Skip to main content
Back to Vector Algebra
JEE Main 2020
Vector Algebra
Vector Algebra
Hard

Question

Let three vectors a\overrightarrow a , b\overrightarrow b and c\overrightarrow c be such that a×b=c\overrightarrow a \times \overrightarrow b = \overrightarrow c , b×c=a\overrightarrow b \times \overrightarrow c = \overrightarrow a and a=2\left| {\overrightarrow a } \right| = 2. Then which one of the following is not true?

Options

Solution

Key Concepts and Formulas

  • Cross Product Properties:
    • u×v\overrightarrow u \times \overrightarrow v is a vector perpendicular to both u\overrightarrow u and v\overrightarrow v. This implies (u×v)u=0(\overrightarrow u \times \overrightarrow v) \cdot \overrightarrow u = 0 and (u×v)v=0(\overrightarrow u \times \overrightarrow v) \cdot \overrightarrow v = 0.
    • u×v=uvsinθ|\overrightarrow u \times \overrightarrow v| = |\overrightarrow u| |\overrightarrow v| \sin \theta, where θ\theta is the angle between u\overrightarrow u and v\overrightarrow v. If uv\overrightarrow u \perp \overrightarrow v, then θ=90\theta = 90^\circ, so u×v=uv|\overrightarrow u \times \overrightarrow v| = |\overrightarrow u| |\overrightarrow v|.
    • u×v=(v×u)\overrightarrow u \times \overrightarrow v = -(\overrightarrow v \times \overrightarrow u).
  • Scalar Triple Product (STP): [u v w]=(u×v)w[\overrightarrow u \ \overrightarrow v \ \overrightarrow w] = (\overrightarrow u \times \overrightarrow v) \cdot \overrightarrow w. Cyclical permutation preserves the value: [u v w]=[v w u]=[w u v][\overrightarrow u \ \overrightarrow v \ \overrightarrow w] = [\overrightarrow v \ \overrightarrow w \ \overrightarrow u] = [\overrightarrow w \ \overrightarrow u \ \overrightarrow v]. If vectors are mutually orthogonal, [u v w]=±uvw[\overrightarrow u \ \overrightarrow v \ \overrightarrow w] = \pm |\overrightarrow u| |\overrightarrow v| |\overrightarrow w|.
  • Vector Triple Product (VTP): u×(v×w)=(uw)v(uv)w\overrightarrow u \times (\overrightarrow v \times \overrightarrow w) = (\overrightarrow u \cdot \overrightarrow w) \overrightarrow v - (\overrightarrow u \cdot \overrightarrow v) \overrightarrow w.
  • Magnitude Squared: For mutually orthogonal vectors x,y,z\overrightarrow x, \overrightarrow y, \overrightarrow z, k1x+k2y+k3z2=k12x2+k22y2+k32z2|k_1 \overrightarrow x + k_2 \overrightarrow y + k_3 \overrightarrow z|^2 = k_1^2 |\overrightarrow x|^2 + k_2^2 |\overrightarrow y|^2 + k_3^2 |\overrightarrow z|^2.
  • Projection of u\overrightarrow u on v\overrightarrow v: projvu=uvv\text{proj}_{\overrightarrow v} \overrightarrow u = \frac{\overrightarrow u \cdot \overrightarrow v}{|\overrightarrow v|}.

Step-by-Step Solution

Step 1: Deduce mutual orthogonality and magnitudes of the vectors. We are given a×b=c\overrightarrow a \times \overrightarrow b = \overrightarrow c and b×c=a\overrightarrow b \times \overrightarrow c = \overrightarrow a. From a×b=c\overrightarrow a \times \overrightarrow b = \overrightarrow c, we know that c\overrightarrow c is perpendicular to both a\overrightarrow a and b\overrightarrow b. Thus, ca=0\overrightarrow c \cdot \overrightarrow a = 0 and cb=0\overrightarrow c \cdot \overrightarrow b = 0. From b×c=a\overrightarrow b \times \overrightarrow c = \overrightarrow a, we know that a\overrightarrow a is perpendicular to both b\overrightarrow b and c\overrightarrow c. Thus, ab=0\overrightarrow a \cdot \overrightarrow b = 0 and ac=0\overrightarrow a \cdot \overrightarrow c = 0. Therefore, a,b,c\overrightarrow a, \overrightarrow b, \overrightarrow c are mutually orthogonal.

Since they are mutually orthogonal, for the cross product magnitudes, we have x×y=xy|\overrightarrow x \times \overrightarrow y| = |\overrightarrow x| |\overrightarrow y|. From a×b=c\overrightarrow a \times \overrightarrow b = \overrightarrow c, we get ab=c|\overrightarrow a| |\overrightarrow b| = |\overrightarrow c|. From b×c=a\overrightarrow b \times \overrightarrow c = \overrightarrow a, we get bc=a|\overrightarrow b| |\overrightarrow c| = |\overrightarrow a|. We are given a=2|\overrightarrow a| = 2. Substituting a=2|\overrightarrow a| = 2 into the equations:

  1. 2b=c2 |\overrightarrow b| = |\overrightarrow c|
  2. bc=2|\overrightarrow b| |\overrightarrow c| = 2 Substitute (1) into (2): b(2b)=2    2b2=2    b2=1    b=1|\overrightarrow b| (2|\overrightarrow b|) = 2 \implies 2|\overrightarrow b|^2 = 2 \implies |\overrightarrow b|^2 = 1 \implies |\overrightarrow b| = 1. Substitute b=1|\overrightarrow b| = 1 back into (1): 2(1)=c    c=22(1) = |\overrightarrow c| \implies |\overrightarrow c| = 2. So, the magnitudes are a=2|\overrightarrow a| = 2, b=1|\overrightarrow b| = 1, and c=2|\overrightarrow c| = 2.

Step 2: Analyze Option (A). We need to check if a×((b+c)×(b×c))=0\overrightarrow a \times \left( {(\overrightarrow b + \overrightarrow c ) \times (\overrightarrow b \times \overrightarrow c )} \right) = \overrightarrow 0. Using b×c=a\overrightarrow b \times \overrightarrow c = \overrightarrow a, the expression becomes: a×((b+c)×a)\overrightarrow a \times \left( {(\overrightarrow b + \overrightarrow c ) \times \overrightarrow a } \right) Using the distributive property of cross product: =a×(b×a+c×a)= \overrightarrow a \times \left( {\overrightarrow b \times \overrightarrow a + \overrightarrow c \times \overrightarrow a } \right) We know b×a=(a×b)=c\overrightarrow b \times \overrightarrow a = -(\overrightarrow a \times \overrightarrow b) = -\overrightarrow c. To find c×a\overrightarrow c \times \overrightarrow a, we can use the VTP formula x×(y×z)=(xz)y(xy)z\overrightarrow x \times (\overrightarrow y \times \overrightarrow z) = (\overrightarrow x \cdot \overrightarrow z) \overrightarrow y - (\overrightarrow x \cdot \overrightarrow y) \overrightarrow z. Consider c×(b×c)=c×a\overrightarrow c \times (\overrightarrow b \times \overrightarrow c) = \overrightarrow c \times \overrightarrow a. Here, x=c,y=b,z=c\overrightarrow x = \overrightarrow c, \overrightarrow y = \overrightarrow b, \overrightarrow z = \overrightarrow c. c×a=(cc)b(cb)c=c2b0c=c2b\overrightarrow c \times \overrightarrow a = (\overrightarrow c \cdot \overrightarrow c) \overrightarrow b - (\overrightarrow c \cdot \overrightarrow b) \overrightarrow c = |\overrightarrow c|^2 \overrightarrow b - 0 \cdot \overrightarrow c = |\overrightarrow c|^2 \overrightarrow b. Since c=2|\overrightarrow c| = 2, we have c×a=22b=4b\overrightarrow c \times \overrightarrow a = 2^2 \overrightarrow b = 4\overrightarrow b. Substituting back into the expression: =a×(c+4b)= \overrightarrow a \times \left( {-\overrightarrow c + 4\overrightarrow b } \right) =a×(c)+a×(4b)= \overrightarrow a \times (-\overrightarrow c) + \overrightarrow a \times (4\overrightarrow b) =(a×c)+4(a×b)= -(\overrightarrow a \times \overrightarrow c) + 4(\overrightarrow a \times \overrightarrow b) We know a×c=(c×a)=(4b)=4b\overrightarrow a \times \overrightarrow c = -(\overrightarrow c \times \overrightarrow a) = -(4\overrightarrow b) = -4\overrightarrow b. And a×b=c\overrightarrow a \times \overrightarrow b = \overrightarrow c. So, the expression becomes: =(4b)+4(c)=4b+4c= -(-4\overrightarrow b) + 4(\overrightarrow c) = 4\overrightarrow b + 4\overrightarrow c. Since b\overrightarrow b and c\overrightarrow c are non-zero and orthogonal, 4b+4c04\overrightarrow b + 4\overrightarrow c \neq \overrightarrow 0. Therefore, Option (A) is not true.

Step 3: Analyze Option (B). The projection of a\overrightarrow a on (b×c)(\overrightarrow b \times \overrightarrow c) is given by a(b×c)b×c\frac{\overrightarrow a \cdot (\overrightarrow b \times \overrightarrow c)}{|\overrightarrow b \times \overrightarrow c|}. We know b×c=a\overrightarrow b \times \overrightarrow c = \overrightarrow a. So, the projection is aaa=a2a=a\frac{\overrightarrow a \cdot \overrightarrow a}{|\overrightarrow a|} = \frac{|\overrightarrow a|^2}{|\overrightarrow a|} = |\overrightarrow a|. Since a=2|\overrightarrow a| = 2, the projection is 2. Therefore, Option (B) is true.

Step 4: Analyze Option (C). We need to check if [a b c]+[c a b]=8[\overrightarrow a \ \overrightarrow b \ \overrightarrow c] + [\overrightarrow c \ \overrightarrow a \ \overrightarrow b] = 8. Using the property of cyclic permutation of STP, [c a b]=[a b c][\overrightarrow c \ \overrightarrow a \ \overrightarrow b] = [\overrightarrow a \ \overrightarrow b \ \overrightarrow c]. So, the expression is 2[a b c]2 [\overrightarrow a \ \overrightarrow b \ \overrightarrow c]. [a b c]=(a×b)c[\overrightarrow a \ \overrightarrow b \ \overrightarrow c] = (\overrightarrow a \times \overrightarrow b) \cdot \overrightarrow c. Given a×b=c\overrightarrow a \times \overrightarrow b = \overrightarrow c, so [a b c]=cc=c2[\overrightarrow a \ \overrightarrow b \ \overrightarrow c] = \overrightarrow c \cdot \overrightarrow c = |\overrightarrow c|^2. Since c=2|\overrightarrow c| = 2, c2=4|\overrightarrow c|^2 = 4. Thus, 2[a b c]=2×4=82 [\overrightarrow a \ \overrightarrow b \ \overrightarrow c] = 2 \times 4 = 8. Therefore, Option (C) is true.

Step 5: Analyze Option (D). We need to check if 3a+b2c2=51|3\overrightarrow a + \overrightarrow b - 2\overrightarrow c |^2 = 51. Since a,b,c\overrightarrow a, \overrightarrow b, \overrightarrow c are mutually orthogonal, we can use the property k1x+k2y+k3z2=k12x2+k22y2+k32z2|k_1 \overrightarrow x + k_2 \overrightarrow y + k_3 \overrightarrow z|^2 = k_1^2 |\overrightarrow x|^2 + k_2^2 |\overrightarrow y|^2 + k_3^2 |\overrightarrow z|^2. 3a+b2c2=(3a)2+(1b)2+(2c)2|3\overrightarrow a + \overrightarrow b - 2\overrightarrow c |^2 = (3|\overrightarrow a|)^2 + (1|\overrightarrow b|)^2 + (-2|\overrightarrow c|)^2 =9a2+b2+4c2= 9|\overrightarrow a|^2 + |\overrightarrow b|^2 + 4|\overrightarrow c|^2. Substituting the magnitudes a=2,b=1,c=2|\overrightarrow a| = 2, |\overrightarrow b| = 1, |\overrightarrow c| = 2: =9(22)+(12)+4(22)= 9(2^2) + (1^2) + 4(2^2) =9(4)+1+4(4)= 9(4) + 1 + 4(4) =36+1+16=53= 36 + 1 + 16 = 53. The value is 53, not 51. Therefore, Option (D) is not true.

Common Mistakes & Tips

  • Confusing Orthogonality: Always confirm mutual orthogonality first, as it drastically simplifies magnitude calculations for sums of vectors.
  • Vector Triple Product Errors: Be careful with the order of vectors and the dot products in the VTP formula.
  • Sign Errors in Cross Products: Remember that u×v=(v×u)\overrightarrow u \times \overrightarrow v = -(\overrightarrow v \times \overrightarrow u).

Summary

The problem requires deducing the orthogonality and magnitudes of the given vectors from the cross product conditions. We found that a,b,c\overrightarrow a, \overrightarrow b, \overrightarrow c are mutually orthogonal with magnitudes a=2,b=1,c=2|\overrightarrow a|=2, |\overrightarrow b|=1, |\overrightarrow c|=2. We then evaluated each option: Option (A) resulted in 4b+4c4\overrightarrow b + 4\overrightarrow c, which is not the zero vector. Option (B) correctly calculated the projection as 2. Option (C) correctly evaluated the sum of scalar triple products to 8. Option (D) calculated the squared magnitude to be 53, not 51. Since the question asks for the statement that is NOT true, and Option (A) is demonstrably false, it is the answer.

The final answer is A\boxed{A}.

Practice More Vector Algebra Questions

View All Questions