Question
Let . Let be a relation on defined by if and only if . Let be a symmetric relation on such that and the number of elements in is . Then, the minimum value of is _________.
Answer: 3
Solution
Key Concepts and Formulas
- Symmetric Relation: A relation on a set is symmetric if for every , it must also be true that .
- Minimum Symmetric Relation: The smallest symmetric relation containing a given relation is formed by taking all elements of and adding the reverse of each element that is not already in . This can be expressed as .
- Cardinality of Union: For any two sets and , the number of elements in their union is given by .
Step-by-Step Solution
Step 1: Determine the elements of the relation . The set is . The relation is defined by if and only if , where . From , we can deduce that must be a multiple of 3 and must be a multiple of 2. Let for some integer . Substituting this into the equation gives , which simplifies to , so . Now we need to ensure that and are within the set . For : . Dividing by 3, we get , so . Since must be an integer, . For : . Dividing by 2, we get , so . For both conditions to be met, must be an integer such that . Thus, the elements of are of the form for . The number of elements in is . The elements of are: .
Step 2: Identify elements that would make symmetric. We are looking for a symmetric relation such that and is minimized. The minimum symmetric relation is formed by , where . The number of elements in is . Since is formed by reversing all pairs in , . We need to find , which represents the number of pairs such that is also in .
Let's consider a pair . This means . If is also in , then . We have the system of equations:
From equation (1), . Substitute this into equation (2): . Since , cannot be 0. Therefore, there is no pair such that . This means , so .
Also, we must check for pairs of the form . If , then , which implies . Since , there are no such pairs in .
Step 3: Calculate the minimum number of elements in . Using the formula for the cardinality of the union: We found , , and . So, . The number of elements in is . Therefore, the minimum value of is 66.
Common Mistakes & Tips
- Overlooking domain constraints: Ensure that all elements derived for and are within the given set . This is crucial for correctly determining .
- Assuming symmetry for all pairs: Do not assume that if , then is automatically in . Always verify the symmetry condition for the specific relation.
- Forgetting : While in this problem is empty, in general, it's important to calculate it. Pairs and pairs where is also in contribute to .
Summary We first identified the elements of the relation by solving the equation under the constraint . This led to , giving . We then analyzed the symmetry property. By solving the system and , we found that no pair has its reverse also in , meaning . The minimum symmetric relation containing is , and its size is .
The final answer is .