Question
If {\Delta _1} = \left| {\matrix{ x & {\sin \theta } & {\cos \theta } \cr { - \sin \theta } & { - x} & 1 \cr {\cos \theta } & 1 & x \cr } } \right| and {\Delta _2} = \left| {\matrix{ x & {\sin 2\theta } & {\cos 2\theta } \cr { - \sin 2\theta } & { - x} & 1 \cr {\cos 2\theta } & 1 & x \cr } } \right|, ; then for all :
Options
Solution
This problem requires us to evaluate two determinants, and , and then find the relationship between them. The core concept involved is the systematic expansion of a determinant and the application of fundamental trigonometric identities.
1. Key Concept: Expansion of a Determinant
To evaluate a determinant, we typically expand it along a row or a column. For a general matrix , its determinant, denoted as or , when expanded along the first row, is given by: Each minor determinant is calculated as . The signs () for the terms in the expansion follow a checkerboard pattern starting with for the element.
2. Step-by-Step Evaluation of
Given the determinant: {\Delta _1} = \left| {\matrix{ x & {\sin \theta } & {\cos \theta } \cr { - \sin \theta } & { - x} & 1 \cr {\cos \theta } & 1 & x \cr } } \right|
Let's expand along its first row: {\Delta _1} = x \cdot \left| {\matrix{ { - x} & 1 \cr 1 & x \cr } } \right| - \sin \theta \cdot \left| {\matrix{ { - \sin \theta } & 1 \cr {\cos \theta } & x \cr } } \right| + \cos \theta \cdot \left| {\matrix{ { - \sin \theta } & { - x} \cr {\cos \theta } & 1 \cr } } \right|
Now, we evaluate each minor determinant:
- The minor for :
- The minor for :
- The minor for :
Substitute these back into the expansion:
Next, distribute the terms:
Notice that the terms and cancel each other out:
Factor out from the trigonometric terms:
Apply the fundamental trigonometric identity: .
3. Step-by-Step Evaluation of
Given the determinant: {\Delta _2} = \left| {\matrix{ x & {\sin 2\theta } & {\cos 2\theta } \cr { - \sin 2\theta } & { - x} & 1 \cr {\cos 2\theta } & 1 & x \cr } } \right|
Observe that the structure of is identical to , with every instance of replaced by . This means the entire expansion process will follow the same steps. If we substitute for in the simplified expression for , we get:
Applying the same trigonometric identity (where ):
4. Comparing with Options
We have found that and . Now let's examine the given options:
-
Option (A): Substituting our calculated values: So, option (A) would imply . Since , this would require for all . This is not universally true (e.g., for , and , which are not equal). Thus, this option is generally incorrect.
-
Option (B): Substituting our calculated values: This matches the option perfectly.
-
Option (C): Substituting our calculated values: This simplifies to , which means , or . This is not true for all . Thus, this option is generally incorrect.
-
Option (D): Substituting our calculated values: So, . Since , this implies , which means . No, this implies , which is false for . Thus, this option is incorrect.
Based on our calculations, Option (B) is the correct relationship.
5. Tips and Common Mistakes
- Sign Errors: The most common mistake in determinant expansion is incorrect signs. Remember the checkerboard pattern of signs for cofactors: .
- Algebraic Simplification: Be careful with distributing negative signs and combining like terms.
- Trigonometric Identities: Always look for opportunities to simplify expressions using fundamental identities like . This often dramatically reduces the complexity of the problem.
- Pattern Recognition: In problems involving similar determinants (like and here), solving one completely often provides a direct path to the solution of the other, saving time and reducing the chance of repeated errors.
- Discrepancy Note: Based on the detailed step-by-step evaluation, and . This leads directly to (Option B) and . If the provided correct answer is (A), it implies , which is only true for specific values of (like ) and not for all . Therefore, based on standard mathematical evaluation, Option (B) is the logically consistent answer.
6. Summary and Key Takeaway
This problem demonstrates a straightforward application of determinant expansion for matrices. The key steps involved were:
- Systematically expanding the determinant along a row or column.
- Carefully performing algebraic simplifications.
- Recognizing and applying the fundamental trigonometric identity .
- Leveraging the structural similarity between and to quickly evaluate both.
The final result is that both determinants simplify to , making their sum . Mastery of determinant evaluation and trigonometric identities is crucial for such problems in JEE Mathematics.
The final answer is .