arithmetic progression with first term a1a_1, last term ana_n, and common difference dd is given by n=ana1d+1n = \frac{a_n - a_1}{d} + 1.
  • Classical Probability: The probability of an event A, P(A)P(A), is given by the ratio of the number of favorable outcomes n(A)n(A) to the total number of possible outcomes n(S)n(S), i.e., P(A)=n(A)n(S)P(A) = \frac{n(A)}{n(S)}.

2. Step-by-Step Solution

Step 1: Determine the maximum value M of the product.

  • What we are doing: We need to find the maximum value of the product of two positive integers whose sum is 66. Let these integers be xx and yy.
  • Why we are doing this: The value of MM is a direct input to define the sample space SS in the next step.
  • Mathematical application: We are given x,yZ+x, y \in \mathbb{Z}^+ and x+y=66x+y=66. We want to maximize P=xyP = xy. Applying the AM-GM inequality to xx and yy: x+y2xy\frac{x+y}{2} \ge \sqrt{xy} Substitute x+y=66x+y=66: 662xy\frac{66}{2} \ge \sqrt{xy} 33xy33 \ge \sqrt{xy} Squaring both sides (which is valid since both sides are non-negative): (33)2xy(33)^2 \ge xy 1089xy1089 \ge xy The maximum possible value of the product xyxy is 1089.
  • Reasoning: The equality in the AM-GM inequality holds when x=yx=y. For x+y=66x+y=66 and x=yx=y, we get 2x=66    x=332x=66 \implies x=33. Since x=33x=33 and y=33y=33 are positive integers, this condition is met. Thus, the maximum product M=1089M = 1089.

Step 2: Define the Sample Space S and calculate n(S)n(S).

  • What we are doing: We need to find the set of integers xx that satisfy the given inequality x(66x)59Mx(66-x) \ge \frac{5}{9}M, which forms our sample space SS. Then we will count the number of elements in SS.
  • Why we are doing this: The sample space SS represents all possible outcomes, and its size n(S)n(S) is the denominator for calculating probability.
  • Mathematical application: Substitute M=1089M=1089 into the inequality: x(66x)591089x(66 - x) \ge \frac{5}{9} \cdot 1089 Simplify the right side: x(66x)5(10899)=5121=605x(66 - x) \ge 5 \cdot \left(\frac{1089}{9}\right) = 5 \cdot 121 = 605 Expand and rearrange the inequality to a standard quadratic form: 66xx260566x - x^2 \ge 605 Move all terms to one side to make the x2x^2 coefficient positive: 0x266x+6050 \ge x^2 - 66x + 605 Or, equivalently: x266x+6050x^2 - 66x + 605 \le 0 To solve this quadratic inequality, we find the roots of x266x+605=0x^2 - 66x + 605 = 0. We look for two numbers that multiply to 605 and sum to -66. These numbers are -11 and -55. So, the quadratic factors as: (x11)(x55)0(x - 11)(x - 55) \le 0
  • Reasoning: For the product of two terms to be less than or equal to zero, xx must lie between or be equal to the roots. The roots are x=11x=11 and x=55x=55. Thus, the solution to the inequality is 11x5511 \le x \le 55. Since xZx \in \mathbb{Z} (integers) and xx must be positive (as stated in the problem for the original xx), the sample space SS includes all integers from 11 to 55, inclusive: S={11,12,13,,55}S = \{11, 12, 13, \ldots, 55\} To find the number of elements in SS, n(S)n(S), we use the formula for counting integers in an inclusive range: n(S)=5511+1=44+1=45n(S) = 55 - 11 + 1 = 44 + 1 = 45

Step 3: Define Event A and calculate n(A)n(A).

  • What we are doing: We need to identify the elements within the sample space SS that are multiples of 3, which constitutes event AA. Then we will count the number of elements in AA.
  • Why we are doing this: Event AA represents the favorable outcomes, and its size n(A)n(A) is the numerator for calculating probability.
  • Mathematical application: Event A={xS:x is a multiple of 3}A = \{ x \in S : x \text{ is a multiple of } 3 \}. The smallest integer in SS is 11. The smallest multiple of 3 greater than or equal to 11 is 1212 (3×43 \times 4). The largest integer in SS is 55. The largest multiple of 3 less than or equal to 55 is 5454 (3×183 \times 18). So, the elements of event AA are: A={12,15,18,,54}A = \{12, 15, 18, \ldots, 54\} This is an arithmetic progression with first term a1=12a_1=12, last term an=54a_n=54, and common difference d=3d=3. To find the number of elements in AA, n(A)n(A), we use the formula for terms in an arithmetic progression: n(A)=ana1d+1n(A) = \frac{a_n - a_1}{d} + 1 n(A)=54123+1=423+1=14+1=15n(A) = \frac{54 - 12}{3} + 1 = \frac{42}{3} + 1 = 14 + 1 = 15
  • Reasoning: By systematically identifying the first and last multiples of 3 within the range of SS, we can precisely define event AA and accurately count its elements using the arithmetic progression formula.

Step 4: Calculate the Probability P(A).

  • What we are doing: We will calculate the probability of event AA using the classical definition of probability.
  • Why we are doing this: This is the final objective of the problem.
  • Mathematical application: Using the values we found for n(A)n(A) and n(S)n(S): P(A)=n(A)n(S)=1545P(A) = \frac{n(A)}{n(S)} = \frac{15}{45} Simplify the fraction: P(A)=15÷1545÷15=13P(A) = \frac{15 \div 15}{45 \div 15} = \frac{1}{3}
  • Reasoning: The probability is simply the ratio of favorable outcomes to total possible outcomes, assuming each outcome in SS is equally likely.

3. Common Mistakes & Tips

  • AM-GM for Integers: When using AM-GM for integers, always check if the equality condition (a=ba=b) yields integer values. If not (e.g., sum is odd), the maximum product for integers will occur when the integers are as close as possible (e.g., for sum 65, x=32,y=33x=32, y=33). In this problem, x=y=33x=y=33 are valid integers.
  • Quadratic Inequality Direction: Be careful when manipulating quadratic inequalities. Ensure the x2x^2 term has a positive coefficient before determining the intervals of solution, or use a sign chart carefully.
  • Counting in Ranges: When counting integers in an inclusive range [a,b][a, b], always remember to add 1: ba+1b-a+1. Similarly, for arithmetic progressions, the formula is lastfirstcommon difference+1\frac{\text{last} - \text{first}}{\text{common difference}} + 1.

4. Summary

This problem integrates several core mathematical concepts to arrive at a probability. We began by using the AM-GM inequality to find the maximum possible product MM of two positive integers with a sum of 66. This value of MM was then used to establish a quadratic inequality, the solution of which defined the integer sample space SS. Next, we identified the subset of SS consisting of multiples of 3, which formed event AA. Finally, by calculating the number of elements in AA and SS, we determined the probability P(A)P(A) using the fundamental definition of probability.

The final answer is 13\boxed{\frac{1}{3}}, which corresponds to option (A).

Practice More Statistics & Probability Questions

View All Questions