Skip to main content
Back to Sets, Relations & Functions
JEE Main 2024
Sets, Relations & Functions
Sets and Relations
Easy

Question

Let A={1,2,3,,100}A=\{1,2,3, \ldots \ldots \ldots \ldots, 100\}. Let RR be a relation on A\mathrm{A} defined by (x,y)R(x, y) \in R if and only if 2x=3y2 x=3 y. Let R1R_1 be a symmetric relation on AA such that RR1R \subset R_1 and the number of elements in R1R_1 is n\mathrm{n}. Then, the minimum value of n\mathrm{n} is _________.

Answer: 3

Solution

Key Concepts and Formulas

  • Symmetric Relation: A relation R1R_1 on a set AA is symmetric if for every (x,y)R1(x,y) \in R_1, it must also be true that (y,x)R1(y,x) \in R_1.
  • Minimum Symmetric Relation: The smallest symmetric relation R1R_1 containing a given relation RR is formed by taking all elements of RR and adding the reverse of each element (x,y)R(x,y) \in R that is not already in RR. This can be expressed as R1=R{(y,x)(x,y)R}R_1 = R \cup \{(y,x) \mid (x,y) \in R\}.
  • Cardinality of Union: For any two sets PP and QQ, the number of elements in their union is given by PQ=P+QPQ|P \cup Q| = |P| + |Q| - |P \cap Q|.

Step-by-Step Solution

Step 1: Determine the elements of the relation RR. The set is A={1,2,3,,100}A = \{1, 2, 3, \ldots, 100\}. The relation RR is defined by (x,y)R(x, y) \in R if and only if 2x=3y2x = 3y, where x,yAx, y \in A. From 2x=3y2x = 3y, we can deduce that xx must be a multiple of 3 and yy must be a multiple of 2. Let x=3kx = 3k for some integer kk. Substituting this into the equation gives 2(3k)=3y2(3k) = 3y, which simplifies to 6k=3y6k = 3y, so y=2ky = 2k. Now we need to ensure that xx and yy are within the set AA. For xx: 1x100    13k1001 \le x \le 100 \implies 1 \le 3k \le 100. Dividing by 3, we get 13k1003\frac{1}{3} \le k \le \frac{100}{3}, so 0.33k33.330.33\ldots \le k \le 33.33\ldots. Since kk must be an integer, 1k331 \le k \le 33. For yy: 1y100    12k1001 \le y \le 100 \implies 1 \le 2k \le 100. Dividing by 2, we get 12k50\frac{1}{2} \le k \le 50, so 0.5k500.5 \le k \le 50. For both conditions to be met, kk must be an integer such that 1k331 \le k \le 33. Thus, the elements of RR are of the form (3k,2k)(3k, 2k) for k=1,2,,33k = 1, 2, \ldots, 33. The number of elements in RR is n(R)=33n(R) = 33. The elements of RR are: (3,2),(6,4),(9,6),,(99,66)(3,2), (6,4), (9,6), \ldots, (99,66).

Step 2: Identify elements that would make R1R_1 symmetric. We are looking for a symmetric relation R1R_1 such that RR1R \subset R_1 and n(R1)n(R_1) is minimized. The minimum symmetric relation R1R_1 is formed by RRR \cup R', where R={(y,x)(x,y)R}R' = \{(y,x) \mid (x,y) \in R\}. The number of elements in R1R_1 is n(R1)=n(RR)=n(R)+n(R)n(RR)n(R_1) = n(R \cup R') = n(R) + n(R') - n(R \cap R'). Since RR' is formed by reversing all pairs in RR, n(R)=n(R)=33n(R') = n(R) = 33. We need to find n(RR)n(R \cap R'), which represents the number of pairs (x,y)R(x,y) \in R such that (y,x)(y,x) is also in RR.

Let's consider a pair (x,y)R(x,y) \in R. This means 2x=3y2x = 3y. If (y,x)(y,x) is also in RR, then 2y=3x2y = 3x. We have the system of equations:

  1. 2x=3y2x = 3y
  2. 2y=3x2y = 3x

From equation (1), y=2x3y = \frac{2x}{3}. Substitute this into equation (2): 2(2x3)=3x2\left(\frac{2x}{3}\right) = 3x 4x3=3x\frac{4x}{3} = 3x 4x=9x4x = 9x 5x=05x = 0 x=0x = 0. Since xA={1,2,,100}x \in A = \{1, 2, \ldots, 100\}, xx cannot be 0. Therefore, there is no pair (x,y)R(x,y) \in R such that (y,x)R(y,x) \in R. This means RR=R \cap R' = \emptyset, so n(RR)=0n(R \cap R') = 0.

Also, we must check for pairs of the form (x,x)R(x,x) \in R. If (x,x)R(x,x) \in R, then 2x=3x2x = 3x, which implies x=0x=0. Since 0A0 \notin A, there are no such pairs in RR.

Step 3: Calculate the minimum number of elements in R1R_1. Using the formula for the cardinality of the union: n(R1)=n(R)+n(R)n(RR)n(R_1) = n(R) + n(R') - n(R \cap R') We found n(R)=33n(R) = 33, n(R)=33n(R') = 33, and n(RR)=0n(R \cap R') = 0. So, n(R1)=33+330=66n(R_1) = 33 + 33 - 0 = 66. The number of elements in R1R_1 is nn. Therefore, the minimum value of nn is 66.

Common Mistakes & Tips

  • Overlooking domain constraints: Ensure that all elements derived for xx and yy are within the given set AA. This is crucial for correctly determining n(R)n(R).
  • Assuming symmetry for all pairs: Do not assume that if (x,y)R(x,y) \in R, then (y,x)(y,x) is automatically in RR. Always verify the symmetry condition for the specific relation.
  • Forgetting RRR \cap R': While in this problem RRR \cap R' is empty, in general, it's important to calculate it. Pairs (x,x)R(x,x) \in R and pairs (x,y)R(x,y) \in R where (y,x)(y,x) is also in RR contribute to n(RR)n(R \cap R').

Summary We first identified the elements of the relation RR by solving the equation 2x=3y2x=3y under the constraint x,y{1,2,,100}x, y \in \{1, 2, \ldots, 100\}. This led to R={(3k,2k)k=1,,33}R = \{(3k, 2k) \mid k=1, \ldots, 33\}, giving n(R)=33n(R)=33. We then analyzed the symmetry property. By solving the system 2x=3y2x=3y and 2y=3x2y=3x, we found that no pair (x,y)R(x,y) \in R has its reverse (y,x)(y,x) also in RR, meaning RR=R \cap R' = \emptyset. The minimum symmetric relation R1R_1 containing RR is RRR \cup R', and its size is n(R1)=n(R)+n(R)n(RR)=33+330=66n(R_1) = n(R) + n(R') - n(R \cap R') = 33 + 33 - 0 = 66.

The final answer is 66\boxed{66}.

Practice More Sets, Relations & Functions Questions

View All Questions