Skip to main content
Back to Vector Algebra
JEE Main 2020
Vector Algebra
Vector Algebra
Medium

Question

If u,v,w\overrightarrow u ,\overrightarrow v ,\overrightarrow w are non-coplanar vectors and p,qp,q are real numbers, then the equality [3upvpw][pvwqu][2wqvqu]=0\left[ {3\overrightarrow u \,\,p\overrightarrow v \,\,p\overrightarrow w } \right] - \left[ {p\overrightarrow v \,\,\overrightarrow w \,\,q\overrightarrow u } \right] - \left[ {2\overrightarrow w \,\,q\overrightarrow v \,\,q\overrightarrow u } \right] = 0 holds for :

Options

Solution

Key Concepts and Formulas

  • Scalar Triple Product (STP): The scalar triple product of three vectors a,b,c\overrightarrow a, \overrightarrow b, \overrightarrow c is denoted by [abc][\overrightarrow a \,\,\overrightarrow b \,\,\overrightarrow c ] and represents the volume of the parallelepiped formed by these vectors.
  • Properties of STP:
    • Scalar Multiplication: [k1ak2bk3c]=k1k2k3[abc][k_1 \overrightarrow a \,\, k_2 \overrightarrow b \,\, k_3 \overrightarrow c ] = k_1 k_2 k_3 [\overrightarrow a \,\,\overrightarrow b \,\,\overrightarrow c ].
    • Cyclic Permutation: [abc]=[bca]=[cab][\overrightarrow a \,\,\overrightarrow b \,\,\overrightarrow c ] = [\overrightarrow b \,\,\overrightarrow c \,\,\overrightarrow a ] = [\overrightarrow c \,\,\overrightarrow a \,\,\overrightarrow b ].
    • Non-coplanarity: If u,v,w\overrightarrow u, \overrightarrow v, \overrightarrow w are non-coplanar, then [uvw]0[\overrightarrow u \,\,\overrightarrow v \,\,\overrightarrow w ] \neq 0.

Step-by-Step Solution

We are given the equation: [3upvpw][pvwqu][2wqvqu]=0\left[ {3\overrightarrow u \,\,p\overrightarrow v \,\,p\overrightarrow w } \right] - \left[ {p\overrightarrow v \,\,\overrightarrow w \,\,q\overrightarrow u } \right] - \left[ {2\overrightarrow w \,\,q\overrightarrow v \,\,q\overrightarrow u } \right] = 0 We are also given that u,v,w\overrightarrow u, \overrightarrow v, \overrightarrow w are non-coplanar vectors, which implies that [uvw]0[\overrightarrow u \,\,\overrightarrow v \,\,\overrightarrow w ] \neq 0.

Step 1: Apply the scalar multiplication property of the scalar triple product to each term in the given equation. The first term is [3upvpw][3\overrightarrow u \,\,p\overrightarrow v \,\,p\overrightarrow w ]. Using the property, we can take out the scalars 3, p, and p: [3upvpw]=3pp[uvw]=3p2[uvw][3\overrightarrow u \,\,p\overrightarrow v \,\,p\overrightarrow w ] = 3 \cdot p \cdot p [\overrightarrow u \,\,\overrightarrow v \,\,\overrightarrow w ] = 3p^2 [\overrightarrow u \,\,\overrightarrow v \,\,\overrightarrow w ] The second term is [pvwqu][p\overrightarrow v \,\,\overrightarrow w \,\,q\overrightarrow u ]. Taking out the scalars p, 1, and q: [pvwqu]=p1q[vwu]=pq[vwu][p\overrightarrow v \,\,\overrightarrow w \,\,q\overrightarrow u ] = p \cdot 1 \cdot q [\overrightarrow v \,\,\overrightarrow w \,\,\overrightarrow u ] = pq [\overrightarrow v \,\,\overrightarrow w \,\,\overrightarrow u ] The third term is [2wqvqu][2\overrightarrow w \,\,q\overrightarrow v \,\,q\overrightarrow u ]. Taking out the scalars 2, q, and q: [2wqvqu]=2qq[wvu]=2q2[wvu][2\overrightarrow w \,\,q\overrightarrow v \,\,q\overrightarrow u ] = 2 \cdot q \cdot q [\overrightarrow w \,\,\overrightarrow v \,\,\overrightarrow u ] = 2q^2 [\overrightarrow w \,\,\overrightarrow v \,\,\overrightarrow u ] So the equation becomes: 3p2[uvw]pq[vwu]2q2[wvu]=03p^2 [\overrightarrow u \,\,\overrightarrow v \,\,\overrightarrow w ] - pq [\overrightarrow v \,\,\overrightarrow w \,\,\overrightarrow u ] - 2q^2 [\overrightarrow w \,\,\overrightarrow v \,\,\overrightarrow u ] = 0

Step 2: Use the cyclic permutation property of the scalar triple product to express all terms with the same base STP, i.e., [uvw][\overrightarrow u \,\,\overrightarrow v \,\,\overrightarrow w ]. We know that [vwu]=[uvw][\overrightarrow v \,\,\overrightarrow w \,\,\overrightarrow u ] = [\overrightarrow u \,\,\overrightarrow v \,\,\overrightarrow w ] (one cyclic shift). We also know that [wvu]=[uvw][\overrightarrow w \,\,\overrightarrow v \,\,\overrightarrow u ] = -[\overrightarrow u \,\,\overrightarrow v \,\,\overrightarrow w ] (swapping two vectors negates the STP). Substituting these into the equation from Step 1: 3p2[uvw]pq[uvw]2q2([uvw])=03p^2 [\overrightarrow u \,\,\overrightarrow v \,\,\overrightarrow w ] - pq [\overrightarrow u \,\,\overrightarrow v \,\,\overrightarrow w ] - 2q^2 (-[\overrightarrow u \,\,\overrightarrow v \,\,\overrightarrow w ]) = 0

Step 3: Simplify the equation by factoring out the common term [uvw][\overrightarrow u \,\,\overrightarrow v \,\,\overrightarrow w ]. 3p2[uvw]pq[uvw]+2q2[uvw]=03p^2 [\overrightarrow u \,\,\overrightarrow v \,\,\overrightarrow w ] - pq [\overrightarrow u \,\,\overrightarrow v \,\,\overrightarrow w ] + 2q^2 [\overrightarrow u \,\,\overrightarrow v \,\,\overrightarrow w ] = 0 (3p2pq+2q2)[uvw]=0(3p^2 - pq + 2q^2) [\overrightarrow u \,\,\overrightarrow v \,\,\overrightarrow w ] = 0

Step 4: Since u,v,w\overrightarrow u, \overrightarrow v, \overrightarrow w are non-coplanar, we have [uvw]0[\overrightarrow u \,\,\overrightarrow v \,\,\overrightarrow w ] \neq 0. Therefore, for the equation to hold, the scalar factor must be zero. 3p2pq+2q2=03p^2 - pq + 2q^2 = 0

Step 5: Analyze the quadratic form 3p2pq+2q2=03p^2 - pq + 2q^2 = 0 to determine the values of pp and qq that satisfy it. We can treat this as a quadratic equation in pp (or qq). Let's consider it as a quadratic in pp: 3p2(q)p+2q2=03p^2 - (q)p + 2q^2 = 0. For real solutions of pp, the discriminant of this quadratic must be non-negative. The discriminant is given by Δ=b24ac\Delta = b^2 - 4ac, where a=3a=3, b=qb=-q, and c=2q2c=2q^2. Δ=(q)24(3)(2q2)\Delta = (-q)^2 - 4(3)(2q^2) Δ=q224q2\Delta = q^2 - 24q^2 Δ=23q2\Delta = -23q^2 For real values of pp, we need Δ0\Delta \ge 0. 23q20-23q^2 \ge 0 Since q20q^2 \ge 0 for any real number qq, the term 23q2-23q^2 is always less than or equal to 0. The only way for 23q20-23q^2 \ge 0 to be true is if q2=0q^2 = 0, which implies q=0q=0.

If q=0q=0, substitute this back into the equation 3p2pq+2q2=03p^2 - pq + 2q^2 = 0: 3p2p(0)+2(0)2=03p^2 - p(0) + 2(0)^2 = 0 3p2=03p^2 = 0 This implies p=0p=0.

So, the only real solution for (p,q)(p,q) that satisfies 3p2pq+2q2=03p^2 - pq + 2q^2 = 0 is (p,q)=(0,0)(p,q) = (0,0).

Step 6: Interpret the result in terms of the number of possible values for (p,q)(p,q). We found that the equality holds only for the specific pair of values (p,q)=(0,0)(p,q) = (0,0). This means there is exactly one pair of values (p,q)(p,q) for which the given equality holds.

Common Mistakes & Tips

  • Incorrect application of STP properties: Ensure that scalar multiplication and cyclic permutation properties are applied correctly, especially with regard to signs when vectors are swapped.
  • Ignoring the non-coplanarity condition: The condition that vectors are non-coplanar is crucial, as it allows us to divide by [uvw][\overrightarrow u \,\,\overrightarrow v \,\,\overrightarrow w ] (or more precisely, to set the scalar coefficient to zero).
  • Mistakes in analyzing the quadratic form: When analyzing 3p2pq+2q2=03p^2 - pq + 2q^2 = 0, it's important to correctly calculate the discriminant and understand its implications for real solutions. A common mistake is to assume that if the discriminant is negative, there are no solutions, without considering the case where the expression is identically zero. In this case, if q0q \neq 0, the discriminant is strictly negative, meaning no real solutions for pp. If q=0q=0, the discriminant is zero, and we get a solution.

Summary

The problem involves simplifying a given equation involving scalar triple products of non-coplanar vectors. By applying the properties of scalar triple products, the equation reduces to a condition on the real numbers pp and qq: 3p2pq+2q2=03p^2 - pq + 2q^2 = 0. Analyzing this quadratic form reveals that the only real solution for (p,q)(p,q) is (0,0)(0,0). Therefore, the equality holds for exactly one pair of values of (p,q)(p,q).

The final answer is \boxed{A}.

Practice More Vector Algebra Questions

View All Questions