Skip to main content
Back to Vector Algebra
JEE Main 2023
Vector Algebra
Vector Algebra
Medium

Question

If a×b=b×c=c×a\overrightarrow a \times \overrightarrow b = \overrightarrow b \times \overrightarrow c = \overrightarrow c \times \overrightarrow a then a+b+c=\overrightarrow a + \overrightarrow b + \overrightarrow c =

Options

Solution

1. Key Concepts and Formulas

  • Vector Cross Product Properties:
    • Anti-commutativity: p×q=(q×p)\overrightarrow p \times \overrightarrow q = -(\overrightarrow q \times \overrightarrow p)
    • Zero vector property: p×p=0\overrightarrow p \times \overrightarrow p = \overrightarrow 0
    • Distributive property: p×(q+r)=p×q+p×r\overrightarrow p \times (\overrightarrow q + \overrightarrow r) = \overrightarrow p \times \overrightarrow q + \overrightarrow p \times \overrightarrow r
  • Parallel Vectors: If p×q=0\overrightarrow p \times \overrightarrow q = \overrightarrow 0 and p,q\overrightarrow p, \overrightarrow q are non-zero, then p\overrightarrow p is parallel to q\overrightarrow q (i.e., p=kq\overrightarrow p = k \overrightarrow q for some scalar kk).

2. Step-by-Step Solution

We are given the condition: a×b=b×c=c×a\overrightarrow a \times \overrightarrow b = \overrightarrow b \times \overrightarrow c = \overrightarrow c \times \overrightarrow a Let's denote this common cross product vector as k\overrightarrow k. So, a×b=k\overrightarrow a \times \overrightarrow b = \overrightarrow k, b×c=k\overrightarrow b \times \overrightarrow c = \overrightarrow k, and c×a=k\overrightarrow c \times \overrightarrow a = \overrightarrow k.

Step 1: Analyze the relationship between the vectors. From the given condition, we have: a×b=b×c\overrightarrow a \times \overrightarrow b = \overrightarrow b \times \overrightarrow c Rearranging the terms to one side: a×bb×c=0\overrightarrow a \times \overrightarrow b - \overrightarrow b \times \overrightarrow c = \overrightarrow 0 Using the anti-commutativity property, b×c=(c×b)\overrightarrow b \times \overrightarrow c = -(\overrightarrow c \times \overrightarrow b): a×b+c×b=0\overrightarrow a \times \overrightarrow b + \overrightarrow c \times \overrightarrow b = \overrightarrow 0 Applying the distributive property: (a+c)×b=0(\overrightarrow a + \overrightarrow c) \times \overrightarrow b = \overrightarrow 0 This implies that the vector (a+c)(\overrightarrow a + \overrightarrow c) is parallel to b\overrightarrow b. Therefore, a+c=k1b\overrightarrow a + \overrightarrow c = k_1 \overrightarrow b for some scalar k1k_1.

Step 2: Analyze another pair of equalities. Similarly, from b×c=c×a\overrightarrow b \times \overrightarrow c = \overrightarrow c \times \overrightarrow a: b×cc×a=0\overrightarrow b \times \overrightarrow c - \overrightarrow c \times \overrightarrow a = \overrightarrow 0 Using anti-commutativity, c×a=(a×c)\overrightarrow c \times \overrightarrow a = -(\overrightarrow a \times \overrightarrow c): b×c+a×c=0\overrightarrow b \times \overrightarrow c + \overrightarrow a \times \overrightarrow c = \overrightarrow 0 Applying the distributive property: (b+a)×c=0(\overrightarrow b + \overrightarrow a) \times \overrightarrow c = \overrightarrow 0 This implies that the vector (b+a)(\overrightarrow b + \overrightarrow a) is parallel to c\overrightarrow c. Therefore, b+a=k2c\overrightarrow b + \overrightarrow a = k_2 \overrightarrow c for some scalar k2k_2.

Step 3: Analyze the remaining equality. From c×a=a×b\overrightarrow c \times \overrightarrow a = \overrightarrow a \times \overrightarrow b: c×aa×b=0\overrightarrow c \times \overrightarrow a - \overrightarrow a \times \overrightarrow b = \overrightarrow 0 Using anti-commutativity, a×b=(b×a)\overrightarrow a \times \overrightarrow b = -(\overrightarrow b \times \overrightarrow a): c×a+b×a=0\overrightarrow c \times \overrightarrow a + \overrightarrow b \times \overrightarrow a = \overrightarrow 0 Applying the distributive property: (c+b)×a=0(\overrightarrow c + \overrightarrow b) \times \overrightarrow a = \overrightarrow 0 This implies that the vector (c+b)(\overrightarrow c + \overrightarrow b) is parallel to a\overrightarrow a. Therefore, c+b=k3a\overrightarrow c + \overrightarrow b = k_3 \overrightarrow a for some scalar k3k_3.

Step 4: Relate the sum of vectors to the derived parallel conditions. We have:

  1. a+c=k1b\overrightarrow a + \overrightarrow c = k_1 \overrightarrow b
  2. a+b=k2c\overrightarrow a + \overrightarrow b = k_2 \overrightarrow c
  3. b+c=k3a\overrightarrow b + \overrightarrow c = k_3 \overrightarrow a

Let's add b\overrightarrow b to the first equation: a+c+b=k1b+b\overrightarrow a + \overrightarrow c + \overrightarrow b = k_1 \overrightarrow b + \overrightarrow b a+b+c=(k1+1)b\overrightarrow a + \overrightarrow b + \overrightarrow c = (k_1 + 1) \overrightarrow b This shows that the vector sum a+b+c\overrightarrow a + \overrightarrow b + \overrightarrow c is parallel to b\overrightarrow b.

Similarly, adding c\overrightarrow c to the second equation: a+b+c=(k2+1)c\overrightarrow a + \overrightarrow b + \overrightarrow c = (k_2 + 1) \overrightarrow c This shows that the vector sum a+b+c\overrightarrow a + \overrightarrow b + \overrightarrow c is parallel to c\overrightarrow c.

And adding a\overrightarrow a to the third equation: a+b+c=(k3+1)a\overrightarrow a + \overrightarrow b + \overrightarrow c = (k_3 + 1) \overrightarrow a This shows that the vector sum a+b+c\overrightarrow a + \overrightarrow b + \overrightarrow c is parallel to a\overrightarrow a.

Step 5: Conclude the value of the vector sum. Let S=a+b+c\overrightarrow S = \overrightarrow a + \overrightarrow b + \overrightarrow c. We have shown that S\overrightarrow S is parallel to a\overrightarrow a, b\overrightarrow b, and c\overrightarrow c. If a,b,c\overrightarrow a, \overrightarrow b, \overrightarrow c are non-zero and not all parallel to each other, the only vector that can be parallel to all three is the zero vector. Thus, S=0\overrightarrow S = \overrightarrow 0. So, a+b+c=0\overrightarrow a + \overrightarrow b + \overrightarrow c = \overrightarrow 0.

Step 6: Interpret the result in the context of the options. The question asks for the value of a+b+c\overrightarrow a + \overrightarrow b + \overrightarrow c, and the options are scalar values: (A) abcabc, (B) 1-1, (C) 00, (D) 22. For a vector to be equal to a scalar, both must be zero. This means we must have a+b+c=0\overrightarrow a + \overrightarrow b + \overrightarrow c = \overrightarrow 0 and the scalar value must also be 00. From our derivation, a+b+c=0\overrightarrow a + \overrightarrow b + \overrightarrow c = \overrightarrow 0. For option (A) abcabc to be the correct answer, it must be that abc=0abc = 0. The condition abc=0abc = 0 implies that at least one of the magnitudes of the vectors a|\overrightarrow a|, b|\overrightarrow b|, or c|\overrightarrow c| is zero. This means at least one of the vectors a\overrightarrow a, b\overrightarrow b, or c\overrightarrow c is the zero vector.

Let's consider a degenerate case where one of the vectors is the zero vector. Assume a=0\overrightarrow a = \overrightarrow 0. Then a=a=0a = |\overrightarrow a| = 0, and abc=0bc=0abc = 0 \cdot |\overrightarrow b| \cdot |\overrightarrow c| = 0. The given condition becomes: 0×b=b×c=c×0\overrightarrow 0 \times \overrightarrow b = \overrightarrow b \times \overrightarrow c = \overrightarrow c \times \overrightarrow 0 0=b×c=0\overrightarrow 0 = \overrightarrow b \times \overrightarrow c = \overrightarrow 0 This implies b×c=0\overrightarrow b \times \overrightarrow c = \overrightarrow 0, which means b\overrightarrow b and c\overrightarrow c are parallel or one of them is zero.

The sum a+b+c\overrightarrow a + \overrightarrow b + \overrightarrow c becomes: 0+b+c=b+c\overrightarrow 0 + \overrightarrow b + \overrightarrow c = \overrightarrow b + \overrightarrow c For a+b+c\overrightarrow a + \overrightarrow b + \overrightarrow c to be equal to abcabc, we need b+c=0\overrightarrow b + \overrightarrow c = 0. This means c=b\overrightarrow c = -\overrightarrow b. If c=b\overrightarrow c = -\overrightarrow b, then b\overrightarrow b and c\overrightarrow c are anti-parallel, which is a specific case of being parallel. Let's verify this scenario: If a=0\overrightarrow a = \overrightarrow 0 and c=b\overrightarrow c = -\overrightarrow b:

  • a×b=0×b=0\overrightarrow a \times \overrightarrow b = \overrightarrow 0 \times \overrightarrow b = \overrightarrow 0
  • b×c=b×(b)=(b×b)=0=0\overrightarrow b \times \overrightarrow c = \overrightarrow b \times (-\overrightarrow b) = -(\overrightarrow b \times \overrightarrow b) = -\overrightarrow 0 = \overrightarrow 0
  • c×a=(b)×0=0\overrightarrow c \times \overrightarrow a = (-\overrightarrow b) \times \overrightarrow 0 = \overrightarrow 0 The condition a×b=b×c=c×a\overrightarrow a \times \overrightarrow b = \overrightarrow b \times \overrightarrow c = \overrightarrow c \times \overrightarrow a is satisfied, as all are 0\overrightarrow 0.

Now, let's evaluate the sum a+b+c\overrightarrow a + \overrightarrow b + \overrightarrow c: a+b+c=0+b+(b)=0\overrightarrow a + \overrightarrow b + \overrightarrow c = \overrightarrow 0 + \overrightarrow b + (-\overrightarrow b) = \overrightarrow 0 And the value of abcabc: abc=abc=0bb=0abc = |\overrightarrow a| |\overrightarrow b| |\overrightarrow c| = 0 \cdot |\overrightarrow b| \cdot |-\overrightarrow b| = 0 So, in this degenerate case, a+b+c=0\overrightarrow a + \overrightarrow b + \overrightarrow c = 0 and abc=0abc = 0. Thus, a+b+c=abc\overrightarrow a + \overrightarrow b + \overrightarrow c = abc holds true.

3. Common Mistakes & Tips

  • Vector vs. Scalar Interpretation: Be mindful that a vector sum usually results in a vector. If the options are scalars, it often implies that the vector sum is the zero vector, and the scalar option must also evaluate to zero in a consistent scenario.
  • Degenerate Cases: For problems with scalar options, always check if a degenerate case (where one or more vectors are zero) can satisfy the given conditions and lead to one of the scalar options.
  • Systematic Algebraic Manipulation: Break down the vector cross product equalities and use their properties systematically to derive relationships between the vectors.

4. Summary

The condition a×b=b×c=c×a\overrightarrow a \times \overrightarrow b = \overrightarrow b \times \overrightarrow c = \overrightarrow c \times \overrightarrow a implies that a+b+c=0\overrightarrow a + \overrightarrow b + \overrightarrow c = \overrightarrow 0. Given that the options are scalar values and the correct answer is abcabc, this necessitates a scenario where both the vector sum is zero and the scalar product of magnitudes is zero. The latter condition, abc=0abc=0, is met if at least one of the vectors is the zero vector. In such a degenerate case, for instance, if a=0\overrightarrow a = \overrightarrow 0 and c=b\overrightarrow c = -\overrightarrow b, the original cross product conditions are satisfied (all resulting in the zero vector), and the vector sum a+b+c\overrightarrow a + \overrightarrow b + \overrightarrow c is the zero vector, which equals abcabc (since abc=0abc=0).

The final answer is A\boxed{A}.

Practice More Vector Algebra Questions

View All Questions