Question
The mean of the numbers a, b, 8, 5, 10 is 6 and the variance is 6.80. Then which one of the following gives possible values of a and b?
Options
Solution
This problem requires a solid understanding of the definitions and formulas for the mean and variance of a data set. We will use the given information to form a system of equations involving the unknown numbers and , and then solve this system.
1. Key Concepts and Formulas
-
Mean (): The average of a set of numbers. For a data set , the mean is given by: where is the sum of all observations and is the number of observations.
-
Variance (): A measure of the spread of numbers in a data set from their mean. For a data set with mean , the variance is defined as: An alternative and often more convenient formula for calculation, especially when the mean is an integer, is: This formula helps avoid calculating individual deviations and is generally more efficient.
2. Step-by-Step Solution
We are given the numbers . The total number of observations, . The mean of these numbers, . The variance of these numbers, .
-
Step 1: Use the mean to form the first equation. What we are doing: We are using the definition of the mean to establish a relationship between and . Why this step: The problem provides the mean, so applying its formula is the direct way to use this information.
First, sum all the observations: Now, apply the mean formula: Multiply both sides by 5: Rearrange to find the first equation:
-
Step 2: Use the variance to form the second equation. What we are doing: We are using the given variance and mean to establish another relationship between and . Why this step: With two unknown variables ( and ), we need two independent equations to solve for them. The variance provides this second piece of information.
We will use the computationally efficient variance formula: . First, calculate the sum of the squares of all observations: Now, substitute the values into the variance formula: Calculate the squared mean: Add 36 to both sides: Multiply both sides by 5: Rearrange to find the second equation:
-
Step 3: Solve the system of equations for and . What we are doing: We now have two equations with two unknowns, which we can solve simultaneously. Why this step: Solving these equations will give us the specific values of and that satisfy both the mean and variance conditions.
Our system of equations is:
From Equation 1, express in terms of : Substitute this expression for into Equation 2: Expand the squared term: . Combine like terms: Move all terms to one side to form a standard quadratic equation: Divide the entire equation by 2 to simplify: Factorize the quadratic equation. We need two numbers that multiply to 12 and add up to -7. These are -3 and -4. This gives two possible values for : Now, find the corresponding values of using : If , then . If , then . So, the possible pairs for are or .
-
Step 4: Check the given options. What we are doing: We compare our derived possible values for with the given options to find the correct match. Why this step: This is the final verification to ensure our solution aligns with one of the provided choices.
Our derived pairs are and . Let's examine the options: (A) (B) (C) (D)
Option (D) directly matches one of our derived pairs. Let's verify option (D) against the original problem conditions for completeness: For :
- Mean: . (Matches the given mean)
- Variance: The numbers are . The mean is 6. Sum of squares: . Variance . (Matches the given variance) Since both conditions are satisfied, is a possible pair.
Let's also quickly check option (A) as it was designated as the correct answer in the prompt, to highlight any discrepancy: For :
- Mean: . (Matches the given mean)
- Variance: The numbers are . The mean is 6. Sum of squares: . Variance . This variance () does not match the given variance of . Therefore, option (A) is not a possible value.
Based on the problem statement and standard statistical formulas, the values or are the correct solutions.
3. Common Mistakes & Tips
- Formula Recall: Ensure you correctly recall the formulas for mean and variance. A common mistake is to forget to divide by in the variance formula or to use the sum of absolute deviations instead of squared deviations.
- Algebraic Errors: Be meticulous with arithmetic and algebraic manipulations, especially when expanding or combining terms. Small calculation errors can lead to incorrect quadratic equations.
- Checking Options: Always substitute your calculated values back into the original conditions (mean and variance) or check the options against the derived equations to verify your answer. This is a crucial step for catching errors.
4. Summary
We systematically used the given mean and variance to construct two algebraic equations involving the unknown numbers and . The mean condition led to , and the variance condition led to . Solving this system of equations revealed that the possible pairs for are or . Comparing these with the given options, we found that option (D) matches our derived values.
The final answer is which corresponds to option (D).