Skip to main content
Back to Statistics & Probability
JEE Main 2019
Statistics & Probability
Probability
Medium

Question

The probability that two randomly selected subsets of the set {1, 2, 3, 4, 5} have exactly two elements in their intersection, is :

Options

Solution

Key Concepts and Formulas

  • Probability Definition: The probability of an event EE is given by the ratio of the number of favorable outcomes to the total number of possible outcomes: P(E)=Number of Favorable OutcomesTotal Number of Possible OutcomesP(E) = \frac{\text{Number of Favorable Outcomes}}{\text{Total Number of Possible Outcomes}}
  • Subset Formation and Element Placement: For a set SS with nn elements, there are 2n2^n possible subsets. When considering two subsets, say AA and BB, from SS, each element xSx \in S can fall into one of four mutually exclusive regions:
    1. xAx \in A and xBx \in B (i.e., xABx \in A \cap B)
    2. xAx \in A and xBx \notin B (i.e., xABx \in A \setminus B)
    3. xAx \notin A and xBx \in B (i.e., xBAx \in B \setminus A)
    4. xAx \notin A and xBx \notin B (i.e., xS(AB)x \in S \setminus (A \cup B)) This implies that for each element, there are 4 independent choices regarding its membership in the pair of subsets (A,B)(A, B).
  • Combinations: The number of ways to choose kk elements from a set of nn distinct elements, without regard to the order of selection, is given by the combination formula: nCk=n!k!(nk)!^n C_k = \frac{n!}{k!(n-k)!}

Step-by-Step Solution

Step 1: Understand the Problem and Identify the Universal Set The given set is S={1,2,3,4,5}S = \{1, 2, 3, 4, 5\}, which has n(S)=5n(S) = 5 elements. We are randomly selecting two subsets, let's call them AA and BB, from SS. We need to find the probability that their intersection, ABA \cap B, contains exactly two elements.

Step 2: Calculate the Total Number of Possible Ways to Select Two Subsets We need to determine the total number of distinct ordered pairs of subsets (A,B)(A, B) that can be formed from the set SS. As per the Key Concept of element placement, for each of the 5 elements in SS, there are 4 independent choices regarding its membership in the subsets AA and BB.

  • For element 1, there are 4 choices.
  • For element 2, there are 4 choices.
  • ...
  • For element 5, there are 4 choices. Since there are 5 elements, the total number of ways to define the two subsets AA and BB (i.e., the total number of ordered pairs of subsets) is: Total Number of Outcomes=45\text{Total Number of Outcomes} = 4^5 We can also write 454^5 as (22)5=210(2^2)^5 = 2^{10}. Total Number of Outcomes=210=1024\text{Total Number of Outcomes} = 2^{10} = 1024

Step 3: Calculate the Number of Favorable Outcomes (Subsets with Exactly Two Elements in Intersection) We are looking for pairs of subsets (A,B)(A, B) such that n(AB)=2n(A \cap B) = 2. We can achieve this by following two sub-steps:

Sub-step 3.1: Choose the elements that will be in the intersection (ABA \cap B). We need to select exactly 2 elements from the 5 available elements in set SS to form the intersection ABA \cap B. The number of ways to do this is given by the combination formula nCk^n C_k: Number of ways to choose elements for AB=5C2=5!2!(52)!=5×42×1=10\text{Number of ways to choose elements for } A \cap B = ^5 C_2 = \frac{5!}{2!(5-2)!} = \frac{5 \times 4}{2 \times 1} = 10 Let's assume these two chosen elements are now fixed as members of ABA \cap B. This means for these 2 elements, their "fate" is decided (they are in AA and in BB).

Sub-step 3.2: Distribute the remaining elements. After selecting 2 elements for the intersection, there are 52=35 - 2 = 3 elements remaining in the set SS. For each of these 3 remaining elements, it cannot be in the intersection ABA \cap B (because we have already fixed the elements that are in the intersection). Therefore, each of these 3 remaining elements must belong to one of the other three possible regions:

  • In AA but not in BB (ABA \setminus B)
  • In BB but not in AA (BAB \setminus A)
  • Neither in AA nor in BB (S(AB)S \setminus (A \cup B)) So, for each of the 3 remaining elements, there are 3 independent choices. The total number of ways to distribute these 3 remaining elements is: Number of ways to distribute remaining elements=3×3×3=33=27\text{Number of ways to distribute remaining elements} = 3 \times 3 \times 3 = 3^3 = 27

Combining Sub-steps for Favorable Outcomes: To get the total number of favorable outcomes, we multiply the number of ways to choose the intersection elements by the number of ways to distribute the remaining elements: Number of Favorable Outcomes=(5C2)×33=10×27=270\text{Number of Favorable Outcomes} = (^5 C_2) \times 3^3 = 10 \times 27 = 270

Step 4: Calculate the Required Probability Now, we use the probability formula: P(AB has 2 elements)=Number of Favorable OutcomesTotal Number of Possible OutcomesP(A \cap B \text{ has 2 elements}) = \frac{\text{Number of Favorable Outcomes}}{\text{Total Number of Possible Outcomes}} P(AB has 2 elements)=270210P(A \cap B \text{ has 2 elements}) = \frac{270}{2^{10}} To simplify the fraction, we can divide the numerator and denominator by 2: P(AB has 2 elements)=13529P(A \cap B \text{ has 2 elements}) = \frac{135}{2^9}


Common Mistakes & Tips

  • Miscounting Total Outcomes: A common mistake is to count 2n×2n2^n \times 2^n as the total number of outcomes, which is correct, but sometimes students might think of NC2^N C_2 where N=2nN=2^n if they are considering choosing two distinct subsets from the 2n2^n possible subsets. The phrasing "two randomly selected subsets" typically implies ordered pairs (A,B)(A, B) where AA and BB are chosen independently. The "fate of each element" method (4n4^n) inherently counts ordered pairs.
  • Incorrect Distribution of Remaining Elements: Ensure that once elements are assigned to a specific region (like the intersection), they cannot be assigned to other regions. The remaining elements must be distributed among the remaining allowed regions.
  • Overlooking Independence: Remember that the choices for each element's placement are independent of the choices for other elements. This allows for multiplication of possibilities.

Summary

This problem required us to calculate the probability that two randomly selected subsets of a 5-element set have exactly two elements in their intersection. We first determined the total number of ways to form two ordered subsets by considering the 4 possible regions each of the 5 elements could belong to, resulting in 45=2104^5 = 2^{10} total outcomes. Next, we calculated the number of favorable outcomes by first choosing 2 elements for the intersection (5C2^5 C_2 ways) and then distributing the remaining 3 elements into the 3 non-intersection regions (333^3 ways). This yielded 10×27=27010 \times 27 = 270 favorable outcomes. Finally, dividing the favorable outcomes by the total outcomes gave the probability 270210=13529\frac{270}{2^{10}} = \frac{135}{2^9}.

The final answer is 13529\boxed{\frac{135}{2^9}} which corresponds to option (A).

Practice More Statistics & Probability Questions

View All Questions