Skip to main content
Back to Sets, Relations & Functions
JEE Main 2022
Sets, Relations & Functions
Sets and Relations
Medium

Question

Let the relations R1R_1 and R2R_2 on the set X={1,2,3,,20}X=\{1,2,3, \ldots, 20\} be given by R1={(x,y):2x3y=2}R_1=\{(x, y): 2 x-3 y=2\} and R2={(x,y):5x+4y=0}R_2=\{(x, y):-5 x+4 y=0\}. If MM and NN be the minimum number of elements required to be added in R1R_1 and R2R_2, respectively, in order to make the relations symmetric, then M+NM+N equals

Options

Solution

Key Concepts and Formulas

  • Symmetric Relation: A relation RR on a set XX is symmetric if for every (x,y)R(x, y) \in R, it is also true that (y,x)R(y, x) \in R.
  • Minimum Additions for Symmetry: To make a relation symmetric, for every pair (x,y)R(x, y) \in R where (y,x)R(y, x) \notin R, we must add (y,x)(y, x) to the relation. The minimum number of elements to be added is the count of such missing inverse pairs. Pairs of the form (x,x)(x, x) are always symmetric.

Step-by-Step Solution

Step 1: Understanding the Problem and the Set

We are given a set X={1,2,3,,20}X = \{1, 2, 3, \ldots, 20\}. Two relations, R1R_1 and R2R_2, are defined on XX:

  1. R1={(x,y):2x3y=2}R_1 = \{(x, y) : 2x - 3y = 2\}
  2. R2={(x,y):5x+4y=0}R_2 = \{(x, y) : -5x + 4y = 0\}

We need to find MM, the minimum number of elements to add to R1R_1 to make it symmetric, and NN, the minimum number of elements to add to R2R_2 to make it symmetric. Our final goal is to compute M+NM+N.

Step 2: Analyzing Relation R1R_1 and Calculating MM

The relation R1R_1 is defined by 2x3y=22x - 3y = 2. We need to find pairs (x,y)(x, y) where x,y{1,2,,20}x, y \in \{1, 2, \ldots, 20\}. Rearranging the equation for xx: 2x=3y+22x = 3y + 2. Since 2x2x is even, 3y+23y + 2 must be even. This implies 3y3y must be even, which means yy must be an even number. We test even values of yy from 2 to 20:

  • If y=2y=2: 2x=3(2)+2=8    x=42x = 3(2) + 2 = 8 \implies x = 4. Pair: (4,2)(4, 2). Both 4,2X4, 2 \in X.
  • If y=4y=4: 2x=3(4)+2=14    x=72x = 3(4) + 2 = 14 \implies x = 7. Pair: (7,4)(7, 4). Both 7,4X7, 4 \in X.
  • If y=6y=6: 2x=3(6)+2=20    x=102x = 3(6) + 2 = 20 \implies x = 10. Pair: (10,6)(10, 6). Both 10,6X10, 6 \in X.
  • If y=8y=8: 2x=3(8)+2=26    x=132x = 3(8) + 2 = 26 \implies x = 13. Pair: (13,8)(13, 8). Both 13,8X13, 8 \in X.
  • If y=10y=10: 2x=3(10)+2=32    x=162x = 3(10) + 2 = 32 \implies x = 16. Pair: (16,10)(16, 10). Both 16,10X16, 10 \in X.
  • If y=12y=12: 2x=3(12)+2=38    x=192x = 3(12) + 2 = 38 \implies x = 19. Pair: (19,12)(19, 12). Both 19,12X19, 12 \in X.
  • If y=14y=14: 2x=3(14)+2=44    x=222x = 3(14) + 2 = 44 \implies x = 22. 22X22 \notin X, so we stop.

The elements of R1R_1 are {(4,2),(7,4),(10,6),(13,8),(16,10),(19,12)}\{(4, 2), (7, 4), (10, 6), (13, 8), (16, 10), (19, 12)\}. For R1R_1 to be symmetric, for each (x,y)R1(x, y) \in R_1, we must have (y,x)R1(y, x) \in R_1. Let's check the inverse pairs:

  • For (4,2)(4, 2), is (2,4)R1(2, 4) \in R_1? 2(2)3(4)=412=822(2) - 3(4) = 4 - 12 = -8 \neq 2. No.
  • For (7,4)(7, 4), is (4,7)R1(4, 7) \in R_1? 2(4)3(7)=821=1322(4) - 3(7) = 8 - 21 = -13 \neq 2. No.
  • For (10,6)(10, 6), is (6,10)R1(6, 10) \in R_1? 2(6)3(10)=1230=1822(6) - 3(10) = 12 - 30 = -18 \neq 2. No.
  • For (13,8)(13, 8), is (8,13)R1(8, 13) \in R_1? 2(8)3(13)=1639=2322(8) - 3(13) = 16 - 39 = -23 \neq 2. No.
  • For (16,10)(16, 10), is (10,16)R1(10, 16) \in R_1? 2(10)3(16)=2048=2822(10) - 3(16) = 20 - 48 = -28 \neq 2. No.
  • For (19,12)(19, 12), is (12,19)R1(12, 19) \in R_1? 2(12)3(19)=2457=3322(12) - 3(19) = 24 - 57 = -33 \neq 2. No.

None of the inverse pairs are present in R1R_1. All elements in these inverse pairs are within XX. Since there are 6 pairs in R1R_1, and none of their inverses are present, we need to add 6 elements to make R1R_1 symmetric. Thus, M=6M = 6.

Step 3: Analyzing Relation R2R_2 and Calculating NN

The relation R2R_2 is defined by 5x+4y=0-5x + 4y = 0. We need to find pairs (x,y)(x, y) where x,y{1,2,,20}x, y \in \{1, 2, \ldots, 20\}. Rearranging the equation: 4y=5x4y = 5x. This implies 5x5x must be a multiple of 4. Since 5 and 4 are coprime, xx must be a multiple of 4. Also, y=5x4y = \frac{5x}{4}. Since y20y \le 20, we have 5x420    5x80    x16\frac{5x}{4} \le 20 \implies 5x \le 80 \implies x \le 16. We test multiples of 4 for xx from 4 to 16:

  • If x=4x=4: 4y=5(4)=20    y=54y = 5(4) = 20 \implies y = 5. Pair: (4,5)(4, 5). Both 4,5X4, 5 \in X.
  • If x=8x=8: 4y=5(8)=40    y=104y = 5(8) = 40 \implies y = 10. Pair: (8,10)(8, 10). Both 8,10X8, 10 \in X.
  • If x=12x=12: 4y=5(12)=60    y=154y = 5(12) = 60 \implies y = 15. Pair: (12,15)(12, 15). Both 12,15X12, 15 \in X.
  • If x=16x=16: 4y=5(16)=80    y=204y = 5(16) = 80 \implies y = 20. Pair: (16,20)(16, 20). Both 16,20X16, 20 \in X.
  • If x=20x=20: 4y=5(20)=100    y=254y = 5(20) = 100 \implies y = 25. 25X25 \notin X, so we stop.

The elements of R2R_2 are {(4,5),(8,10),(12,15),(16,20)}\{(4, 5), (8, 10), (12, 15), (16, 20)\}. For R2R_2 to be symmetric, for each (x,y)R2(x, y) \in R_2, we must have (y,x)R2(y, x) \in R_2. Let's check the inverse pairs:

  • For (4,5)(4, 5), is (5,4)R2(5, 4) \in R_2? 5(5)+4(4)=25+16=90-5(5) + 4(4) = -25 + 16 = -9 \neq 0. No.
  • For (8,10)(8, 10), is (10,8)R2(10, 8) \in R_2? 5(10)+4(8)=50+32=180-5(10) + 4(8) = -50 + 32 = -18 \neq 0. No.
  • For (12,15)(12, 15), is (15,12)R2(15, 12) \in R_2? 5(15)+4(12)=75+48=270-5(15) + 4(12) = -75 + 48 = -27 \neq 0. No.
  • For (16,20)(16, 20), is (20,16)R2(20, 16) \in R_2? 5(20)+4(16)=100+64=360-5(20) + 4(16) = -100 + 64 = -36 \neq 0. No.

None of the inverse pairs are present in R2R_2. All elements in these inverse pairs are within XX. Since there are 4 pairs in R2R_2, and none of their inverses are present, we need to add 4 elements to make R2R_2 symmetric. Thus, N=4N = 4.

Step 4: Calculating M+NM+N

We have found M=6M = 6 and N=4N = 4. The required sum is M+N=6+4=10M+N = 6 + 4 = 10.

Common Mistakes & Tips

  • Forgetting the Set Constraint: Always ensure that both elements of a pair (x,y)(x, y) and its inverse (y,x)(y, x) belong to the given set XX.
  • Ignoring (x,x)(x,x) Pairs: Pairs of the form (x,x)(x,x) are inherently symmetric and do not require any additions. In this problem, neither R1R_1 nor R2R_2 contained any such pairs.
  • Algebraic Errors: Double-check the rearrangement of equations and the arithmetic when finding pairs and their inverses.

Summary

We first identified all the pairs belonging to relations R1R_1 and R2R_2 by satisfying their respective equations and the set constraint X={1,2,,20}X=\{1, 2, \ldots, 20\}. For each relation, we then checked if the inverse of every existing pair was also present in the relation. The number of missing inverse pairs for R1R_1 gives MM, and for R2R_2 gives NN. We found R1R_1 to have 6 pairs and R2R_2 to have 4 pairs, none of whose inverses were present in their respective relations. Therefore, M=6M=6 and N=4N=4, leading to M+N=10M+N=10.

The final answer is 10\boxed{10}.

Practice More Sets, Relations & Functions Questions

View All Questions