Skip to main content
Back to Mathematical Reasoning
JEE Main 2019
Mathematical Reasoning
Mathematical Reasoning
Easy

Question

If q is false and p \wedge q \leftrightarrow r is true, then which one of the following statements is a tautology ?

Options

Solution

Key Concepts and Formulas

  • Logical AND (\wedge): pqp \wedge q is true only if both pp and qq are true. Otherwise, it's false.
  • Logical Equivalence (\leftrightarrow): pqp \leftrightarrow q is true if both pp and qq have the same truth value (both true or both false). Otherwise, it's false.
  • Tautology: A statement that is always true, regardless of the truth values of its components.
  • Logical OR (\vee): pqp \vee q is true if at least one of pp or qq is true. It's false only if both are false.
  • Logical Implication (\to): pqp \to q is true if pp is false, or if qq is true (or both). It is only false when pp is true and qq is false.

Step-by-Step Solution

Step 1: Analyze the given information. We are given that qq is false (F) and (pq)r(p \wedge q) \leftrightarrow r is true (T).

Step 2: Determine the truth value of pqp \wedge q. Since qq is false, pqp \wedge q must also be false, regardless of the truth value of pp. This is because for pqp \wedge q to be true, both pp and qq must be true, and we know qq is false. So, pq=Fp \wedge q = F.

Step 3: Determine the truth value of rr. We know that (pq)r(p \wedge q) \leftrightarrow r is true, and we just found that pqp \wedge q is false. Therefore, rr must also be false for the equivalence to be true. If rr were true, then (pq)r(p \wedge q) \leftrightarrow r would be false. So, r=Fr = F.

Step 4: Evaluate the truth values of the given options. Now that we know q=Fq = F and r=Fr = F, we can analyze each option to see which one is a tautology.

(A) prp \wedge r Since rr is false, prp \wedge r is always false, regardless of the truth value of pp. Thus, this is not a tautology.

(B) (pr)(pr)(p \vee r) \to (p \wedge r) Since rr is false, this becomes (pF)(pF)(p \vee F) \to (p \wedge F), which simplifies to pFp \to F. This statement is false when pp is true and false when pp is false. Thus, it is not a tautology.

(C) prp \vee r Since rr is false, this becomes pFp \vee F, which simplifies to pp. This statement is true when pp is true and false when pp is false. Thus, it is not a tautology.

(D) (pr)(pr)(p \wedge r) \to (p \vee r) Since rr is false, prp \wedge r is always false. Therefore, the statement becomes F(pF)F \to (p \vee F), which is equivalent to FpF \to p. Since FxF \to x is always true, this statement is a tautology.

Step 5: Verify the correct answer. We need to check if the answer we arrived at matches the given correct answer, which is option (D).

Common Mistakes & Tips

  • Remember the truth tables for the logical operators. A quick reference can prevent errors.
  • When dealing with equivalences, remember that both sides must have the same truth value for the entire statement to be true.
  • A statement is a tautology if and only if it is always true, regardless of the truth values of its components. Don't settle for just one case where the statement is true.

Summary

We are given that qq is false and (pq)r(p \wedge q) \leftrightarrow r is true. From this, we deduced that rr is also false. Then, we evaluated each of the given options with r=Fr = F to determine which one is a tautology. We found that option (D), (pr)(pr)(p \wedge r) \to (p \vee r), is a tautology because when rr is false, prp \wedge r is always false, making the implication always true.

Final Answer

The final answer is \boxed{(p \wedge r) \to (p \vee r)}, which corresponds to option (D).

Practice More Mathematical Reasoning Questions

View All Questions